News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:From Linux to OSX - 1 Year Later by fsniper on Sunday September 09, 2012 @06:19PM (#4497227)
I'm a hardcore Linux user, a sysadmin, developer of some kinds and an humble desktop user. For some IOS projects I have to use an hackintosh.

The experience is - in one word - disgusting. It lacks common denominator keyboard shortcuts and keyboard bindings. It lacks sane default simple applications like a decent terminal emulator. ( Yes Windows lacks is too). unavailability of a great package manager - all of us knows it, homebrew or macports doesn't cut it - makes me vomit. Unfamiliar key bindings makes me think twice or thrice before typing , "Which key should I use for this? Apple or Option? How can I skip to end of line? Why I'm at end of file now?" Also some desktop choices are not ok for my liking; switching to full height windows instead of full screen windows with the maximize button? Why on earth I would opt-in for loosing screen real estate? So many details.

Most of the time I can't help myself to stop restarting into Linux. I get slower and distracted. I have to install Mozilla Stack (Thunderbird and Firefox).

This may be only me but, I hate OsX. And I'm not starting on the "wanna be walled garden-ness."

Re:From Linux to OSX - 1 Year Later by seiji on Sunday September 09, 2012 @06:31PM (#4497263)
decent terminal emulator. -- lie.

makes me vomit. -- visit your local physician.

Unfamiliar key bindings -- "Unfamiliar" by definition = "I don't know it" which isn't the OS's problem. You've gotta admit Command-C for copy being different than Control-C is brilliant.

switching to full height windows -- it's not a maximize button, it's an "optimal size" button. If your content is 500px wide, you don't need a 1000px wide window full of white space.

may be only me -- I'm pretty sure it is (check their stock).

Re:From Linux to OSX - 1 Year Later by randall on Sunday September 09, 2012 @07:07PM (#4497385)
http://www.paulgraham.com/disagree.html

You're so close! Just put some respect in this and it'd be one of the best refutations i've seen on HN in ages.

Re:From Linux to OSX - 1 Year Later by seiji on Sunday September 09, 2012 @07:32PM (#4497456)
Respect would require increasing the word count. Hopefully the jump-right-in-and-comment formatting conveyed a half sense of playfulness and half irrational zealotry.

After all, mild humour is always more hilarious when fully explained.

Re:From Linux to OSX - 1 Year Later by fsniper on Sunday September 09, 2012 @07:15PM (#4497403)
Thank you randall. I lack the ability to down vote (for the seiji's comment) but this made my day. Thank you :)
Re:From Linux to OSX - 1 Year Later by fsniper on Sunday September 09, 2012 @06:57PM (#4497360)
Terminal as a decent terminal emulator? I believe you are referring to iTerm2 but that's not the default.

unfamiliar key bindings, look for any other keyboard except OsX ones and show me the apple or the option or the command keys then I will back.

For the "Optimal Size button", the underlying operation does not account for the contents width, it only accounts for the desktop height.

The world is not running on OsX or Apple hardware. They have a decent userbase but not the whole computer users are using one.

Re:From Linux to OSX - 1 Year Later by pooriaazimi on Sunday September 09, 2012 @07:04PM (#4497379)
1. Terminal.app is a very good app. I switched to iTerm 2 a while back, but only because of a few minor features that I could've lived without. What are your problems?

2 & 4. You don't run a Hackintosh and expect it to work. If you want OS X, you buy a Mac. And all Macs (except the Mini) come with standard Apple keyboard.

3. I'm not sure what you're talking about. There's no "magic" algorithm that all apps use. Each app can use its own "algorithm" and can account for screen width as well. Just because Finder.app (most of the time) just grows the height doesn't mean all apps should do it, or are doing it.

Re:From Linux to OSX - 1 Year Later by fsniper on Sunday September 09, 2012 @07:11PM (#4497397)
Terminal app is a sufficient terminal emulator. But it lacks most of decent options. Can you split windows? Use tabs? Can you change color profiles? May be so many simple decent ap choices are lacking from it. Also I'm not even talking about the lack of simple Terminal emulation modes. I told you I'm a system administrator and I live in terminals. So Terminal.app is not cutting for me.

What's wrong with a Hackintosh other then legal and ethics issues if it's running well? I used Apple hardware and my criticisms were the same.

and for the 3, If every app is using it's own algorithm than I'm really on the wrong side of the issue. And my criticism lacks proper bases. I have to take it back. But again, why not a maximise button?

