I probably should generalize my thoughts though to say “expectation of economic growth” (instead of just “money printing”) seems to me necessary to yield “opaque market insanity”, as opposed to “transparent evil sanity”.
As a thought experiment, consider a (practically impossible) scenario where there is universally no expectation for long-term economic growth/contraction — regardless of whether it’s “real” or just monetary. Then by definition, a long term market simply cannot exist at all. No amount of wealth inequality can cause market insanity if there is no (long-term) market at all.
Wealth inequality in such a situation can still yield hoarding, domination, conquest, control, scams, manipulations, etc. But I wouldn’t call that “market insanity” so much as “evil sanity”.
In practice, the real impact of wealth inequality on the common people would likely be the same either way. However, without long term economic growth/inflation, the “sane evil” of the greedy wealth can no longer hide behind the veil of “market insanity”.
You probably won't get a lot to support that idea on the literature.
If anything, the experiments you're talking about are just the logical consequences of doing the same thing over and over.
After all, the experiments never seemed to modify the problematic element, all they did was increase the quantity according to the logic of accumulation.
In fact, isn't it remarkable that the last 2000 years have produced the exact same pattern over and over again?
The logic is always the same. Money from period A can be carried over to period B. This means there is too little money during period A and too much during period B.
Since period A is perpetually today, and period B is perpetually tomorrow, one could get the idea to at least fix period A, which isn't as stupid as the Austrian economists would like to tell you. But fixing today through quantity means there is even more money carried over to tomorrow. The problem is being fixed with more of itself. It certainly isn't being fixed by having a competing system for trade.
Abandoning gold, fractional reserve banking, QE, etc all exist due to the fundamental mistake of making it possible to carry something that is time and location bound away from the time and location it is bound to.
Reintroducing a gold standard doesn't change this logic. It just makes it slightly more visible.
When you look at Arrow-Debreu models, you see the assumption is that utility maximizing economic agents will spend their entire budget on either present utility (consumer goods) or future utility (investment goods). The concept of carrying money from one period to another doesn't exist and is inherently incompatible with equilibrium and yet you don't see economists warning us about the carrying over of past balances into the future with the exception Keynes and Wolfgang Stützel. Not even Marx thought that this was problematic. Even the Austrian economists know the problem, as they argue that the single individual with the lowest time preference should own the entire planet and that the real problem is the national central bank (which happens to be quite small in contrast to world domination).
The problem and its half baked attempts at solutions is at least as old as Christianity. Possibly all the way back to mesopotamia.
I just told you two things that changed within a human lifetime, and you didn't even read them, so the conversation ends here.
I don't know how the ancient civilizations handled non-metalic money, I know that on the Middle age it was a famous kingdom killer because most kings couldn't refrain from creating infinite money.
I feel like I'm going to be able to tell my adult kids "Yeah, when I was younger the Republicans were the party of free trade and government non-intervention in private industry..."
I think you have just defined gold and bitcoin to be "nothing".
Sounds about right.
If you want to make it less vague, you can read Keynes.
It's inequality that is the important one, money printing doesn't impact it (except for it impacting inequality). In simple language, people don't want to spend all their money on consumption (the "demand is infinite" you see on econ101 is an approximation), and so when only two dozen people have all the money there aren't many things you can sell and turn a profit. But those people still want to invest all the money they aren't using, there is just nothing to invest into.
At the turn of the 19th to the 20th century, explaining this was a huge open problem in economics.