News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Home Depot Sued for 'Secretly' Using Facial Recognition a... by closewith on Thursday August 21, 2025 @05:05AM (#44970619)
> Put the criminals in prison. Do it often enough, and shoplifting ceases to be a problem of plague-like proportions. Big fan of accountability and immediate personal consequences and enforcing the law.

This just doesn't work. A high-trust society cannot be built by force.

> I am fatigued of the suicidal and deleterious empathy of those in charge who refuse to take second-order effects into account.

The irony here is palpable. An increasingly desperate poverty class with no hope of social mobility has many second-order effects, and none of them can be policed out of existence.

Re:Home Depot Sued for 'Secretly' Using Facial Recognition a... by RugnirViking on Thursday August 21, 2025 @05:32AM (#44970757)
> A high-trust society cannot be built by force.

Imo we're kinda in the worse quadrant of whats possible.

You can either have high visibility/force of prevention efforts or low. And you can have high actual rates of crime or low.

Imo we currently have low actual rates of crime (you see people saying oh its rampant in California or whatever but im not there and can't make an accurate assessment of it over the internet) and highly visible (damn near pervasive) efforts at preventing crime in almost every corner of our lives. "please don't abuse our staff" "cctv in operation", facial recognition, constant assumptions that you are a threat. If I didn't know better its almost like they "want" people to be criminals -- it seems like according to some other threads there are at least some people whose jobs it would make easier

Re:Home Depot Sued for 'Secretly' Using Facial Recognition a... by UncleMeat on Thursday August 21, 2025 @07:43AM (#44971540)
It is amazing to me that we have have failed so completely to report on the miraculous drop in crime rates over the past 30 years. People consistently report that crime is up, even when presented with contradictory evidence.

A major part of the problem, in my estimation, is that a lot of people don't actually perceive crime as crime but instead perceive divergence from their expected social hierarchies as crime. This is how you get people saying that crime in DC is high because they saw a person that looked homeless sitting on the metro. Although sitting on the metro is legal, a poor person doesn't "belong" there so this is seen as evidence of crime.

Re:Home Depot Sued for 'Secretly' Using Facial Recognition a... by JKCalhoun on Thursday August 21, 2025 @09:22AM (#44972457)
That's a good point. Perhaps people "feel" unsafe, not that, statistically, they in fact are.
Re:Home Depot Sued for 'Secretly' Using Facial Recognition a... by RugnirViking on Thursday August 21, 2025 @09:59AM (#44972890)
and thats kinda what my point is. Even outside of the news cycle, there is so much anti thievery signs etc where their main function, in my estimation, is causing people to feel that crime is all around them, regardless of their effects on actual crime.
Re:Home Depot Sued for 'Secretly' Using Facial Recognition a... by randallsquared on Thursday August 21, 2025 @07:37AM (#44971500)
> This just doesn't work. A high-trust society cannot be built by force.

To badly quote Mead, "It's the only thing that ever has". If the incentives are such that defecting becomes less attractive, defection will decrease.

Re:Home Depot Sued for 'Secretly' Using Facial Recognition a... by bee_rider on Thursday August 21, 2025 @09:32AM (#44972562)
I don’t think that’s what a high trust society is. In fact, I’m pretty sure the whole point of the thing is that people in a high trust society don’t defect even when they don’t think they’ll get caught, because they understand that not-defecting is part of the bargain everybody is engaging in to keep the good thing going.
Re:Home Depot Sued for 'Secretly' Using Facial Recognition a... by closewith on Thursday August 21, 2025 @10:16AM (#44973095)
You're just plain wrong. You can enforce compliance - a police state - but it inevitably worsens outcomes for both people who commit crimes and their victims.

But that isn't a high-trust society. In fact a high trust society requires minimal formal policing by definition (and a _lot_ of informal policing by parents, families, friends, and communities).

High-trust societies aren't without their problems, too, as trust is regularly abused.

Re:Home Depot Sued for 'Secretly' Using Facial Recognition a... by randallsquared on Thursday August 21, 2025 @12:08PM (#44974465)
A society where trust is regularly abused isn’t—or will not long remain—a “high-trust” society.

Also, it’s not clear me if you really meant that enforcing property laws inevitably worsens outcomes for those who would otherwise have been victims, or if you mean that the now-much-smaller pool of victims have a worse time with effective enforcement. I’d argue that both are false, but the latter at least seems arguable.

Re:Home Depot Sued for 'Secretly' Using Facial Recognition a... by closewith on Thursday August 21, 2025 @03:07PM (#44976785)
> A society where trust is regularly abused isn’t—or will not long remain—a “high-trust” society.

Yes, well, I think you'll find this is how every high-trust society to date has ended up. Trust is abused, usually by the in-group rather than strangers. Abuse of power by politicians, the clergy, authorities like police, etc has largely lead to the collapse of trust across the West.

It's part of the inevitable cyclical nature of social change.

> Also, it’s not clear me if you really meant that enforcing property laws inevitably worsens outcomes for those who would otherwise have been victims, or if you mean that the now-much-smaller pool of victims have a worse time with effective enforcement.

