Re:Palantir Is Extending Its Reach Even Further into Government
by _Algernon_ on Monday August 04, 2025 @10:17AM
(#44786135)
The argument that somebody else has better integrity and sense of duty representing my needs or wants is dead on arrival. Direct democracy is a representative democracy where each person has a representative.
Re:Palantir Is Extending Its Reach Even Further into Government
by bpt3 on Monday August 04, 2025 @10:43AM
(#44786499)
The founding fathers and many others would disagree. Based on human history, your assessment of the average human's level of integrity and reasoning is irrationally optimistic.
Also, I assume you meant to say "Direct democracy is a representative democracy where each person *is* a representative."
Re:Palantir Is Extending Its Reach Even Further into Government
by _Algernon_ on Monday August 04, 2025 @05:01PM
(#44791291)
It doesn't matter because everyone only has to represent themselves so they don't really need to have integrity or ability to reason in some larger sense, they just have to be selfish — which is a lot easier than reasoning your way to what maximizes societal good, or some average of the 100'000+ people you are supposedly representing.
And the amount of power an individual has is negligible so a bad vote is diluted much more than it is in a representative democracy.
Re:Palantir Is Extending Its Reach Even Further into Government
by bpt3 on Tuesday August 05, 2025 @09:55AM
(#44798015)
You realize that a certain "institution" would have died out much slower (if at all) in the US if what you said was accurate?
I think that's the only example needed to prove that direct democracy is not a desirable form of government, let alone the ideal.
That idea has always been tested, with the current times being the largest test in several decades at least.