While we agree on this point, I feel that this is bandied about a little too liberally. I love comforts and toys as much as the next, but this has been the general progression of the above argument at my current company :
1. "GeekDesks cost *nothing* next to a developer salary" : GeekDesk acquired ($900 per)
2. "Ergonomic chairs cost *nothing* next to a developer's salary" : Steelcase Leap chairs acquired ($1k per)
3. "30 inch Dell UltraSharps cost *nothing* next to a developer's salary" : Dell UltraSharps acquired ($1.2k per)
4. "New machines cost *nothing* next to a developer's salary" : Retina MBP's acquired ($2.2k per)
etc.
I am not arguing that the above were all frivolous expenses (geekdesk is worth every penny, whereas the jury is out on a 30 inch display), just that the argument has potential for being applied very liberally.When compounded with other perks such as paid conferences, travel expenses (hotels etc), office meals and books, the costs of maintaining an office can rapidly spiral upwards.
That being said, at my last work there was a significant remodeling of the office space by a designer. As in, the techboys roll their eyes type designer. She was there to customise our area, as long as we fitted into the grand design. So we had these chairs that fit into the grand design. Attractive chairs. But terrible for sitting in, and the seat pan was way too low. I cited my height and kept my old chair. "But it doesn't fit in with the design!" was followed with "We'll get you cushions!" (which were never seen...). Over time, I noticed other staff were taking my lead and going with chairs that worked for them rather than chairs that looked good. Long story short, I like your 'all chairs must be black' idea, it's far better than making all chairs the same.
I will also note that you can find Aerons for about half-price used and the Steelcase Leap for an even greater discount (as it is not as well known.) I paid $350 for my current Steelcase Leap, and that included delivery (of myself and the chair) right to my doorstep in the nice older gentleman's Mercedes, complete with heated seats.
Perhaps their quality has gone downhill over the decades.
At that point, it is vital that you remember two things:
First, chairs are cheap compared to salaries.
Second, an inflexible policy is an impediment to working at your company.
Don't set a policy like "We buy Aeron for everybody." If you have an esthetic issue (don't laugh, some companies do, I've worked at one) make the policy "All chairs are black". Pretty much every chair can be ordered in black, and nobody outside your company will ever notice a chair that they someone is using at their desk.