News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Galaxy S III beats out iPhone 4S as top selling device in US by josteink on Wednesday September 05, 2012 @09:23AM (#4479201)
While comments about iPhone 5 being due soon is probably correct, I suspect this is the first visible sign of a tend which began quite a while ago: iPhone has peaked (just like the iPod did) and right now Android us exploding everywhere.

The question is just when we officially start treating iOS as the minority OS, the one we develop for last.

To those thinking I disregard Windows 8 tablets, I don't. I know they're out really soon now, but it's just too early to predict its impact on the market. My guess is that it will eat into both Android and iOS's market-share for tablets, but how much is impossible to say.

Re:Galaxy S III beats out iPhone 4S as top selling device in US by X-Istence on Wednesday September 05, 2012 @10:24AM (#4479485)
Until the iOS market for apps becomes small enough that developing for it is no longer guaranteed returns I will continue to develop for iOS.

The biggest issue is that on the Android Market Place (Play store or whatever they are calling it these days) I still can't make as much money as on the Apple App Store for iOS.

Releasing a free app with ads just doesn't work for me. So in the long run, until it becomes no longer cost effective it is going to be a long time before I switch to treating iOS as my secondary platform and Android as my primary.

Re:Galaxy S III beats out iPhone 4S as top selling device in US by cageface on Wednesday September 05, 2012 @10:06AM (#4479396)
The technorati are still mostly running iOS and as long as the opinion makers favor it the people that make apps to impress that crowd will make iOS a priority. iOS also makes it easier to make the kind of overly fussy photoshopped UIs that people with too much time on their hands fetishize.

But Android has already gone from optional extra to mandatory second platform for any serious consumer-facing app and the sheer number of users is going to make it increasingly important for those for whom an app is just a part of a larger business, i.e. the people that will be supplying the bulk of the capital in the mobile app business.

Re:Galaxy S III beats out iPhone 4S as top selling device in US by joeguilmette on Wednesday September 05, 2012 @09:37AM (#4479263)
Your judgement seems a bit hasty. Comparing sales of a flagship phone on launch week to sales of a one year old phone (that is a spruced up 2.5 year old phone) one week before a replacement is due seems a bit... Ridiculous?

Why dont we compare all of Android sales for the last half of September and see how they look against the new iPhone.

Re:Galaxy S III beats out iPhone 4S as top selling device in US by MatthewPhillips on Wednesday September 05, 2012 @09:46AM (#4479300)
> Why dont we compare all of Android sales for the last half of September and see how they look against the new iPhone.

Doing so wouldn't tell us anything about trends.

Re:Galaxy S III beats out iPhone 4S as top selling device in US by tobylane on Wednesday September 05, 2012 @05:39PM (#4481602)
When would? iPhone sales are very predictable, strong now and coming up to Christmas (plus any other major contract ending time that I'm not aware of). If you're aiming to be flattering to one side it's too easy.
Re:Galaxy S III beats out iPhone 4S as top selling device in US by nodemaker on Wednesday September 05, 2012 @09:33AM (#4479248)
> The question is just when we officially start treating iOS as the minority OS, the one we develop for last.

At least for me(as an indie dev), probably never. Developing for the Android is not enjoyable at all.

Re:Galaxy S III beats out iPhone 4S as top selling device in US by cageface on Wednesday September 05, 2012 @09:56AM (#4479348)
So far I'm finding it remarkably pleasant. Some things are more difficult than iOS but some things are vastly easier. Maybe my opinion will change over time but I don't see either platform as a clear winner for the developer.

If anything I think there's an opportunity for somebody to make a Rails of mobile dev. It's a lot more work on either side than it really has to be most of the time.

Re:Galaxy S III beats out iPhone 4S as top selling device in US by myko on Wednesday September 05, 2012 @10:10AM (#4479414)
This is my experience as well, it is certainly a give and take.

Java isn't my favorite language to use and I really prefer Objective-C, but Xcode is a huge annoyance as well. I would say I prefer Android development as it is my favored OS to use but neither blow the other away as far as development fun.

Re:Galaxy S III beats out iPhone 4S as top selling device in US by option_greek on Wednesday September 05, 2012 @09:46AM (#4479301)
I'm curious about what makes android development not enjoyable. Is it the fragmentation or development tools or low economic incentive ?
Re:Galaxy S III beats out iPhone 4S as top selling device in US by yuriyg on Wednesday September 05, 2012 @09:52AM (#4479328)
Not trying to troll here, but can someone explain this "fragmentation" issue please? There's a single API for Android; there are also different versions of the API, but there's a same issue in iOS. Is the issue the different screen resolutions? Does all the Android developement require low-level access to hardware?
Re:Galaxy S III beats out iPhone 4S as top selling device in US by X-Istence on Wednesday September 05, 2012 @10:33AM (#4479532)
The biggest issue with fragmentation is the extra hardware and the screen size.

