News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Brain Parasites, California’s Hidden Health Problem by SlipperySlope on Saturday September 08, 2012 @02:18AM (#4492424)
This parasite can be eradicated worldwide. We need pigs to be penned where they cannot eat human feces - its that simple.

Who else thinks that if the Hebrews had figured that out long ago, then Hebrew and Muslim diet restrictions might today be more permissive?

Re:Brain Parasites, California’s Hidden Health Problem by vectorbunny on Saturday September 08, 2012 @06:58AM (#4492746)
I think Hebrew dietary restrictions may be more instructively viewed as a mechanism to enforce group cohesion than as a primer on suggested health practices. It is difficult to mix with other groups when you cannot eat with them. Matrilineal line of descent serves the same function. Children fathered by in-group men with women outside the group are simply excluded, while in-group women face censure for the same behavior. There are structural reasons why Jewish culture has remained distinct in diaspora, while many other disjoint populations are absorbed by host populations over time.
Re:Brain Parasites, California’s Hidden Health Problem by gojomo on Saturday September 08, 2012 @01:10PM (#4493360)
Longstanding practices are often multiply-determined, and the relative balance of benefits may change according to the situation. (In high-sanitation environments, the rules help enforce cohesion/segregation; in low-sanitation environments, the rules provide protection from endemic parasites.)
Re:Brain Parasites, California’s Hidden Health Problem by trhtrsh on Saturday September 08, 2012 @04:38PM (#4493929)
Why forbid pigs, and not cows? Why catfish, not cod? Vulture, not chicken? Even within a framework, there are reasons for specific decisions.
Re:Brain Parasites, California’s Hidden Health Problem by vectorbunny on Sunday September 09, 2012 @11:20AM (#4495985)
Agreed, there are always reasons for specific decisions. In the three cases you've mentioned, the banned flesh is from animals that are carrion eating scavengers.
Re:Brain Parasites, California’s Hidden Health Problem by bryanlarsen on Saturday September 08, 2012 @07:23AM (#4492770)
Pork production in the United States is monitored and tapeworm free. You're much safer eating American pork than you are eating fish.

As noted in the article, the discussion is about human to human spread of this parasite. The solution there is even simpler, though more difficult: wash your hands regularly and thoroughly.

Re:Brain Parasites, California’s Hidden Health Problem by kevindication on Saturday September 08, 2012 @09:05AM (#4492876)
And even more importantly, wash your hands regularly and thoroughly when you are preparing food for others.
Re:Brain Parasites, California’s Hidden Health Problem by vectorbunny on Saturday September 08, 2012 @07:38AM (#4492782)
Agreed. Sanitation practices that seem obvious in the developed world assume infrastructure not available in many other areas. People who live in these places are not stupid, and I, for one, am glad that my morning ritual doesn't involve hauling fresh water from a mile away.
Re:Brain Parasites, California’s Hidden Health Problem by nivertech on Saturday September 08, 2012 @12:06PM (#4493194)
This was figured not by Hebrews (ancient Israelites), but by ancient Egyptians.

Cysticercosis was endemic in ancient Egypt. Pork was a staple food for common people in Egypt, but priests had strict dietary laws and they knew that Cysticercosis caused by tapeworms from swine.

Ancient Israelites just adopted a lot of customs from Egyptian Priestly caste, like circumcision, calendar and dietary laws. Not surprising, considering Moses was raised as Egyptian.

Re:Brain Parasites, California’s Hidden Health Problem by iskander on Saturday September 08, 2012 @03:08PM (#4493682)
>...priests had strict dietary laws and they knew that Cysticercosis caused by tapeworms from swine.

> Ancient Israelites just adopted a lot of customs from Egyptian Priestly caste...Not surprising, considering Moses was raised as Egyptian.

Even allowing the existence of Moses (which, if we're feeling skeptical we can reinterpret as the long cultural shadow of Egypt), this still seems like a "just so" story.

