News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:We Are Now One Year Away From Global Riots, Complex Syste... by pyre on Monday September 10, 2012 @10:34PM (#4503464)
I wonder how much bad the drought would have been had we done something like cut back on livestock farming. If all of the water that goes towards growing livestock feed + keeping the animals watered instead went directly to plants grown for human consumption, would it have still been as bad?
Re:We Are Now One Year Away From Global Riots, Complex Syste... by bryanlarsen on Monday September 10, 2012 @10:54PM (#4503516)
Livestock farming is crucial to keeping grain prices stable. Human demand for calories is relatively constant, for obvious reasons, but only accounts for a small majority of grain demand in normal years. The remainder is consumed by animals and by industrial processes.

When grain gets expensive, feeding animals becomes expensive. Raising them becomes unprofitable, so farmers dump their animals onto the market which 1) lowers the price of meat 2) makes a large number of meat calories available for human consumption when they are needed most and 3) reduces the demand for grain, dampening the price rise for grain.

This effect has mostly replaced the need for the long-term grain storage that countries used to do.

So why isn't working now? One word: ethanol. President Obama could single-handedly stop the current food crisis by eliminating or suspending ethanol subsidies and mandates.

Re:We Are Now One Year Away From Global Riots, Complex Syste... by pyre on Monday September 10, 2012 @11:51PM (#4503679)

  > The remainder is consumed by animals and by
  > industrial processes.
Grain raised for livestock use is only for livestock use. It's not like "corn" is all the same thing. The corn that is used for livestock is not the same corn that you buy at the store (on the cob or in a can). It's tasteless, and so far as I know, not desirable for human consumption. You can't treat all of the corn produced as usable for all uses that corn is put towards.

Also, if livestock is what regulates the grain market, then why do grain-producers get such large (non-ethanol-related) subsidies?

Re:We Are Now One Year Away From Global Riots, Complex Syste... by bryanlarsen on Tuesday September 11, 2012 @07:29AM (#4504830)
"The corn that is used for livestock is not the same corn that you buy at the store (on the cob or in a can). It's tasteless, and so far as I know, not desirable for human consumption"

No, but it is suitable for turning into meal, which is how corn is consumed in the third world, or into HFCS which is how corn is consumed in the first world.

For other grains, it mostly works in the other direction in normal years. For example, a farmer may try to grow wheat suitable for bread, but it rains while the crop is in windrow, making it unsuitable for bread due to its low protein content. It's graded as "feed" and fed to animals in a normal year. However, you can still make bread from it, it just doesn't rise as well.

"why do grain-producers get such large (non-ethanol-related) subsidies?" Because farmer's causes are sympathetic to voters for various different reasons. (historical attachment, enjoyment of low food prices, stereotyping of farmers as close to the land, lower populations in rural districts, and many others)

Re:We Are Now One Year Away From Global Riots, Complex Syste... by evgen on Tuesday September 11, 2012 @12:43AM (#4503849)
The varieties of corn produced for each use are different but they are completely fungible. If livestock is culled due to higher feed costs from diminished production this year then farmers will plant more human-edible corn next year (along with more soybeans and other alternative crops) because there is going to be less demand for dent corn to feed the livestock. The system balances itself.
Re:We Are Now One Year Away From Global Riots, Complex Syste... by lifeguard on Monday September 10, 2012 @11:23PM (#4503596)
Bankers drove up food prices. Do more research. Ethanol is a red herring.
Re:We Are Now One Year Away From Global Riots, Complex Syste... by Daniel_Newby on Monday September 10, 2012 @11:06PM (#4503545)
Cutting ethanol would just delay the Malthusian crisis.
Re:We Are Now One Year Away From Global Riots, Complex Syste... by ars on Tuesday September 11, 2012 @12:19AM (#4503785)
A: Is that a bad thing?

B: What Malthusian crisis? He's been thoroughly discredited.

C: That's like saying eating will delay death. It will, just keep on delaying it every day.

Re:We Are Now One Year Away From Global Riots, Complex Syste... by Daniel_Newby on Tuesday September 11, 2012 @10:48AM (#4505669)
How can Malthus be discredited? He said that the population tends to grow to the limit of the food supply, and then suffer periodic famine as the weather fluctuates. This is an obvious truth.

It matters because subsistence living is probably not compatible with a high-tech society.

Re:We Are Now One Year Away From Global Riots, Complex Syste... by bryanlarsen on Tuesday September 11, 2012 @11:53AM (#4506103)
No, it's obviously wrong. Population does not grow to the limit of food supply: food supply has increased dramatically in the first world over the last century, yet population growth has flatlined in most first world countries.
Re:We Are Now One Year Away From Global Riots, Complex Syste... by Daniel_Newby on Tuesday September 11, 2012 @03:00PM (#4507168)
Ah, you are talking about a momentary decrease in the rate during a time of enormous change.

