It matters because subsistence living is probably not compatible with a high-tech society.
In the long run, population grows to the limits of resources. Natural selection always selects for more descendants, and the population always hits the resource limits. The only alternative is for natural selection to cease operating.
Incidentally, population growth has not flatlined uniformly in First World countries. There are identifiable subgroups that have very high fecundity, and whose descendants are capable of eating any possible green revolution within a few centuries at the most.
We're now in an age where energy is cheap, and energy can be converted to food relatively easily. The amount of energy required to feed the entire world is now a small fraction of total world energy production. The fact that we don't do it this way is only because food is even cheaper than energy.
And yes, our oil energy supplies are relatively constrained, but our alternative supplies (aka nuclear) are not.
So "any possible green revolution" is pretty darn big. If we wanted to, we could feed a trillion people using nuclear power lighting artificial greenhouses.
This is the reason so many science fiction stories are set on a future Earth that is baking hot (industrial waste heat) and has fertility police that terminate unlicensed pregnancies. It's a simple extrapolation of current conditions.
So it doesn't matter how many humans you have, there will always be enough resources.
Remember that from a physical point of view nothing can ever be destroyed. The only thing that happens is the atom moves from one place to another. With application of energy and brains, you can move that atom right back to where you want it.
No. There are hard limits to resources, but exponential growth curves have no upper bounds.
For example, humans could disassemble all the planets in the Solar system and turn them into space stations, increasing the habitable area by a factor of a trillion trillion. For a population doubling time of 20 years, the new territory will be filled up in a few thousand years. If we convert all the solid matter in the galaxy into space stations, the galaxy will hit the Malthusian limit within a few million years. The only solution to an exponential growth curve is starvation or artificial selection.
B: What Malthusian crisis? He's been thoroughly discredited.
C: That's like saying eating will delay death. It will, just keep on delaying it every day.