For what it's worth, I weigh about what you do (a bit more, sigh), and used a sized-B Aeron (which should've been too small) at work and a Steelcase Leap at home, and didn't ever have any issues with breakage. I also found that regular $100-$200 office chairs would break yearly or so, so I think we must put comparable strain on our chairs.
I will also note that you can find Aerons for about half-price used and the Steelcase Leap for an even greater discount (as it is not as well known.) I paid $350 for my current Steelcase Leap, and that included delivery (of myself and the chair) right to my doorstep in the nice older gentleman's Mercedes, complete with heated seats.
Thanks for your comments (and everyone below). I've just broken my home office chair about a week ago, so I might start looking with your suggestions in mind.
You have more freedom at home. Please consider a standing desk.
Be sure to take a look at the Embody.
Size C Aerons are pretty robust and should be reasonable for 6'6" 275-300#. Plus, if anything breaks, you can get spare parts and just fix the broken part, so a $800 Aeron ends up not being as expensive as a $250 chair every couple years. There's also a 12 year warranty if you buy new (or buy used for $300 or so instead)
Have you considered just calling Herman Miller or Steelcase? They should be able to give you a definitive answer on the weight limits for their chairs.
Re:Five Best Office Chairs
by MartinCron on Sunday September 09, 2012 @09:08PM
(#4497769)
Steelcase makes some great stuff. I have some vintage steelcase chairs that could easily handle someone large and will last forever.
Re:Five Best Office Chairs
by jaggederest on Sunday September 09, 2012 @09:54PM
(#4497899)
I had one of their chairs, the gas cylinder went out, and nobody could or would fix it. I was disappointed.
Re:Five Best Office Chairs
by MartinCron on Monday September 10, 2012 @12:13AM
(#4498269)
That is a shame. The chairs I have are from the 1960s and have no moving parts. I expect them to far outlive me.
Perhaps their quality has gone downhill over the decades.
That being said, at my last work there was a significant remodeling of the office space by a designer. As in, the techboys roll their eyes type designer. She was there to customise our area, as long as we fitted into the grand design. So we had these chairs that fit into the grand design. Attractive chairs. But terrible for sitting in, and the seat pan was way too low. I cited my height and kept my old chair. "But it doesn't fit in with the design!" was followed with "We'll get you cushions!" (which were never seen...). Over time, I noticed other staff were taking my lead and going with chairs that worked for them rather than chairs that looked good. Long story short, I like your 'all chairs must be black' idea, it's far better than making all chairs the same.