News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Show HN: Claude Code workflow: PRDs → GitHub Issues → par... by aososidjbd on Wednesday August 20, 2025 @09:50AM (#44961955)
This has been my experience with coworkers who are big vibe coders as well. Another “sorry, big PR coming in that needs a review” and I’m gonna lose it. 50 comments later and they still don’t change.

When using agents like this, you only see a speedup because you’re offloading the time you’d spend thinking / understanding the code. If you can review code faster than you can write it, you’re cutting corners on your code reviews. Which is normally fine with humans (this is why we pay them), but not AI. Most people just code review for nitpicks anyways (rename a variable, add some white space, use map reduce instead of for each) instead of taking time to understand the change (you’ll be looking a lots of code and docs that aren’t present in the diff).

That is, unless you type really slowly - which I’ve recently discovered is actually a bottle neck for some professionals (slow typing, syntax issues, constantly checking docs, etc). I’ll add I experience this too when learning a new language and AI is immensely helpful.

Re:Show HN: Claude Code workflow: PRDs → GitHub Issues → par... by aitchnyu on Wednesday August 20, 2025 @10:42AM (#44962415)
Which industry are you in, that there is 1:1 ratio of coding to review hours?
Re:Show HN: Claude Code workflow: PRDs → GitHub Issues → par... by swader999 on Wednesday August 20, 2025 @10:51AM (#44962493)
You're absolutely right but I wonder if we'll have to ditch the traditional code review for something else, perhaps automated, if this agentic way continues.
Re:Show HN: Claude Code workflow: PRDs → GitHub Issues → par... by CuriouslyC on Wednesday August 20, 2025 @02:03PM (#44964450)
AI can actually review PRs decently when given enough context and detailed instructions. It doesn't eliminate the PR problem, but it can catch a lot of bugs and it can add comments to parts of the code that look questionable to instruct humans to manually verify.
Re:Show HN: Claude Code workflow: PRDs → GitHub Issues → par... by mac-mc on Wednesday August 20, 2025 @02:30PM (#44964728)
You can also force the agent to write up a summary of the code change, reasoning, etc, fortunately, which can help with review.
Re:Show HN: Claude Code workflow: PRDs → GitHub Issues → par... by robbs on Wednesday August 20, 2025 @02:43PM (#44964887)
> You're absolutely right

Claude! Get off HN and get back to work.

Re:Show HN: Claude Code workflow: PRDs → GitHub Issues → par... by swader999 on Wednesday August 20, 2025 @05:27PM (#44966678)
Oh my, that was unintentional. What have I become...