News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Kindle Fire HD 8.9 vs. iPad 3: Is the Apple Experience re... by mtgx on Friday September 07, 2012 @12:26PM (#4489876)
Amazon is going to commoditize the entire tablet market, simply because they don't care about making profits on hardware, while everyone else, including Apple, does.

Microsoft is going to feel this as well, as manufacturers won't be very happy selling $200-$300 tablets with $100 ($200 for enterprise versions) Windows licenses. The tablet market is going to be commoditezed so much faster than the PC market. Hopefully, Amazon launches a smartphone with a similar strategy as well.

Intel will invariably be hurt by this, too, as people move to much cheaper, yet capable devices. Even if they succeed entering the tablet market with their Atom chips, they'll be be forced to have very competitive prices with ARM chips. So instead of selling $200 chips for ultrabooks and PC's, they'll be selling $20 chips. There's no way they can make it up in volume to keep or increase their current revenues and profits.

Re:Kindle Fire HD 8.9 vs. iPad 3: Is the Apple Experience re... by greedo on Friday September 07, 2012 @02:03PM (#4490358)
And Amazon will always trail in terms of innovation, because selling things at a loss doesn't give you much room to spend on R&D.

And your view of history is skewed; IBM released the PC (5150) in 1981. Compaq shipped the first compatible in 1982, and by 1985 the PC market was thoroughly commoditized.

Jump to the iPad's release in 2010. It's been 2 1/2 years, and still no signs of the tablet market being commoditized. It's still an iPad market, and not a tablet market.

Re:Kindle Fire HD 8.9 vs. iPad 3: Is the Apple Experience re... by jerf on Friday September 07, 2012 @02:25PM (#4490471)
Innovation doesn't run forever. What's left to innovate on a tablet's hardware? Non-zero, but it's not like next year Apple's going to equip them with little robotic arms and legs or anything. There's more room for innovation in the laptop market, and that's a market that hasn't been driven by very much "innovation" for a long time.

Innovation isn't a magic word you can just wave around like a mantra, it has to concretize into something real if it's going to have any effect. There is, quite literally, not much room left for tablet innovation.

Re:Kindle Fire HD 8.9 vs. iPad 3: Is the Apple Experience re... by greedo on Friday September 07, 2012 @02:58PM (#4490625)
Wow. I guess I disagree with you about the innovation in the laptop market. I showed my wife the MacBook Air yesterday, and she was amazed at how different it was from the stuff she was used to.

And your argument about "what's left to innovate on a tablet's hardware" is also pretty shortsighted. I'm sure that you had the foresight to predict the iPad?

Change and innovation aren't magic. But saying that there's no more room for innovation has been proven wrong, time and time again.

Re:Kindle Fire HD 8.9 vs. iPad 3: Is the Apple Experience re... by jerf on Friday September 07, 2012 @03:31PM (#4490770)
My saying it was "non-zero" is an important part of my point. It isn't zero. But it isn't going to be the driver of the market anymore. Just as your MacBook Air is merely "an interesting offering" and not an "OMG this rewrites everything!". (It was hyped that way at the time but I don't think it worked. The iPhone killed everything that came before it. The Air certainly did not; laptops are alive and well.)

"Trailing in innovation" to grab market share is probably a very good move at this point.

I know it's chic to talk a lot about innovation, but take a serious look around yourself and what you'll find surrounding you on all sides are markets of incremental improvements, not "innovation"-driven markets. I think the tablet market is here now, or very nearly.

Re:Kindle Fire HD 8.9 vs. iPad 3: Is the Apple Experience re... by greedo on Friday September 07, 2012 @03:44PM (#4490829)
I guess we have to disagree about the Air. I don't think it revolutionized computing, but it was a huge shift for notebooks.

And grabbing market share with no foreseeable plan for decent profits seems hard to sell, but Wall St. seems to love Amazon.

