Re:Try and
by umanwizard on Sunday August 10, 2025 @11:53AM
(#44856026)
Linguists don’t say varieties are right or wrong (even though they might have private aesthetic opinions like everyone else). That would be like a biologist saying dogs are the correct version of mammals and cats are wrong and/or don’t exist.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Biologists actually say the opposite of that!
https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/cats-are-perfect-...
Just because someone has a degree and a job in the field doesn't mean they understand how science works. Prescriptive biology is even sillier than prescriptive linguistics.
I think her tongue is planted firmly in cheek.
There do exist prescriptivist linguists, who do exactly that: they try to divine "correct" from "incorrect" usage of language.
Re:Try and
by umanwizard on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @09:07AM
(#44875780)
> There do exist prescriptivist linguists
That is not true, at least in mainstream serious academia. Prescriptive linguistics doesn’t exist any more than prescriptive biology or astronomy.
Maybe in the USA. But bodies like the French Academy and many similar ones in other countries very much do issue opinions on correct grammatical (and vocabulary) usage. And members of these institutions are very much considered the top of their field in their countries.
Re:Try and
by umanwizard on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @06:22PM
(#44882469)
The members of the French Academy are not linguists. They are mostly writers or academics from other fields (history, philosophy, etc). If you can read French, check here: https://www.academie-francaise.fr/les-immortels/les-quarante...
> And members of these institutions are very much considered the top of their field in their countries.
Maybe, but their field isn't linguistics.