Re:From Linux to OSX - 1 Year Later by pooriaazimi on Sunday September 09, 2012 @07:30PM (#4497453)
Terminal has tabs (had it since early 00's).

The lack of split panes was what made me switch to iTerm. I don't use it that often, but it's a "nice to have" feature. Terminal.app has split panes, but it's not "two sessions, side-by-side", rather "different windows into the same session", which I personally don't like much.

And you're right. You can't change the color profile like http://kde-look.org/content/show.php?content=86353 , which might be a bummer for some one like you (you can change the 16 ANSI colors to look less horrible though!).

Why no maximize button? I don't know the reasoning behind that, but I don't miss it. Full screen apps are amazing (for one monitor scenarios), and OS X has a nice handy feature called "Hide Others" (Command-Option-H) that gives you a distraction-free experience without making the app ridiculously large (and showing you a million white pixels!)

[1] touches upon this issue and has good arguments for it.

But of course, power users need more "power", so I also use the wonderful Moom[2] which combined with "Zoom" and "Full Screen" fulfills 100% of my windowing needs.

[1]: http://www.macyourself.com/2011/02/06/why-doesnt-mac-os-xs-g...

[2]: http://manytricks.com/moom/

Re:From Linux to OSX - 1 Year Later by lloeki on Monday September 10, 2012 @05:25AM (#4498965)
> And you're right. You can't change the color profile like http://kde-look.org/content/show.php?content=86353

I may be missing something but I don't see how it's different from what has been available since Lion (and since Tiger with a SIMBL plugin). I've been using Zenburn and Solarized since what seems like forever.

Re:From Linux to OSX - 1 Year Later by da_n on Sunday September 09, 2012 @07:26PM (#4497440)
"Can you split windows?" - CMD+D splits vertically "Use tabs?" - yes, CMD+T "Can you change color profiles?" - yes "why not a maximise button?" - there is a separate fullscreen button now if you want maximize
Re:From Linux to OSX - 1 Year Later by lloeki on Monday September 10, 2012 @05:32AM (#4498979)
> "Can you split windows?" - CMD+D splits vertically

Nitpick: it's different. Cmd+D splits the current buffer in two allowing to view two parts of the same output without scrolling, whereas in iTerm2 it splits into two distinct buffers, each with its own shell.

I arguably prefer the Terminal.app feature, when I have the other one with window management like with Window Magnet, which happens to handle any window, not just what's inside the terminal (in which case I'd simply use vim or tmux splits)

Re:From Linux to OSX - 1 Year Later by jsz0 on Sunday September 09, 2012 @07:24PM (#4497432)
Can you split windows? Use tabs? Can you change color profiles?

Yes to all though you can only split windows horizontally. Terminal is a really good app. iTerm2 is great too but a little slower than Terminal in my experience.

Re:From Linux to OSX - 1 Year Later by fsniper on Sunday September 09, 2012 @07:27PM (#4497444)
I have to switch my os to check these. If you are right It's better than what I think about it.
Re:From Linux to OSX - 1 Year Later by seiji on Sunday September 09, 2012 @07:11PM (#4497395)
What now? I think your mind box may be severely out of alignment with the rest of the world. (It's not an unusual occurrence among extreme computer people.)

Four points. Four points only:

• Terminal.app is perfect. Except for the crashing.

• You can't honestly argue the command key is strange while the windows key isn't (which was a direct copy of "hey, Apple has their own key, why not us?" Also see: recycle bin versus trash can).

• The lil' green button adjusts for width but at max height (unless you are iTunes). It's up to each application to determine how the button should best destroy your viewing experience.

• Do you want to be the most popular or the best? Sugar water or make a difference in the world? Sounds like you may have a case of Bieber Fever.

Re:From Linux to OSX - 1 Year Later by fsniper on Sunday September 09, 2012 @07:21PM (#4497422)
Are you trying to be sarcastic?

- Terminal.app. If it's perfect what use has iTerm2?

- I'm not ok with windows key too. It has the same twisted mind after it. Also will be out of context but for the record I'm hating Turkey governments hate and movement against Turkish-Q keyboard layout.

- In this optimized button context, I was mistaken about it being a maximize button and it's underlying algorithm. I backed my criticism. But why be different and choose this strange button instead of maximize?

- I can't follow you here.

