Re:Can't pay, won't pay: streaming services are driving view...
by nosioptar on Thursday August 14, 2025 @06:27PM
(#44906436)
There's also a DVD release of the theatrical versions. Usually goes for $50-75 for OG trilogy.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Can't pay, won't pay: streaming services are driving view...
by LeifCarrotson on Thursday August 14, 2025 @07:04PM
(#44906760)
DVDs are 480i, the parent comment described far higher quality than DVD.
Re:Can't pay, won't pay: streaming services are driving view...
by pezezin on Thursday August 14, 2025 @08:29PM
(#44907344)
DVDs support progressive scan and most movies were encoded in 480p; the player then just sent half the picture on one field and the other half on the other field.
Your point still stand though, these modern 4k editions are far higher quality.
Re:Can't pay, won't pay: streaming services are driving view...
by scheeseman486 on Thursday August 14, 2025 @09:52PM
(#44907789)
The DVD releases of the original theatrical versions of Star Wars were encoded in 480i non-anamorphic, drawn from analog video masters intended for Laserdisc, which employed an early version of DNR that created a bunch of ugly temporal ghosting artifacts. Blown up onto a modern display it looks really bad.
Re:Can't pay, won't pay: streaming services are driving view...
by pezezin on Thursday August 14, 2025 @10:11PM
(#44907889)
I watched the PAL edition and I don't remember those artifacts, but it was a million years ago so my memory could be wrong xD
Re:Can't pay, won't pay: streaming services are driving view...
by scheeseman486 on Friday August 15, 2025 @02:31AM
(#44909232)
The PAL release was an NTSC>PAL conversion, so throw upscaling artifacts onto the pile as well. e: Actually thinking back on it, it may not even have been PAL at all, but 480i/60hz Region 2/4.
There's a good chance you watched it on a CRT given that even on a flat panel LCD fom the late 2000s the low vertical resolution was quite noticeable (effectively ~272p, not counting deinterlacing artifacts from it being sourced from a video master). It looked somewhat acceptable in that context but aged very quickly once CRTs started becoming obsolete.
Re:Can't pay, won't pay: streaming services are driving view...
by pezezin on Saturday August 16, 2025 @01:30AM
(#44920459)
I remembered that I borrowed the collection from my uncle and he still has it. I will ask him for pictures of the box, maybe it was the "updated" editions.
Re:Can't pay, won't pay: streaming services are driving view...
by scheeseman486 on Saturday August 16, 2025 @01:49AM
(#44920558)
The re-issues used the same masters.