Do you know if there's any evidence that Egyptian priests actually had medical justifications for their taboos? Similarly, how do we know that ancient Israelites adopted certain beliefs due to direct Egyptian influence, rather than participating in widespread regional practices also found in the Canaanite populations from which they emerged?

Re:Brain Parasites, California’s Hidden Health Problem by nivertech on Saturday September 08, 2012 @04:34PM (#4493915)
I don't think at the time there was distinction between religion, astrology, science, medicine and healthcare. The priests had the knowledge, while the commoners were mostly illiterate.

During the Predynastic Period pigs were considered unclean in Upper Egypt but were domesticated and eaten in Lower Egypt. During the Dynastic Period Pigs were thought to be unclean in some areas and among the wealthier classes. Herodotus states that people who raised and ate pig were shunned but archaeological evidence suggests that although technically unclean, pork was still popular with many poorer Egyptians.

http://www.ancientegyptonline.co.uk/dietmeat.html

Moses or not, the word "Israel" was found in Egyptian scripts. "Hapiru" king "Yakubu" also mentioned in Egyptian sources - cognates with Hebrew Yaakov.

There are enough evidence, that ancient Egyptians and ancient Israelis had a contact.

Re:Brain Parasites, California’s Hidden Health Problem by iskander on Saturday September 08, 2012 @07:09PM (#4494333)
I took a biblical archaeology class as an undergrad and both our teacher and every text we read were very cautious about making this link. There simply isn't very much evidence for who the 'PRW (apiru or whatever) were; we don't even know if it's a particular tribe/identity or just a catch-all for brigands and outlaws. Similarly, we don't have any historical evidence for what Israelite society was like before ~1000BC and definitely nothing about 2000BC (when the word apiru starts appearing).

I agree that the ancient documents about marauding apiru might be referring to Hebrews, but we really should keep our Bayesian hats on when evaluating archaeological evidence.

As for "Yakubu" and "Israel", any citations? Are those in one of the Amarna letters?

Re:Brain Parasites, California’s Hidden Health Problem by nivertech on Sunday September 09, 2012 @02:18AM (#4495092)
Re:Brain Parasites, California’s Hidden Health Problem by iskander on Sunday September 09, 2012 @10:33AM (#4495870)
Cool, thanks.
Re:Brain Parasites, California’s Hidden Health Problem by raverbashing on Saturday September 08, 2012 @03:55AM (#4492547)
Yes, but not only that

Vegetables should be properly cleaned before eating

If you eat contaminated pork, you won't get NCC (or other cysticercosis) , you get a worm.

You get Cysticercosis when you eat food contaminated with human faeces (sorry about that). Because then the human is "playing the part" of the pig.

Cooking and basic hygiene goes a long way.

Re:Brain Parasites, California’s Hidden Health Problem by rorrr on Saturday September 08, 2012 @04:58AM (#4492620)
> If you eat contaminated pork, you won't get NCC (or other cysticercosis)

You are wrong

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cysticercosis

Re:Brain Parasites, California’s Hidden Health Problem by raverbashing on Saturday September 08, 2012 @05:29AM (#4492650)
You were so quick to dismiss me you haven't even read the link you posted, so please read this https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cysticercosis#Transmission carefully

"Humans are T. solium reservoirs. They are infected by eating undercooked pork that contains viable cysticerci."

They are infected -> they get a worm by eating undercooked pork. Not cysticercosis

Normal lifecycle: Pork eats tape worm eggs -> the pork gets cysticercosis -> Humans eat pork meat -> humans get tape worm -> worm releases eggs in human faeces -> back to step one

Cysticercosis happens when the human plays the role of the pork

Re:Brain Parasites, California’s Hidden Health Problem by rorrr on Saturday September 08, 2012 @03:37PM (#4493764)
The very first line of the link I sent says "Cysticercosis refers to tissue infection after exposure to eggs of Taenia solium, the pork tapeworm."
Re:Brain Parasites, California’s Hidden Health Problem by raverbashing on Saturday September 08, 2012 @03:55PM (#4493812)
Correct

Contaminated pork meat has no tapeworm eggs, it has cysticerci, which is the tapeworm larvae. Not eggs

You're confusing things.