Re:Kindle Fire HD 8.9 vs. iPad 3: Is the Apple Experience re... by jerf on Friday September 07, 2012 @03:58PM (#4490896)
Of course Amazon has a plan for profits. They've all but spelled it out, sell the hardware to sell the services. "They don't have a plan" != "I don't think their plan will work", or whatever else you've got on the right side of that !=.
Re:Kindle Fire HD 8.9 vs. iPad 3: Is the Apple Experience re... by greedo on Friday September 07, 2012 @04:18PM (#4490997)
I meant in more general terms for Amazon. Their margins are incredibly low, their P/E ratio is way out of whack, and they seem to epitomize the old "we'll make it up on volume" angle that proved so helpful in 2000.

Maybe they just want to be like a grocery chain that ekes out a 1-3% margin. But if that's the case, Wall St. won't be happy. Wall St. expects outsized profits based on their P/E ratio.

Re:Kindle Fire HD 8.9 vs. iPad 3: Is the Apple Experience re... by gfodor on Friday September 07, 2012 @03:03PM (#4490640)
He's just saying there is little room for innovation in the tablet hardware space. I'd tend to agree. Once all tablets are light, responsive, high resolution, reasonably powered (RAM/CPU), and have all the standard frills you're really past the point of diminishing returns IMHO. There's not much you can do with an iPad 3 you could't do with the first iPad, though it's a nicer experience. The iPad 6 is probably going to be much less of a leap from the iPad 3 than the 3 was from the original.
Re:Kindle Fire HD 8.9 vs. iPad 3: Is the Apple Experience re... by greedo on Friday September 07, 2012 @03:23PM (#4490731)
And again, that's 20/20 hindsight. Go look at the tablets that were on sale in 2009. Do you think that the innovation fairy just started shooting Skittles out that magically gave the iPad a huge leap? Innovation isn't always in engineering terms, boosting cycles etc. Sometimes it's in reimagining how things can be done.

Even a technology considered relatively mature (cars) changes a lot, in subtle yet important details.

Just because you can't foresee change in existing markets doesn't mean it won't occur.

Re:Kindle Fire HD 8.9 vs. iPad 3: Is the Apple Experience re... by ido on Friday September 07, 2012 @03:07PM (#4490657)
It did take it quite a while to get really cheap tho - I remember reading a PC magazine article in the late 90s declaring the arrival of the till-then mythical "$1000 PC" era - computers used to cost $2-3k, and these are USDs of 2-3 decades ago (probably worth double in today's dollars). if you spend $1k on a pc desktop today you'll get absolute top of the line hardware, even $500 will get you a solid mid-range desktop.

only in the last ~5 years with the arrival of netbooks did we start seeing PCs get really, really cheap.

Re:Kindle Fire HD 8.9 vs. iPad 3: Is the Apple Experience re... by greedo on Friday September 07, 2012 @03:41PM (#4490813)
Agreed. Relatively speaking, an iPad (with far more horsepower than the Dell XP I bought in 1994) is a tremendous bargain. Adjusted for inflation that would be $385 in 1994 (for a $600 iPad).
Re:Kindle Fire HD 8.9 vs. iPad 3: Is the Apple Experience re... by enraged_camel on Friday September 07, 2012 @12:41PM (#4489951)
I've always been of the opinion that while cheaper prices are good for consumers, commoditization is not. When products in a field become commoditized, profit margins fall drastically, and so do companies' incentives to innovate in that space. Think about it: when was the last time we saw a totally innovative toothpaste or a laundry detergent? The answer is never.
Re:Kindle Fire HD 8.9 vs. iPad 3: Is the Apple Experience re... by takluyver on Friday September 07, 2012 @12:54PM (#4490032)
To play devil's advocate, how much innovation is needed for toothpaste? It works, it's safe, and it's not unpleasant to use. Maybe consumers benefit more from having cheap commoditised toothpaste than they would from paying extra to stimulate innovation.
Re:Kindle Fire HD 8.9 vs. iPad 3: Is the Apple Experience re... by jad on Friday September 07, 2012 @01:38PM (#4490239)
> To play devil's advocate, how much innovation is needed for toothpaste?

