News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:"Six strikes" Internet warning system will come to US thi... by sp332 on Tuesday September 11, 2012 @01:06PM (#4506526)
The perils are mainly getting sued for copyright infringement. I'm all for copyright even if the current scheme is insane.

The legal problem is that no one can tell if the content is authorized or not. Maybe it's fair use, maybe I legitimately bought it, or maybe it's similar enough to another video that the bot got confused. Sending a warning is just a way to sidestep the judicial oversight that a legitimate legal action would entail.

Re:"Six strikes" Internet warning system will come to US thi... by jiggy2011 on Tuesday September 11, 2012 @06:31PM (#4508091)
I think the way this works in practise is not that it's monitored by ISPs at the source but rather it's monitored at the other end of the connection.

What happens is that the copyright holder, or some company working on their behalf goes and connects to a torrent swarm.

Once they are connected to the swarm , they download the file in order to verify that it is in fact copyrighted material. At that point they can log any attempts by other peers to connect to them and download material from them since the clients have no real way of telling who is a normal peer and who is involved in monitoring.

They get a big list of IP addresses and times, from the IP they can figure out who the ISP is. They can then ask the ISP to release records for which subscriber was assigned that particular IP address at that time and bingo they have found the infringer.

Re:"Six strikes" Internet warning system will come to US thi... by thaumasiotes on Tuesday September 11, 2012 @10:50PM (#4508870)
two points:

- I believe there's some sort of issue with the approach where they log people who download from them, because if you download a copyrighted file being willfully shared by the copyright holder you haven't infringed.

- I once downloaded one song from a "500 greatest hits" type torrent. Some time later, my university sent me a notice that they'd received a complaint that I'd illegally downloaded Hotel California (I hadn't). Hotel California wasn't even adjacent in the torrent to the song I did download; there were never any attempts to get all or part of it. So the detection system (at that time, at least) would seem to leave something to be desired.

Re:"Six strikes" Internet warning system will come to US thi... by jiggy2011 on Wednesday September 12, 2012 @12:17AM (#4509117)
I'd be amazed if #1 washed in court. By connecting to a swarm that is distributing copyrighted works without the copyright holder's consent you've demonstrated that you have intent to pirate the material. Besides even if you argued that you got a few chunks of the file from the copyright holder (or a party acting on their behalf) you will have downloaded other chunks from others (and possibly uploaded some of them back to the rights holder).

#2 I'd put down to a random bureaucratic fuckup rather than an inherent issue with the detection system. I know a couple of people who've had letters from their ISPs regards these activities and they have said that they were accurate.

Re:"Six strikes" Internet warning system will come to US thi... by ninnypants on Tuesday September 11, 2012 @04:06PM (#4507540)
I've been wondering how they would tell if it was legitimate as well. There are some easy checks that would indicate that it was coming from a legal source like the site it's coming from, but what if I'm downloading from my dropbox account or from a remote backup. How is legitimacy determined then. Do I just get a strike for completely legal activity.
Re:"Six strikes" Internet warning system will come to US thi... by wmf on Tuesday September 11, 2012 @04:20PM (#4507596)
In general, Hollywood movies are not legitimately available over any P2P system. P2P monitoring companies can't see your Dropbox, so that's not a concern. Also, you can challenge strikes if you think they're in error.
Re:"Six strikes" Internet warning system will come to US thi... by gergles on Tuesday September 11, 2012 @06:46PM (#4508158)
You can challenge strikes by paying $35 and you can only challenge one strike for "you misidentified me, you muppets" (even if the "independent board" finds in your favor!!)

Seems about as fair as we'd expect from the MAFIAA to me.

(see http://www.copyrightinformation.org/sites/default/files/Momo... [sic] - "attachment C", specifically 4.1.6 )

Re:"Six strikes" Internet warning system will come to US thi... by ninnypants on Tuesday September 11, 2012 @05:27PM (#4507864)
"At that point, all of the tools that the content owners and the ISPs have at their disposal are there,"

Seems like ISPs will be scanning as well not just P2P monitors, that's why I wonder about something like dropbox or ftp setting it off.

Re:"Six strikes" Internet warning system will come to US thi... by sp332 on Tuesday September 11, 2012 @11:29PM (#4508996)
Actually ISPs won't be scanning for this. Even if they wanted to (which they don't), they don't have the databases of content to match traffic against. They wait for content owners to complain about a specific IP address, and the ISP delivers the complaint to the person behind that address. The identity of the user is pretty much never revealed to the content owner unless they get a court order.