Yes, increasing enforcement without structurally addressing the underlying issues - starting with poverty and wealth inequality - only ever leads to a criminal underclass, more poverty, more crime, and a worse society for everybody, criminals and victims alike.

It doesn't create fewer victims, it creates more (and I'm not being mealy-mouthed and counting the criminals as victims).

There is no way to police yourself into a better society.

Re:Home Depot Sued for 'Secretly' Using Facial Recognition a... by 9cb14c1ec0 on Thursday August 21, 2025 @06:39AM (#44971129)
High trust societies can only exist when there are consequences for things like theft.
Re:Home Depot Sued for 'Secretly' Using Facial Recognition a... by closewith on Thursday August 21, 2025 @06:47AM (#44971174)
All examples of high trust societies show that those consequences must be social, because _by definition_, in a high-trust society, you must trust other people to do the right thing.

A punitive dictatorship or police state is not a high-trust society, even though laws may be strictly enforced. Likewise, in a high-trust society, behaviour is expected to be good and moral, even where not mandated by law.

Re:Home Depot Sued for 'Secretly' Using Facial Recognition a... by 9cb14c1ec0 on Thursday August 21, 2025 @07:02AM (#44971262)
And there-in lies the problem of modern society. There are no social consequences. The decline of religion and family with no suitable replacement has left most people without a peer group to exert these social consequences.
Re:Home Depot Sued for 'Secretly' Using Facial Recognition a... by cnity on Thursday August 21, 2025 @07:15AM (#44971343)
A lot of HN readers would get a lot out of watching more Star Trek: TNG.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Justice_(Star_Trek:_The_Next_G...

Re:Home Depot Sued for 'Secretly' Using Facial Recognition a... by matthewdgreen on Thursday August 21, 2025 @09:17AM (#44972392)
Lots of people in the US are religious. This generally doesn’t seem to dramatically lower crime on a statistical basis (with all kinds of caveats.)
Re:Home Depot Sued for 'Secretly' Using Facial Recognition a... by 9cb14c1ec0 on Thursday August 21, 2025 @10:30AM (#44973255)
Far less than in previous generations. And just because people vaguely claim to be religious in some general sense today doesn't mean that their vague generalities provide them with communities that bring about social responsibility.
Re:Home Depot Sued for 'Secretly' Using Facial Recognition a... by aaronbaugher on Thursday August 21, 2025 @10:38AM (#44973358)
Yeah, a whole lot of Americans who still click the "religious" box on a poll are just going on habit and family tradition, or they go to a church that's become part social club and part community charity center. (Nothing wrong with charity, of course, but you don't have to be religious to be charitable.) It doesn't mean what it meant a few generations ago, when, probably coincidentally, there was less crime.
Re:Home Depot Sued for 'Secretly' Using Facial Recognition a... by Ajedi32 on Thursday August 21, 2025 @10:29AM (#44973241)
Trust has to be earned. High-trust societies are awesome, but you can't just expect people to trust that they're not going to be robbed in the street if people keep getting robbed in the street, or that the few criminals that do exist will suffer consequences for their behavior if they're not actually suffering those consequences. That sort of culture takes time to build.
Re:Home Depot Sued for 'Secretly' Using Facial Recognition a... by closewith on Thursday August 21, 2025 @03:06PM (#44976778)
> That sort of culture takes time to build.

It does. Generations. We should get started.

Just to be clear, I don't think policing is futile or unethical or anything. But it is symptom control and cannot improve your society. Leaning into policing as a panacea inevitably results in worse outcomes for everybody, police included.

Re:Home Depot Sued for 'Secretly' Using Facial Recognition a... by bko on Thursday August 21, 2025 @06:39AM (#44971133)
What do you mean "this just doesn't work"?

You do understand that an overwhelming majority of crime and overall anti social behavior is done by a tiny percentage of people. Remove those people and you spare the rest of us.

For instance, the number of prisoners that have had 15 or more prior arrests is over 26%.

You can just have a 15 strikes and you're out policy and make a huge impact. Once these bad actors are out of society, high trust can be built. Stop letting a tiny percentage of people terrorize the rest of us.

It's not about poverty and ironically the biggest victims of this criminal behavior are poor people. Poor innocent people deal w theft, getting hassled and other consequences of criminal behavior at a much higher rate. It's not compassionate to let them suffer.

https://mleverything.substack.com/p/acceptance-of-crime-is-a...

Re:Home Depot Sued for 'Secretly' Using Facial Recognition a... by UncleMeat on Thursday August 21, 2025 @07:45AM (#44971547)
> You do understand that an overwhelming majority of crime and overall anti social behavior is done by a tiny percentage of people.

Are you including all the bosses committing wage theft in this? Or are we only looking at a particular kind of crime?