Having the market structured such that innovation is rewarded might not be important in toothpaste, but it's really important in technology. Commoditization can kill innovation in a technology market, which is exactly what happened with PCs once Windows reached monopoly market share.

Re:Kindle Fire HD 8.9 vs. iPad 3: Is the Apple Experience re... by davidw on Friday September 07, 2012 @01:41PM (#4490256)
Monopolies != commodities.

I suppose there are corner cases where they could be, but they're two rather different things.

Re:Kindle Fire HD 8.9 vs. iPad 3: Is the Apple Experience re... by jad on Friday September 07, 2012 @06:44PM (#4491562)
Right. I was saying that in the PC industry, it was the Windows monopoly that commoditized PC hardware. I wasn't saying that every monopoly necessarily leads to commoditization.
Re:Kindle Fire HD 8.9 vs. iPad 3: Is the Apple Experience re... by kalid on Friday September 07, 2012 @02:44PM (#4490557)
Just a thought -- there's lots of little packaging innovations that, collectively, make commodity products better to use.

Ketchup bottles: store upside down, wide mouth

Toothpaste: flat tops you can store vertically

Toothbrushes: grips, padding, strips, etc.

Even slicing bread is a huge innovation [how annoying is it to make a sandwich otherwise?].

Re:Kindle Fire HD 8.9 vs. iPad 3: Is the Apple Experience re... by JoshTriplett on Friday September 07, 2012 @01:04PM (#4490076)
How about the last toothpaste you'd ever have to use: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4213679

That's the problem with not innovating: you don't know what you're giving up.

Re:Kindle Fire HD 8.9 vs. iPad 3: Is the Apple Experience re... by takluyver on Friday September 07, 2012 @01:20PM (#4490147)
Even if that was possible, which I'm sceptical of (you can already get toothpaste with antibiotics, you still need to use it regularly), I doubt that companies making a comfortable profit margin from non-commoditised toothpaste would be interested in that kind of innovation. They would stand to lose a lot from it. A new company could emerge with it, but they could equally disrupt a commoditised market.
Re:Kindle Fire HD 8.9 vs. iPad 3: Is the Apple Experience re... by Too on Friday September 07, 2012 @03:29PM (#4490756)
Interesting that you bring up toothbrushes. Actually some company spent tons of money and time to come up with THE ULTIMATE shape for a toothbrush. They tried all different shapes, twists, angles and grips. The result? Simple straight toothbrushes are the most ergonomic and effective shapes.
Re:Kindle Fire HD 8.9 vs. iPad 3: Is the Apple Experience re... by Steko on Friday September 07, 2012 @03:36PM (#4490790)
"they don't care about making profits on hardware, while everyone else, including Apple, does."

(1) Amazon has turned a profit on all of their hardware afaik. They may change their mind as they go for a landgrab but to say they don't care is not exactly true.

(2) You can make the same argument that Google and Microsoft don't care about making money on hardware. You can say "but Google and Microsoft rely on third parties" which is historically the case but less so today.

(3) Amazon cuts corners to get to a shock price. If the tablet is "not good enough" as they say then you can't commoditize it yet because the latest specs are worthy of chasing.

(3a) Amazon's high end machine in two and a half months has a SoC that's graphically comparable to what Apple started shipping in March 2011 [1].

(3b) The original Kindle Fire advertised 8 hours of btty life and delivered 6 hours [2]. KF HD doesn't even advertise one that I've seen. If it's 6 hours that's basically unusable for most people. The iPad doesn't last 10 hours because it's a convenient amount of batteries to put in a case of predetermined size. It lasts 10 hours because that's the minimum use case they determined for much of the market (students, professionals, readers, travelers) and things like the thickness of the ipad were driven by the amount of batteries you needed to get to 10 hours.