In the long run, population grows to the limits of resources. Natural selection always selects for more descendants, and the population always hits the resource limits. The only alternative is for natural selection to cease operating.

Incidentally, population growth has not flatlined uniformly in First World countries. There are identifiable subgroups that have very high fecundity, and whose descendants are capable of eating any possible green revolution within a few centuries at the most.

Re:We Are Now One Year Away From Global Riots, Complex Syste... by bryanlarsen on Tuesday September 11, 2012 @04:53PM (#4507739)
The biggest population growth in history was accompanied by a green revolution that increased food production even faster. So example indicates that you're likely wrong.

We're now in an age where energy is cheap, and energy can be converted to food relatively easily. The amount of energy required to feed the entire world is now a small fraction of total world energy production. The fact that we don't do it this way is only because food is even cheaper than energy.

And yes, our oil energy supplies are relatively constrained, but our alternative supplies (aka nuclear) are not.

So "any possible green revolution" is pretty darn big. If we wanted to, we could feed a trillion people using nuclear power lighting artificial greenhouses.

Re:We Are Now One Year Away From Global Riots, Complex Syste... by Daniel_Newby on Tuesday September 11, 2012 @07:52PM (#4508376)
Populations under natural selection grow exponentially in the presence of sufficient food. If we have 100,000 times more food capacity than we need, and the population doubling time is a very slow 100 years, then we hit the Malthusian limit in 1,700 years. Exponential growth is a powerful process.

This is the reason so many science fiction stories are set on a future Earth that is baking hot (industrial waste heat) and has fertility police that terminate unlicensed pregnancies. It's a simple extrapolation of current conditions.

Re:We Are Now One Year Away From Global Riots, Complex Syste... by ars on Wednesday September 12, 2012 @02:23AM (#4509400)
Malthus forgot something very basic: Unlike animals, Humans create their own resources, they don't just find them in the environment.

So it doesn't matter how many humans you have, there will always be enough resources.

Remember that from a physical point of view nothing can ever be destroyed. The only thing that happens is the atom moves from one place to another. With application of energy and brains, you can move that atom right back to where you want it.

Re:We Are Now One Year Away From Global Riots, Complex Syste... by Daniel_Newby on Wednesday September 12, 2012 @10:34AM (#4510844)
> Unlike animals, Humans create their own resources, they don't just find them in the environment.

No. There are hard limits to resources, but exponential growth curves have no upper bounds.

For example, humans could disassemble all the planets in the Solar system and turn them into space stations, increasing the habitable area by a factor of a trillion trillion. For a population doubling time of 20 years, the new territory will be filled up in a few thousand years. If we convert all the solid matter in the galaxy into space stations, the galaxy will hit the Malthusian limit within a few million years. The only solution to an exponential growth curve is starvation or artificial selection.

Re:We Are Now One Year Away From Global Riots, Complex Syste... by Spooky23 on Monday September 10, 2012 @10:49PM (#4503502)
In the US, that happened. Low quality beef is cheap right now -- my supermarket is selling Select grade tenderloin for US $5.99/lb, becuase ranchers are dumping livestock on the market.

In a few months, that same cut of beef will be 250-400% higher.

Re:We Are Now One Year Away From Global Riots, Complex Syste... by Gustomaximus on Monday September 10, 2012 @11:26PM (#4503605)
I know in Australia much of the grazing land will not support growing crops. And it is also worth considering popular crops too that use significant amounts of water like rice and cotton.

So while livestock do account for much water use, it's not a simple switch to grains and the world will be rainbows.

Re:We Are Now One Year Away From Global Riots, Complex Syste... by pyre on Tuesday September 11, 2012 @12:05AM (#4503730)

  > I know in Australia much of the grazing land will
  > not support growing crops.
I realize that some of the land used for livestock won't switch to farmland, but I'm not talking about reclaiming land, I'm talking about freshwater shortage.

  > And it is also worth considering popular crops too that
  > use significant amounts of water like rice and cotton.
I don't know about cotton, but I don't know of anyone growing rice in the midwestern United States. So far as I know, the only rice grown in the United States is in California, where they pump the water out of mountains (the Sierras). I don't believe that they are experiencing issues right now.

  > So while livestock do account for much water use, it's not a
  > simple switch to grains and the world will be rainbows.
It's more about freshwater usage. If farmers are having issues keeping their crops watered, would it make sense to pour more water into livestock (and the grains that go to feed them) with a lower rate of return on that water, or to pour it into the grains, where the yield is higher?

Also, comments like "and the world will be rainbows" are a little condescending.