The company I work for does Android development for the gov't, and we have had a lot of issues with difference in camera support for example. Yes, there is one API, but for each camera in a phone it behaves slightly differently.

The worst still is the different screen sizes. It will look and work perfectly on one or two devices, and then you try it on a third and all of the elements are laid out differently or are rendered wrong and we have to add a work-around for that specific device.

The other issue we have found is the different versions of the libraries that various different versions of Android ship with. For example BouncyCastle is extremely outdated, or sqlite versions differ enough that it works on one device but doesn't work on the other.

We've also had issues with the phone switching between the cellular network and then wifi whereby sometimes our app will get sent up to 50 notifications in rapid fire saying it is switching between the two, which causes our app to tear down/restart the connection process. We ended up putting a timer in that waits a couple seconds and uses the last notification that came in ...

That's not to say that iOS development also doesn't have its issues. I had one app that if you used the switch on the iPad for screen orientation lock that it wouldn't output sound due to the switch not being recognised correctly. A bug that still exists in the latest version of iOS, and still hasn't been fixed (here is hoping for iOS 6 (which I have not yet installed on this device), my radar got closed as duplicate). But iOS has less of an issue with fragmentation due to the fact that most of the hardware is the same, and people with iOS devices tend to upgrade en masse to the latest version when it is released so it becomes less of an issue to have an app require a new version of iOS and no longer function on older versions of iOS (although, I am still targeting iOS 4 for now when doing consulting/client work).

Re:Galaxy S III beats out iPhone 4S as top selling device in US by wcarey on Wednesday September 05, 2012 @01:43PM (#4480446)
We've also run into some interesting documentation fragmentation points. Let's say you make an app for relatively technically unsophisticated users. You need them to drag some files to a folder on their SD card (the files are so large that you don't want to try and move them over a network). To do that, they need to mount their SD card on their computer's file system. How do you write the documentation that explains that?

Some mount to the file system as USB mass storage. Some devices call it "Disk Drive" mode. Some have a button called "Mount USB". Sometimes the button's in the notification bar. Sometimes it's in the settings. Some Android devices use MTP and the user doesn't have to do anything (but the names of the folders are different!).

You either get to write documentation like a choose-your-own-adventure novel or deal with confused users.

Re:Galaxy S III beats out iPhone 4S as top selling device in US by MatthewPhillips on Wednesday September 05, 2012 @11:40AM (#4479821)
Thanks for your comments. I was hoping you would elaborate on what makes the screen sizes so problematic? Web developers have had to deal with different screen sizes and different resolutions for a long time. Luckily we have CSS which makes it much easier (and especially now with media queries). Is it that Android layout doesn't give you enough control?
Re:Galaxy S III beats out iPhone 4S as top selling device in US by X-Istence on Wednesday September 05, 2012 @01:18PM (#4480317)
The issue isn't layout control, although that could definitely be better, the issue is that even with all their fancy auto-resizing everything sometimes depending on the device/OS version you HAVE to hard code a pixel perfect layout or it just won't render correctly.

This means that even if you use Android's layout tools and create automatically resizing and fitting layouts it may not work correctly, and render incorrectly for example when you move from landscape to portrait, or move from one screen to the next. Highly annoying.

We've also had bugs that we could not reproduce on any of our test devices (all 27 of them that we have now ...) but that a customer had out in the field. We then attempt to locate the same device with the same OS version to test on.

Sometimes it has to do with themes that a manufacturer has installed not working correctly... this gets annoying fast when you've got the same phone on multiple carriers and they each customise it their own way.

Re:Galaxy S III beats out iPhone 4S as top selling device in US by kalid on Wednesday September 05, 2012 @11:55AM (#4479914)
Take a look at http://opensignalmaps.com/reports/fragmentation.php

Android manufacturers & carriers have little incentive to get you to upgrade [Apple sidesteps them and delivers updates directly]. Do you want to target a several-years-old platform to guarantee the most access?

Screen sizes are also a challenge. iOS (iPhone + iPad) has 4 different ones to choose from. Android has... a lot more than that.

