Re:Kindle Fire HD 8.9 vs. iPad 3: Is the Apple Experience re...
by takluyver on Friday September 07, 2012 @12:54PM
(#4490032)
To play devil's advocate, how much innovation is needed for toothpaste? It works, it's safe, and it's not unpleasant to use. Maybe consumers benefit more from having cheap commoditised toothpaste than they would from paying extra to stimulate innovation.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Kindle Fire HD 8.9 vs. iPad 3: Is the Apple Experience re...
by jad on Friday September 07, 2012 @01:38PM
(#4490239)
> To play devil's advocate, how much innovation is needed for toothpaste?
Having the market structured such that innovation is rewarded might not be important in toothpaste, but it's really important in technology. Commoditization can kill innovation in a technology market, which is exactly what happened with PCs once Windows reached monopoly market share.
Re:Kindle Fire HD 8.9 vs. iPad 3: Is the Apple Experience re...
by davidw on Friday September 07, 2012 @01:41PM
(#4490256)
Monopolies != commodities.
I suppose there are corner cases where they could be, but they're two rather different things.
Re:Kindle Fire HD 8.9 vs. iPad 3: Is the Apple Experience re...
by jad on Friday September 07, 2012 @06:44PM
(#4491562)
Right. I was saying that in the PC industry, it was the Windows monopoly that commoditized PC hardware. I wasn't saying that every monopoly necessarily leads to commoditization.
Re:Kindle Fire HD 8.9 vs. iPad 3: Is the Apple Experience re...
by kalid on Friday September 07, 2012 @02:44PM
(#4490557)
Just a thought -- there's lots of little packaging innovations that, collectively, make commodity products better to use.
Ketchup bottles: store upside down, wide mouth
Toothpaste: flat tops you can store vertically
Toothbrushes: grips, padding, strips, etc.
Even slicing bread is a huge innovation [how annoying is it to make a sandwich otherwise?].
Re:Kindle Fire HD 8.9 vs. iPad 3: Is the Apple Experience re...
by JoshTriplett on Friday September 07, 2012 @01:04PM
(#4490076)
How about the last toothpaste you'd ever have to use: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4213679
That's the problem with not innovating: you don't know what you're giving up.
Re:Kindle Fire HD 8.9 vs. iPad 3: Is the Apple Experience re...
by takluyver on Friday September 07, 2012 @01:20PM
(#4490147)
Even if that was possible, which I'm sceptical of (you can already get toothpaste with antibiotics, you still need to use it regularly), I doubt that companies making a comfortable profit margin from non-commoditised toothpaste would be interested in that kind of innovation. They would stand to lose a lot from it. A new company could emerge with it, but they could equally disrupt a commoditised market.