Re:The ban on electronic devices rests on anecdotes
by rll on Sunday September 09, 2012 @12:18AM
(#4494913)
Forget the radio interference, put hard projectiles like laptops and tablets away during take-off and landings so they don't go flying around the cabin if there is an incident.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:The ban on electronic devices rests on anecdotes
by mahyarm on Sunday September 09, 2012 @12:23AM
(#4494928)
That logic doesn't make any sense, since you can have other hard projectiles, such as a saxophone or a textbook during those times. They'll have to tell everyone to put away ALL objects, which they don't.
Re:The ban on electronic devices rests on anecdotes
by CamperBob2 on Sunday September 09, 2012 @12:27AM
(#4494937)
A musical instrument would have to be stowed under the seat. A book, though, represents a pretty big loophole. I've never been asked to put a book away during takeoff or landing, even a textbook that's heavy enough to serve as a murder weapon.
Re:The ban on electronic devices rests on anecdotes
by rll on Sunday September 09, 2012 @12:56AM
(#4494993)
There are also way more laptops and tablets around on planes than big heavy textbooks. People tend to bring smaller softcovers when they travel for obvious reasons.
Re:The ban on electronic devices rests on anecdotes
by rdtsc on Sunday September 09, 2012 @02:28AM
(#4495107)
> Forget the radio interference, put hard projectiles like laptops and tablets away during take-off
And the government is what? shy? or embarrassed to admit such physics facts? But in turn had to make up lies and fake convoluted reasons to accomplish this?
You are basically implying that they all gathered in a dark room someplace at FAA and decided "Aha, we don't want all these projectiles flying around, but we don't want to reveal our true motives, so we'll ... call it electronic interference and tell them to stow away electronic devices, but now, everyone must keep this secret!", then they all raise their right hand, swear on their mother's grave, and there you have it, a new FAA rule.