Re:Nukes, Nubs And Coners: The Social Hierarchy Aboard A Nuc...
by FirmwareBurner on Monday August 11, 2025 @09:11AM
(#44863693)
Firing rounds inside a nuclear submarine? Isn't it like firing a gun inside a plane?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Nukes, Nubs And Coners: The Social Hierarchy Aboard A Nuc...
by rtkwe on Monday August 11, 2025 @10:04AM
(#44864200)
It's definitely a thing you don't do without good reason (enemy boarding action/mutiny) but remember subs are designed to survive nearby explosions underwater; there's redundancy and there's massive amounts of time spent training damage control where your repair or work around damaged systems.
Re:Nukes, Nubs And Coners: The Social Hierarchy Aboard A Nuc...
by John23832 on Monday August 11, 2025 @09:14AM
(#44863709)
Yes. What's wrong with that?
A 9mm, buck shot, or even a 556 (which they are not using on a sub) is not piercing the pressure hull of a submarine. That's before considering all the other mass of metal and matter within the sub.
Re:Nukes, Nubs And Coners: The Social Hierarchy Aboard A Nuc...
by esseph on Monday August 11, 2025 @10:33AM
(#44864568)
5.56 is fine in a sub.
Technically firing a .50 / 12.7mm should be fine for the hull even with API.
Bulkheads are thick.
(Note: SynTech / frangible ammo preferred)
Re:Nukes, Nubs And Coners: The Social Hierarchy Aboard A Nuc...
by John23832 on Monday August 11, 2025 @12:52PM
(#44866483)
I really meant that at the ranges that you would probably be engaging at in a sub (sub 10ft) a 556 is not the correct round to use.
Re:Nukes, Nubs And Coners: The Social Hierarchy Aboard A Nuc...
by esseph on Monday August 11, 2025 @06:41PM
(#44870290)
Oh, valid!
Just thinking through Navy issued small arms. Lots of M4s and M17/M18.
Re:Nukes, Nubs And Coners: The Social Hierarchy Aboard A Nuc...
by exar0815 on Monday August 11, 2025 @09:42AM
(#44863967)
There are a lot of things that don't react well to bullets in a submarine. One Jack Ryan comes to mind...
Re:Nukes, Nubs And Coners: The Social Hierarchy Aboard A Nuc...
by happytoexplain on Monday August 11, 2025 @09:17AM
(#44863736)
I mean, I guess there's more risk of ricochets and equipment damage on a sub than a ship? Regardless, a lot of "don't do that" things become "you might have to do that" things in a combat scenario.