Re:From Linux to OSX - 1 Year Later by lloeki on Monday September 10, 2012 @05:17AM (#4498950)
> If it's perfect what use has iTerm2?

1. alternative 2. hardcore usage 3. opensource

BTW your precious iTerm2 does not handle ICC color profiles, whereas Terminal.app does, and on calibrated screens it shows.

Re:From Linux to OSX - 1 Year Later by vacri on Sunday September 09, 2012 @08:22PM (#4497627)
Windows has a perfectly serviceable array of shortcuts available on keyboard that don't have the custom Windows key. The 'windows key stuff' is mostly fluff.
Re:From Linux to OSX - 1 Year Later by msbarnett on Sunday September 09, 2012 @07:32PM (#4497457)
> unfamiliar key bindings, look for any other keyboard except OsX ones and show me the apple or the option or the command keys then I will back.

Huh? On any non-Apple keyboard, the alt keycode corresponds to Command, and the windows keycode corresponds to Option. Since their positions are usually reversed vs Apple keyboards, you can swap them around via the standard Keyboard preference panel.

Re:From Linux to OSX - 1 Year Later by chimeracoder on Sunday September 09, 2012 @08:40PM (#4497697)
The problem is that the Command key is also used to do some things that the Alt key isn't on Windows, and there's no way to separate them or rebind the shortcuts (anymore).

Not to mention that you can't remap arbitrary keys in OS X without using third-party software, most of which you have to pay for.

Not that I mind paying for software, but I do mind paying for basic functionality that was present in the last version of the OS.

Re:From Linux to OSX - 1 Year Later by jasomill on Monday September 10, 2012 @02:52AM (#4498642)
KeyRemap4MacBook[1] is free.

[1] http://pqrs.org/macosx/keyremap4macbook/

Re:From Linux to OSX - 1 Year Later by chimeracoder on Monday September 10, 2012 @11:18AM (#4500212)
That doesn't let you remap arbitrary keys; it lets you remap keys in the configurations they've pre-defined for you. That's not the same thing.

Also, the implementation is really wonky, so if you want to do a circular remap (ie, A->B, B->C, C->A), you'll end up with really weird interactions.

It's a stopgap hack at best.

Re:From Linux to OSX - 1 Year Later by msbarnett on Monday September 10, 2012 @01:20AM (#4498420)
Is the complaint here that Mac OS (any version) isn't Windows?

The alt key on Windows doesn't do the same things the command key does in Mac OS, because they are different operating systems. What an utterly vacuous point.

Re:From Linux to OSX - 1 Year Later by sjwright on Sunday September 09, 2012 @06:52PM (#4497334)
Sorry fsniper, but most of your criticisms are either factually wrong and/or based in ignorance.

Not sure what you mean by common denominator shortcuts, but if you mean things like Quit/Cut/Paste/Print/Save/New/Undo then you're dead wrong. Exists, and largely unchanged for nearly 30 years. And they're highly consistent. If it's a menu command, it's the command key.

Mac OS X does not lack a decent terminal emulator. You might have missed it, the program is called Terminal.

You might be right about the package managers, but many people would disagree with you.

There is no maximize button.

You installed Firefox and Thunderbird, so what's the problem? Are you trolling now?

Re:From Linux to OSX - 1 Year Later by fsniper on Sunday September 09, 2012 @07:02PM (#4497372)
If you are thinking of only OsX world, yeah they have never changed for the last 30 or more years, but the world is not only osx. I'm not a single desktop user, I occasionally switch between boxes and only OsX makes my motor memory to fail.

I'm sorry but I can't think of Terminal as a decent Terminal emulator.

Not having a maximize button invalidates my criticism but brings another one of unfamiliar titlebar choices.

I'm not trolling, I'm speaking of defaults.

Re:From Linux to OSX - 1 Year Later by da_n on Sunday September 09, 2012 @07:23PM (#4497429)
"I'm sorry but I can't think of Terminal as a decent Terminal emulator."

Well I'm sorry but unless you explain exactly what the shortcomings are to stop it being 'decent' your comments are nothing more than trollish bigotry. You are just coming across as arrogant and ignorant.

