Re:A Grace Blackwell AI Supercomputer on Your Desk – Nvidia ...
by throwaway48476 on Thursday August 28, 2025 @09:03AM
(#45051674)
Its not priced in a linear way wrt to bom cost.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:A Grace Blackwell AI Supercomputer on Your Desk – Nvidia ...
by aurareturn on Thursday August 28, 2025 @10:03AM
(#45052303)
That's because memory channels cost money. Memory controllers are more complex. Lastly, chips that can make use of high bandwidth VRAM are both of the above.
Memory chips are a commodity, that I agree. Though HBM is trending towards not being a commodity.
Re:A Grace Blackwell AI Supercomputer on Your Desk – Nvidia ...
by throwaway48476 on Thursday August 28, 2025 @11:56AM
(#45053778)
Memory controllers are die area. mm2 die space is linear bom cost.
DRAM+mm2 bom will have a different slope to just DRAM bom but still basically linear. Nonlinear pricing is pure market segmentation.
Re:A Grace Blackwell AI Supercomputer on Your Desk – Nvidia ...
by aurareturn on Thursday August 28, 2025 @11:49PM
(#45059947)
Memory controllers are die area. mm2 die space is linear bom cost.
Ignoring the design and platform support that comes with higher bandwidth memory controllers.
Re:A Grace Blackwell AI Supercomputer on Your Desk – Nvidia ...
by throwaway48476 on Friday August 29, 2025 @02:22AM
(#45060831)
And this is not also linear or fixed cost, why?
I don't think you know how industry pricing works. Wafers have a price, double mm2, double the price of chip in bom.
Re:A Grace Blackwell AI Supercomputer on Your Desk – Nvidia ...
by aurareturn on Friday August 29, 2025 @09:00AM
(#45063542)
Yes. Bigger die size. More complex memory controller designs. More memory lanes. More software support for higher memory lanes. All adds up.
I'm explaining why despite memory being a commodity, high memory bandwidth VRAM cost is not cheap.
Re:A Grace Blackwell AI Supercomputer on Your Desk – Nvidia ...
by throwaway48476 on Friday August 29, 2025 @12:07PM
(#45065897)
Memory controllers are copy paste. It's not more complex.
It's more expensive in a linear way wrt bom.