Re:1948: Catholic Church Publishes Final Edition of "Index L...
by graemep on Wednesday August 13, 2025 @10:58AM
(#44889331)
What about "You shall not kill". There are quite a tradition of exceptions. In self-defence (generally accepted), in war (widely accepted, although not by everyone, and always with limitations such as requiring the war is just), and for judicial punishment (although again only as a necessity, and the Catholic Church has said its not necessary under modern circumstances).
Re:1948: Catholic Church Publishes Final Edition of "Index L...
by boxed on Thursday August 14, 2025 @09:36AM
(#44900230)
The bible doesn't say that. It says "you shouldn't murder" where "murder" means "kill a human without just cause". The standard "thou shalt not kill" is a bad translation, nothing more.
You can tell that it is from context as the laws just after that mandates a LOT of killing. For being "a witch" for example (which I assume is another mistranslation).
Re:1948: Catholic Church Publishes Final Edition of "Index L...
by 1718627440 on Thursday August 14, 2025 @10:15AM
(#44900646)
Violence can be correct in self-defence and war, but being in self-defense is not enough to justify it alone.
That's a far stretch. How is "keep the sabbath holy" a "general principle" in any way? How is "thou shalt have no other gods before me"?