Re:From Linux to OSX - 1 Year Later by fsniper on Sunday September 09, 2012 @07:26PM (#4497438)
Re:From Linux to OSX - 1 Year Later by sjwright on Monday September 10, 2012 @12:55AM (#4498375)
I can't think of top as a decent process monitor, but I don't blame debian for that.
Re:From Linux to OSX - 1 Year Later by DanBC on Sunday September 09, 2012 @07:08PM (#4497388)
Shift clicking the green bobble maximises (really maximises, apart from the unremovable Menu bar) the window.

Not allowing the user to add this functionality (even if it's a hidden option in a config file somewhere) is sub optimal in my opinion.

There are some great things about OSX but there are a few small but frustrating things too.

Re:From Linux to OSX - 1 Year Later by fsniper on Sunday September 09, 2012 @07:23PM (#4497428)
Thank you. This is a really helpful comment.
Re:From Linux to OSX - 1 Year Later by DanBC on Sunday September 09, 2012 @07:38PM (#4497475)
I switched from Windows and Linux to OSX.

I found there were many things that I did not know, and had to learn.

How do I rename a file in the GUI? (right click, select "get info", change the file name in the box, etc.)

How do I do keyboard text navigation? Option (or alt)left or right arrow will move one word. Command left or right arrow will move to the beginning or end of a line. Adding shift will select the text. (etc etc.)

How do I turn off the sound when I turn my machine on? (Don't turn the machine off, or use a third party software.)

There's some things which can't be done.

But, in the end, computers are tools, and people need to be comfortable with their tools. So use whatever fits your needs.

Re:From Linux to OSX - 1 Year Later by kroger on Sunday September 09, 2012 @10:11PM (#4497957)
>>> How do I rename a file in the GUI? (right click, select "get info", change the file name in the box, etc.)

you can just press the Return key to rename a file.

Re:From Linux to OSX - 1 Year Later by DanBC on Monday September 10, 2012 @07:58AM (#4499298)
ha! Thank you!

I thought it would 'do an action' (launch or open). I do need to learn more.

Re:From Linux to OSX - 1 Year Later by tymekpavel on Sunday September 09, 2012 @09:38PM (#4497854)
"How do I rename a file in the GUI?" Click once to highlight the file and click again to rename it. No need to go into the "get info" menu.

"How do I turn off the sound when I turn my machine on?" Mute the computer before shutting it down.

Re:From Linux to OSX - 1 Year Later by evgen on Monday September 10, 2012 @12:17AM (#4498280)
"the sound" that I think he wants to suppress is the startup chime, which can't be turned off because it serves a very specific hardware debugging purpose related to the boot process. There are hacks that can turn down the volume of the chime but it cannot be completely turned off.
Re:From Linux to OSX - 1 Year Later by tymekpavel on Monday September 10, 2012 @12:24AM (#4498303)
Strange. When I mute my computer before rebooting or shutting down, it does not make the sound.
Re:From Linux to OSX - 1 Year Later by DanBC on Monday September 10, 2012 @08:00AM (#4499306)
But you have to mute the computer before you shut it down. Remembering to perform an action every single time in order to prevent a startup chime is sub-optimal. Having an option to turn it off would be better than relying on a 3rd party hack.
Re:From Linux to OSX - 1 Year Later by dylok4200 on Sunday September 09, 2012 @07:48PM (#4497512)
switched to linux long time ago. keep OSX bc of ease for some things, but have more than one computer for this reason. definitely a tradeoff but one i sure found worthy. never did figure out the sound issue.
Re:From Linux to OSX - 1 Year Later by ricardobeat on Sunday September 09, 2012 @06:35PM (#4497277)
I'm curious on the shortcomings of Homebrew (other than like-to-have packages) + app store. And the Terminal, you can have zsh/fish if you want or use iTerm2 for crazy features.

On shortcuts: you're just used to another way, it's not the system's fault. It's possible to use both Windows and OSX without much difficulty after getting used to it.

At least 50% of the joy of using a mac is due to the hardware and integration.

Re:From Linux to OSX - 1 Year Later by jeltz on Sunday September 09, 2012 @06:42PM (#4497305)
From my personal experience using homebrew it is two things.

1) The lack of packages combined with lack of quality of the packages (e.g. they do not build or have a poor defaults).

2) That homebrew installs stuff under /usr/local as owned by your user. That does not meet the expectations of UNIX applications and seems to me like it could be unsafe due to messing with expectations. Stuff under /usr/local/bin is supposed to be owned by root:root.

The good part of homebrew is that writing homebrew scripts seems easier than writing dpkg or rpm scripts.