Re:Home Depot Sued for 'Secretly' Using Facial Recognition a... by bko on Thursday August 21, 2025 @08:14AM (#44971794)
Yes
Re:Home Depot Sued for 'Secretly' Using Facial Recognition a... by gotoeleven on Thursday August 21, 2025 @07:49AM (#44971576)
When you're talking to left wing people about what "works" with regards to law enforcement, it's important to keep in mind that they have a different definition of "works" than most people. Most people think that a law enforcement policy "works" if it reduces the incidence of criminal events against innocent people. Left wing people, on the other hand, tend to think of the criminals themselves as victims--of "the system," or racism, or colonialism, or stigma--so a policy that is too harsh on criminals doesn't "work" for them. In their view, law enforcement should weigh heavily the victim status of criminals themselves.

(and this isn't AI I really do use emdashes)

Re:Home Depot Sued for 'Secretly' Using Facial Recognition a... by bko on Thursday August 21, 2025 @08:20AM (#44971842)
I think another framework is blank slatism.

For instance, you can look at two countries and if one country has a higher prison population, that country over polices because every country and its people should have the same criminality level because all cultures and people are identical.

I remember feeling great shame that the US had such a high imprisonment rate. This led to a big decrease in state prison population and things like cashless bail and letting people go to basically like the stats. We need to get back to basics and remove people that are destructive and stop overanalyzing things

Re:Home Depot Sued for 'Secretly' Using Facial Recognition a... by immibis on Thursday August 21, 2025 @10:36PM (#44980492)
So now you're asserting there is something uniquely, inherently bad about Americans that causes them to need to be locked in jail at 6 times the rate of every other country.

Do you know what that thing might be, and how to fix it?

Re:Home Depot Sued for 'Secretly' Using Facial Recognition a... by justinrubek on Thursday August 21, 2025 @09:13AM (#44972344)
As opposed to right-wing people, who think it works if it makes them feel warm and bubbly inside, which only happens when it's designed poorly and not working properly.
Re:Home Depot Sued for 'Secretly' Using Facial Recognition a... by tomhow on Friday August 22, 2025 @07:20PM (#44991155)
Eschew flamebait.

Please don't use Hacker News for political or ideological battle. It tramples curiosity.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Home Depot Sued for 'Secretly' Using Facial Recognition a... by matthewdgreen on Thursday August 21, 2025 @09:19AM (#44972427)
Please don’t worry about the emdashes, worry about the broad and inaccurate generalizations being churned out by your flawed world model. I urge you to go to some actual criminal reformers in person.
Re:Home Depot Sued for 'Secretly' Using Facial Recognition a... by closewith on Thursday August 21, 2025 @10:21AM (#44973159)
Neither side of any political spectrum thinks that a law enforcement policy "works" if it reduces the incidence of criminal events against innocent people. Obviously if that was the goal, the easiest path is to remove laws and disband police. Instant crime rate drop.

But in fact both sides want to improve their societal outcomes and the policing/criminal policies that they support are by-and-large attempts to do that - improve society.

I'm neither left- nor right-wing in the US sense, but it is clear from examples around the world that high-trust societies emerge from the ground up and require strong family units, strong local communities, and strong engagement in larger politics.

While you do need police, you can't build communities by policing them. It's never worked anywhere.

Re:Home Depot Sued for 'Secretly' Using Facial Recognition a... by tomhow on Friday August 22, 2025 @07:19PM (#44991147)
Eschew flamebait.

Please don't use Hacker News for political or ideological battle. It tramples curiosity.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Home Depot Sued for 'Secretly' Using Facial Recognition a... by cnity on Thursday August 21, 2025 @07:19AM (#44971364)
A policeman's job is only easy in a police state.
Re:Home Depot Sued for 'Secretly' Using Facial Recognition a... by closewith on Thursday August 21, 2025 @10:11AM (#44973041)
> What do you mean "this just doesn't work"?

What I mean is that it doesn't work. Your proposal only increases crime, only deepens poverty, only worsens society.

> You do understand that an overwhelming majority of crime and overall anti social behavior is done by a tiny percentage of people. Remove those people and you spare the rest of us.

And yet, this policy has never worked. Three-stikes laws never work. Increased policing and more comprehensive criminal legislation never works. As long as the circumstances that caused the criminality persist, the problems returns ever more entrenched.

> It's not about poverty and ironically the biggest victims of this criminal behavior are poor people. Poor innocent people deal w theft, getting hassled and other consequences of criminal behavior at a much higher rate. It's not compassionate to let them suffer.

You are correct that the poorest suffer the most. As a society, we should aim to eradicate the poverty. Anything short of that is symptom control.

Re:Home Depot Sued for 'Secretly' Using Facial Recognition a... by cooper_ganglia on Thursday August 21, 2025 @09:33AM (#44972578)
A high-trust society cannot be built any way other than force!

Once you've removed the dredges of society (by force), all of the good, law-abiding citizens have better lives.

Re:Home Depot Sued for 'Secretly' Using Facial Recognition a... by closewith on Thursday August 21, 2025 @10:52AM (#44973527)
What you're describing is a police state and has never resulted in a high-trust society.
Re:Home Depot Sued for 'Secretly' Using Facial Recognition a... by itsanaccount on Thursday August 21, 2025 @02:54PM (#44976619)
^ found the fascist.