[1] http://www.anandtech.com/show/6158/the-archos-101-xs-review/...

[2] http://www.anandtech.com/show/5128/amazon-kindle-fire-review...

Re:Kindle Fire HD 8.9 vs. iPad 3: Is the Apple Experience re... by cooldeal on Friday September 07, 2012 @02:02PM (#4490353)
>Microsoft is going to feel this as well, as manufacturers won't be very happy selling $200-$300 tablets with $100 ($200 for enterprise versions) Windows licenses.

That does not make any sense. If you think Windows 8 Pro x86 tablets like the Surface Pro(running an Intel Core i5) are competing with the Kindles on features and price, think again. They will be expensive, but far more capable and powerful(heavier and less battery life too). For example, they can run the full Visual Studio or Eclipse.

You can take a Surface Pro and a Kindle Fire with you, run Eclipse with the Android SDK loaded, connect the Kindle Fire to the Surface and take the program you just wrote on the Surface and run it on the Kindle! Or write your code while on a roadtrip or on the subway and debug it on your Android or Windows phone(don't know how Hackintosh it can get for running apps on the iPhone).

Can you do that with a Kindle, iPad or any other tablet on the market right now, which are used by most people as consumption devices?

Where Microsoft is competing with the Kindle, Android tablets and the iPad is with Windows RT, which is a different beast(and costs less than $100 for OEMs + they are rumored to get kickbacks on ecosystem sales). The only big advantage Microsoft has right now in this space is Office RT.

Re:Kindle Fire HD 8.9 vs. iPad 3: Is the Apple Experience re... by randallu on Friday September 07, 2012 @02:37PM (#4490529)
You can't do it on a tablet right now, but it's a software problem, not a hardware one.

The Galaxy Note 10.1 ships with 2GB RAM and a good SoC. It's more powerful in every way than the PC I was using 5 years ago to write media player UIs.

I don't know when we'll start seeing things like Eclipse running on Android tablets, or if instead app development will trend to HTML and we'll see web-based tooling around that, but I do think that it is on the cards.

I also can't imagine that the Surface tablets (ARM or x86) are going to sell well at all. Not as good as an iPad for tablet things, not as good as a laptop for Office things.

Re:Kindle Fire HD 8.9 vs. iPad 3: Is the Apple Experience re... by cooldeal on Friday September 07, 2012 @05:07PM (#4491177)
>It's more powerful in every way than the PC I was using 5 years ago to write media player UIs.

I agree about the quantity of RAM and probably even the GPU, but is there a raw comparison of the CPUs(not just cores and GHz? I strongly suspect your 5 yr old x86 PC is much more powerful than the ARM one in the Galaxy note.

>I don't know when we'll start seeing things like Eclipse running on Android tablets, or if instead app development will trend to HTML and we'll see web-based tooling around that, but I do think that it is on the cards.

I sure wish Eclipse would get on to Android instead of devs moving to HTML just because their tablet does not support a full-on IDE or programming platform.

>I also can't imagine that the Surface tablets (ARM or x86) are going to sell well at all. Not as good as an iPad for tablet things, not as good as a laptop for Office things.

This reminds me of the folks that discounted the iPad because it was not good as a smartphone for portability(oversized iPod Touch) and much less powerful than a laptop.

I agree that the Surface Pro is trying to create a new market here, but I do think there is a big market of people who want a no-compromises powerful portable tablet for on-the-go use.

Re:Kindle Fire HD 8.9 vs. iPad 3: Is the Apple Experience re... by larsberg on Friday September 07, 2012 @02:43PM (#4490555)
> but far more capable and powerful

Also, since they're full versions of Windows, they should just be able to access Hulu, Evernote, and all the other services that expect you to pay extra if you choose to use them on an anemic mobile device.