Re:From Linux to OSX - 1 Year Later by fsniper on Sunday September 09, 2012 @06:51PM (#4497333)
That's a good summary. Thank you.

The greatest shortcoming is the lack of packages. After using debian, homebrew is a toy.

Re:From Linux to OSX - 1 Year Later by ricardobeat on Sunday September 09, 2012 @11:42PM (#4498208)
How is running as user less safe than as root?

In OSX, /usr/local is really user-space. It comes empty on an install, and the system never touches it (that means no mess with /opt). The FHS also doesn't mandate /usr/local/bin to be owned by root. Don't root-owned utilities go in /usr/sbin?

Re:From Linux to OSX - 1 Year Later by jasomill on Monday September 10, 2012 @03:18AM (#4498692)
Because the ability to write to a directory in a user's PATH makes it easy to trick this user into running arbitrary code. And /usr/local is a particularly poor choice for package management in a system like OS X without a "universal" package manager, because lots of prepackaged, precompiled third-party software already uses it. It's also not a particularly good idea to put your package manager's paths ahead of the system paths in PATH unless you want shell scripts to mysteriously break when some package pulls in an unanticipated dependency that includes newer, older, or different tools by the same name as system utilities (two examples that come to mind are HEAD from libwww-perl on a case-insensitive filesystem and xattr from the Python module of the same name; also GNU foo where the OS ships some GNU-incompatible version of foo). Instead, create another directory to hold symlinks for the few utilities you want to override system defaults (on my own systems, these include python, emacs, and git).
Re:From Linux to OSX - 1 Year Later by TheGateKeeper on Sunday September 09, 2012 @07:21PM (#4497424)
This is why you use macports ;)
Re:From Linux to OSX - 1 Year Later by chimeracoder on Sunday September 09, 2012 @08:45PM (#4497711)
I'd like to add two more:

1. Installing everything from source (normally I don't mind compiling, but large packages can take an hour or two. Ironically, OS X doesn't need to support many different architectures, so there's no excuse for not having binary compatibility like Linux does).

2. It doesn't manage the entire system. The process for installing from a .dmg or from the app store is completely different from homebrew, and the two don't talk to each other well (or really at all). I want a single source to manage all of my executable files and their configurations, not a small handful that each manage part of it.

Re:From Linux to OSX - 1 Year Later by CountSessine on Sunday September 09, 2012 @08:41PM (#4497700)
The experience is - in one word - disgusting

Really?

It lacks common denominator keyboard shortcuts and keyboard bindings

No it doesn't. Emacs/bash key combos are everywhere. These are the oldest and most important key sequences in use on any computer. CTRL-A, CTRL-E, META-F, META-B, META-D, CTRL-K - and they pervade the Cocoa/Nextstep text engine. They're everywhere.

It lacks sane default simple applications like a decent terminal emulator

Really? Terminal is pretty awesome in some ways. For example, with the Gnome terminal app, when you resize the window, lines aren't readjusted for width and you end up either cropping lines or leaving a blank space to the right. Terminal seems to be one of the few terminal emulators that gets this right.

Unfamiliar key bindings makes me think twice or thrice before typing

I don't understand this. Doesn't this just mean that you haven't gotten used to it?

How can I skip to end of line?

CTRL-E, like I said. If you're an Emacs nut (and I am) you can even edit the file ~/Library/KeyBindings/DefaultKeyBinding.dict to make these key bindings work in ANY text field that uses an NSTextField object in ANY OSX application.

There's even a global kill-ring. It's awesome. Clearly there were some real Emacs fans who worked on the original Nextstep text engine.

switching to full height windows instead of full screen windows with the maximize button? Why on earth I would opt-in for loosing screen real estate

It's a 'resize' button, not a maximize button. For many applications, especially those whose content is a fixed or maximum size (like web browsers), a maximize button with a large screen is just silly - you'd waste screen real estate with white or blank borders. What the 'resize' button does is and should be application-specific. For a web browser, it should resize the window to the size of the content. Ditto a word processor. For an IDE like XCode and Eclipse, it should maximize (and both of those do).

This may be only me but, I hate OsX

It sounds to me like you haven't put much energy into figuring it out and finding the best workflow - certainly not nearly as much energy as I've put into learning the esoterica behind Linux abominations like XKB and Gnome 3. And I would never say that Linux disgusts me - far from it. I think Linux is great.