Re:What Does Palantir Actually Do?
by stephen_g on Thursday August 14, 2025 @07:37PM
(#44906989)
Exactly what I remember reading all the time about the Afghanistan war - the OP calls the Palantir tool 'incredible technology' but the one thing I remember seeing reported time and time and time again during that war was reports of strikes against civilians accidentally being targeted because their mobile phones had been nearby to insurgents (like maybe having visited the same mosque or the same family gathering)...
[ Parent
| on HN ]
There’s some nuance to understand about targeting flows and precision strikes, and why “incredible” is suitable term to use. Not that what you list out didn’t occur, certainly
Re:What Does Palantir Actually Do?
by reactordev on Thursday August 14, 2025 @09:10PM
(#44907582)
Exactly. In military terms - Incredible means highly capable
"Tenuous" is the ever present flip side of the "incredible" assertion, of course.
> There’s some nuance to understand about targeting flows and precision strikes
There's a lot of "nuance". From understanding that these systems will always "need" to target and strike, and they'll always find an enemy to strike at because it's their sole reason to exist, to the arbitrary definition of "precision" or "success".
The entire system and philosophy become redundant without guaranteed targets and weak without guaranteed success.
What it means today is that a random US citizen in the street can be a target, and arresting him up can mean success. Being infallible by definition is indeed incredible.
Re:What Does Palantir Actually Do?
by StopDisinfo910 on Friday August 15, 2025 @05:13AM
(#44910178)
The only thing incredible about "targeting flow" and "precision strikes" is the genius of the pentagone propagandists who coined these expressions and managed to have people use them and somehow believe there is any kind of subtleties in the way this war was fought.
Re:What Does Palantir Actually Do?
by michael1999 on Friday August 15, 2025 @10:56AM
(#44913228)
The number of times the US bombed a wedding because the comms traffic looks the same as a big op was evil.
I'm not a conspiracy theory person, but if I wanted to ensure a perpetuation of terrorism and consequently ever-present wars in the Middle East, I wouldn't do this any other way.
Fucks like Bibi do this successfully (propping up Hamas in detriment of democratic movements). Why wouldn't the MIC do it as well?