Re:Brilliant illustrations bring this 1976 Soviet edition of...
by bananaflag on Thursday August 14, 2025 @11:08AM
(#44901322)
Re:Brilliant illustrations bring this 1976 Soviet edition of...
by bombcar on Friday August 15, 2025 @08:01AM
(#44911303)
I don’t find “small” in reference to Gollum, but the leap does provide some maximum size limits.
Re:Brilliant illustrations bring this 1976 Soviet edition of...
by WillAdams on Thursday August 14, 2025 @08:52PM
(#44907479)
There is a Facsimile Gift Edition which is pretty affordable:
https://www.amazon.com/Hobbit-Facsimile-Gift-Tolkien-author/...
Or, the differences in the texts are pretty thoroughly hashed out in:
https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/12973638-the-history-of-...
which contains an annotated (and analyzed) text of the first edition.
The primary retconning occurred in 1951, when the encounter in The Hobbit between Bilbo and Gollum was rewritten to be confrontational rather than amicable, because TLOTR now needed the Ring to have a malevolent influence. The retconning is reflected in Bilbo's apology in the Council of Elrond to those (i.e. Gloin, but implicitly the readers) who may have heard a different version of his story. I'd love to see a first edition of the Hobbit to see what Tolkien actually did say about Gollum.
[Edit]. Just checked my (third edition) copy of The Hobbit. It only says that Gollum was "a small slimy creature" who "had a little boat". There aren't any other descriptions of their relative size, except that Bilbo actually jumps over Gollum's head when escaping him (Gollum is crouched down at this point), as a sibling comment has just observed.