Fluid layouts usually don't work that well -- awkward spacing here, awkward wrapping there. Notice how many web frameworks use fixed-width columns (like Twitter Bootstrap).

Re:Galaxy S III beats out iPhone 4S as top selling device in US by option_greek on Wednesday September 05, 2012 @10:08AM (#4479404)
It refers to different Android versions on phones which results in developers being forced to test their applications against a lot of versions. Usually like in the case of iOS this would not have been a problem but Android updates are notoriously slow due to various reasons which means that most of the Android users are still stuck on gingerbread while jelly bean is already out. This means developers can't reliably take advantage of features added in newer versions of OS. Of course all this even before we consider the screen sizes.
Re:Galaxy S III beats out iPhone 4S as top selling device in US by cageface on Wednesday September 05, 2012 @10:31AM (#4479519)
The way Android layouts work and the backporting Google has done relieves a lot of this pain and you can now support only 2.3 and up and still get the majority of users.

If you want to get the kind of pixel-perfect layouts people have come to expect on the iPhone then yes that's a hassle. But I suspect the trend is away from that kind of design towards more flexible, information-centric designs just as it's been on the web.

Re:Galaxy S III beats out iPhone 4S as top selling device in US by ryanhuff on Wednesday September 05, 2012 @01:47PM (#4480473)
20% of Android devices in the field are 2.2 or earlier. Its hard to tell a company that they should cut out 20% of their Android users in order to take advantage of the latest APIs.
Re:Galaxy S III beats out iPhone 4S as top selling device in US by cageface on Wednesday September 05, 2012 @02:58PM (#4480856)
Is it? My clients have all been fine with it. Going back to 2.2 isn't that hard but the people on those devices aren't likely to be very valuable customers.
Re:Galaxy S III beats out iPhone 4S as top selling device in US by vacri on Wednesday September 05, 2012 @07:42PM (#4482094)
Isn't it similar for pre-iphone 3 users, who also frequently get left out in the cold?
Re:Galaxy S III beats out iPhone 4S as top selling device in US by yuriyg on Wednesday September 05, 2012 @10:28AM (#4479506)
Isn't this a classic issue in software developement, where you have to require or assume some minimum OS version? Remember all those labels: "Windows 95 or higher required."

And especially with web developement, where you'd have to test your site on a various number of combinations of OS, browser, and resolution.

Re:Galaxy S III beats out iPhone 4S as top selling device in US by ceejayoz on Wednesday September 05, 2012 @10:31AM (#4479517)
> There's a single API for Android; there are also different versions of the API, but there's a same issue in iOS.

Not really, no. http://thenextweb.com/apple/2012/03/06/why-do-developers-pre...

Re:Galaxy S III beats out iPhone 4S as top selling device in US by flyosity on Wednesday September 05, 2012 @09:48AM (#4479308)
Yes.
Re:Galaxy S III beats out iPhone 4S as top selling device in US by matwood on Wednesday September 05, 2012 @01:04PM (#4480251)
iPhone has peaked (just like the iPod did) and right now Android us exploding everywhere.

I've been thinking the same thing, although it's hard to prove either way. I have owned the iPhone since the original version and recently got the N7 tablet and switched to the HTC 1x phone. Android hardware and software has come a long way since I tried it before buying the iPhone4 (my last phone). Before ICS, the Android HW/SW simply wasn't very good. It wasn't as responsive as the iPhone and certainly didn't feel as nice.

Re:Galaxy S III beats out iPhone 4S as top selling device in US by jsz0 on Wednesday September 05, 2012 @07:54PM (#4482126)
The question is just when we officially start treating iOS as the minority OS, the one we develop for last.

About 55% of iOS devices are iPhones. The other 45% are iPads and iPod Touches. On Android I don't think anyone knows the exact number but it's believed the vast majority of Android devices are SmartPhones. So in the end it evens about pretty close.

Re:Galaxy S III beats out iPhone 4S as top selling device in US by DeepDuh on Wednesday September 05, 2012 @08:38PM (#4482279)
That plus the percentage of iOS users actually buying apps is much higher than on Android. Apple's Appstore, as far as I understand, has still the biggest market volume for developers by a good margin.
Re:Galaxy S III beats out iPhone 4S as top selling device in US by snowwrestler on Wednesday September 05, 2012 @10:09AM (#4479411)
The key question for 3rd party developers is which platform will make them more money. My understanding is that iOS is still far and away the winner by that metric, even with the smaller installed base than Android.