Maybe Agile was one of these things, but then a bunch of people started doing it literally.
Re:If You're Remote, Ramble
by TimTheTinker on Sunday August 03, 2025 @11:29AM
(#44777245)
The original manifesto wasn't[0], but it's certainly likely a lot of cargo-cult "Agile" is.
Other way round, i think. The original form had a lot of weird practices which actually worked. The form most common today is just lip service.
The weird practices worked as reported, but as an accident of the context where they arose. Outside that, they're about as robust as really rare orchids, which I think to their credit the authors realized, hence all the "don't take our word for it!" with which they hedged around their wildly bestselling school of management consultancy.
I like to say that the outwardly visible practices and processes of highly effective teams are mostly symptoms, not causes of their success. You can't invert the causal relationship.
Re:If You're Remote, Ramble
by marcosdumay on Sunday August 03, 2025 @03:11PM
(#44778899)
> but then a bunch of people started doing it literally
Most people doing "agile" do literally the opposite of what is on the manifesto.
Lol yep. Our company decided “sprints” were now to last 4 weeks, but there’s also no task scheduling, no retro, no sprint planning… just tasks get given whenever they come up based on what they feel like.
So… what’s the point of a “sprint”? We don’t even do monthly releases. It’s hilarious.
I suspect we do “agile” in name only so they can pretend to the board that there is a system at all.
Re:If You're Remote, Ramble
by marcosdumay on Sunday August 03, 2025 @08:25PM
(#44781049)
You already got to oppose of the manifesto in the "Our company decided" part...
lol yep
Re:If You're Remote, Ramble
by quietbritishjim on Sunday August 03, 2025 @03:15PM
(#44778930)
Or maybe they know that saying something wrong gets more comments / "engagement" than something more reasonable.
This seems to happen a lot: Someone writes some highly exaggerated career advice that has good intent at the core but turns into overly weird suggestions by the end. They might be trying to be memorable or to make an impact by exaggerating the advice.
Then some people, often juniors, take it literally and start practicing it. They think they’re doing some secret that will make them the best employee. Their coworkers and managers are more confused than impressed and think it’s just a personality quirk.
As a manager I found it helpful to skim Reddit and other sites for semi-viral advice blogs like this. With enough juniors in a company there’s a chance one of them will suddenly start doing the thing written in a shared post like this. Knowing why they’re doing it is a good way to help defuse the behavior (assuming they don’t really benefit but rather do it because they perceive it will look good)