Re:Brain Parasites, California’s Hidden Health Problem by onetimeuse001 on Saturday September 08, 2012 @02:28AM (#4492441)
This parasite can be eradicated worldwide. We need pigs to be penned where they cannot eat human feces - its that simple.

Not simple at all. A trip outside the first world will tell you that raising pigs is not as easy as you make it. Not every family has land and resources avail to raise pigs as you said it.

Re:Brain Parasites, California’s Hidden Health Problem by johnchristopher on Saturday September 08, 2012 @02:53AM (#4492473)
Moreoever pigs are in direct competition with humans for food. That's almost certaily why ancestral middle-eastern tribes had taboo on raising pigs and favoured goose and cows that feed on herbs (humans and pigs can't digest grass wich is based on azot).
Re:Brain Parasites, California’s Hidden Health Problem by Spooky23 on Saturday September 08, 2012 @10:21AM (#4492973)
Not really -- pigs are really useful for cultivating land. You pen them in an area and they turn over the soil when they go "rooting" (foraging for roots and bugs).

Historically, pigs are a recycling engine as well. You set them loose on garbage pile and they eat all sorts of stuff, producing rich fertilizer in return.

This stuff all originates from the ancient Egyptian practices, and the reasoning for the taboos aren't precisely known. I always thought they had more to do with the people who kept the pigs -- who were (and still are today in Egypt) non-Muslim/Jews who are associated with garbage.

Re:Brain Parasites, California’s Hidden Health Problem by SlipperySlope on Saturday September 08, 2012 @03:08AM (#4492493)
Agree with your premise, but fault the probability of your conclusion due to the written record left by Hebrew scholars who described pigs as "unclean". Its easy to see how an animal that eats human feces could be viewed that way.
Re:Brain Parasites, California’s Hidden Health Problem by johnchristopher on Saturday September 08, 2012 @05:13AM (#4492624)
> Its easy to see how an animal that eats human feces could be viewed that way.

Not necessarily that easy. For example, they didn't think farmyard manure was unclean but nonetheless used it to grow vegetables. My intuition is that it's easier to remember pig as "filthy", "unclean", "kosher", "forbidden" than their place in a complex and ever moving ecological system. Written record left by scholars could be deductions made about the current state of things and its lost meanings (that's actually part of my intuition).

Re:Brain Parasites, California’s Hidden Health Problem by vectorbunny on Saturday September 08, 2012 @07:56AM (#4492799)
> Its easy to see how an animal that eats human feces could be viewed that way.

Pigs were considered unclean more for their consumption of human flesh than for their consumption of human feces. Geological conditions in the Levant meant that bodies were typically interred in crypts or caves rather that being buried 'six feet under' where the decomposition couldn't be smelled by scavengers.

Re:Brain Parasites, California’s Hidden Health Problem by batista on Saturday September 08, 2012 @05:29AM (#4492649)
Chickens eat human feces too, but they are not considered "unclean".

Plus, the one doesn't exclude the other. The taboo could be because of the reasons the parent mentioned, and the "unclean due to eating feces" could just be a post-fact rationalisation of it.

Re:Brain Parasites, California’s Hidden Health Problem by onetimeuse001 on Saturday September 08, 2012 @03:20AM (#4492509)
Their ability to eat everything is actually an asset, they're relatively easy to raise. Cows and sheep not so.

Any health issues are seen as a cost of doing business, after all they are a million ways to get sick and die in the third world.

Re:Brain Parasites, California’s Hidden Health Problem by SlipperySlope on Saturday September 08, 2012 @02:42AM (#4492459)
Perhaps the goal is simply stated, but the solutions are complex. The main resource lacking is education about proper pig husbandry.

See: http://cnia.inta.gov.ar/helminto/A%20Cisticercosis/Improving...