In my state, a full 1/3 of the population is on Medicaid ... which seems extremely high for a program originally intended for the poor.
From a financial standpoint, it doesn't seem like either party has succeeded at significantly slowing the growth in healthcare costs overall. How much more can it grow without breaking? The Dems haven't proposed a solution either.
There were two options that have been debated before:
* Obamacare’s deleted “public option” which would’ve essentially provided the baseline standard coverage introduced by the ACA; this got deleted due to opposition from moderates and so private insurers offer these plans instead
* Medicaid for All just proposes this entirely to remove layers of middlemen, but is even more opposed by moderates
——
The problem really is the linkage of health insurance to work, but it’s political suicide to sunset this since the transition period will be incredibly painful
I've long argued that this is precisely the problem with the American healthcare system. It's the worst of both worlds. The issue is caused by the fact that we use "insurance" to describe something that is not insurance, but rather a middleman subscription.
Could you imagine how broken any other market would be if saddled with the same system? Imagine if you had no idea what any given property actually cost to rent, but instead just paid into a "housing insurance" plan that took care of it for you and socialized the costs. Add on layers of administrative bureaucracy to determine which properties you qualify for based on your needs, and give it a few decades for prices to adjust to the market distortion. One day we'd find that all the properties are owned by multibillion-dollar housing conglomerates charging prices that are completely impossible for anyone poorer than Jeff Bezos to afford without "insurance". Eventually someone ends up shooting a housing insurance CEO in the street over grievances like Luigi's, e.g. maybe he's stuck sharing a single bedroom with his wife and four kids, or couldn't get approved for a property in the same city as his elderly parents. Meanwhile, the public has been gaslit into defending this Kafkaesque central planning as "free market" because it isn't technically run by the government, ignoring any role of the government in creating and actively propping up the system.
I don't think single-payer is necessarily the optimal solution due to the known impacts on supply / wait times under such systems, but if we're embracing central planning of a sector of the economy regardless, I'd rather the benefits be fully socialized alongside the costs. Right now we're socializing the costs while privatizing many of the benefits — great for profiteers of that system, but not so much for the rest of us. Although single-payer could potentially be a much stronger option in the future if optimized by large-scale anonymized economic data collection and AI-driven pricing, so I'm not necessarily opposed to it in principle.
What I'd also want to consider, however, is a wholesale sunsetting of mandatory "insurance" in its entirety. Make patients bear the costs of their care and incentivize them to shop around for the best prices. Force providers to optimize, innovate, and actually compete with each other to provide the lowest rates — negotiating with suppliers, reevaluating compensation structures, cutting administrative bloat, and embracing technologies like AI and telemedicine would all be viable angles for practices to explore. No one would get away with Gilead-style pricing in a free market, particularly if certain price transparency requirements were imposed. Then add a universal progressive cost-sharing system on top of that to ensure that the poorest aren't left out in the cold. As a practical matter, emergency care prices could be set by states or counties to balance local availability against ensuring that ER patients aren't saddled with excessive debt, continually adjusting for maximum public benefit. In this world, health-related insurance products would still be available for people who really wanted them, but they'd function as actual insurance, and be completely optional without being subject to ACA-style regulation.
> I don't think single-payer is necessarily the optimal solution due to the known impacts on supply / wait times under such systems,
At least where I live today, waits for specialists and primary care are atrocious (I once switched out of a medical system with 6 months wait for primary care), so it's not like we're not already seeing this.
We should take steps to optimize both supply and demand, but I don't think it'd be accurate to characterize the situation as "single-payer = long waits and multi-payer = short waits". More like higher demand with all else being equal means relatively longer waits, and all else being equal single-payer increases demand. But improved health, improved safety, and lower population are all things that drive down demand, all else being equal, so obviously there are a lot of factors here.
Despite not being single-payer, and despite its suppression of effective demand (with high latent demand among those priced out of the market), I'd argue that the current US system is far from optimal at maximizing supply of actual care relative to its full potential.
In 2017, the last time Republicans tried to repeal the ACA and Medicaid expansion, there were nearly riots at town halls from the very same blue collar families you're claiming look down upon the programs and legislation.
People aren't stupid, they know they're going to be fucked without the Medicaid coverage they've had for years.
They are against crack down on fraud as long as that fraud is performed by companies. Which is the most common fraud in healthcare.
> From a financial standpoint, it doesn't seem like either party has succeeded at significantly slowing the growth in healthcare costs overall. How much more can it grow without breaking? The Dems haven't proposed a solution either.
There is one party consistently trying to prevent any measure that could lover the cost. This is really not both sides issue. That one party in particular turned against their own solution once the other party accepted and adopted it.
Stop blaming democrats and everyone else for what republicans and their voters actually do, believe in and push for.
They don't seem to mind being on Medicare. I suppose one could claim that they don't view this as charity/welfare, but then I'd claim that they are stupid.
The EU’s Horizon Europe is €95.5B (2021–27) with €16B for ERC alone, national funders like the UK’s NIHR spend ~£1.4B/yr, and Europe’s pharma industry invests ~€50B/yr domestically.
Europe is home to Roche, Novartis, AstraZeneca, Sanofi, GSK, Novo Nordisk, each spending billions annually on R&D (Roche CHF 13.2B, AZ $13.6B, Sanofi €7.4B etc.). Also a big chunk of US list‑price "overpayment" never reaches manufacturers—rebates/discounts were an estimated $335B in 2023—so it’s not all subsidizing innovation.
Innovation is now multipolar: in 2024 more NAS originated from China (28) than from the U.S. (25) or Europe (18). So strong US funding matters, but Europe clearly pays and builds a lot too.
That said, our ... fascinating ... experiences ... in trying to get the government to fix our health systems is certainly no outsider's fault. Europeans and others can feel at ease continuing to mock us.
I'm 63, and my wife is near my age. We take this stuff seriously.
I have known many people that have been completely devastated by medical crises. Even with insurance, some types of illness can be catastrophic, financially.
I also have known quite a number of folks that have done an amazing job of taking care of themselves, yet still had medical crises.
-but if I get a terminal, especially long-term illness, it's a wipeout either way; if I'm out $20k/year to the healthcare providers and $20k/year to the insurance company, and can't work -- draining $40k/year in health costs just isn't going to work out for very long, unless I can make it another decade or two.
Edit: I should say, too, I give money directly to my daughter (that is, well before [ideally] I'm ill), specifically so I can declare bankruptcy with less family wealth loss if I should have to, and to help fend off Medicaid clawback.
Put me in Hospital for 17 days. A week of that, was ICU (lots of machines that go “beep”).
I had an HMO, at the time, and it was a pain, dealing with them, but it ended up costing me almost nothing. I think it would have been almost a million dollars, if out of pocket.
edit: remainder of original reply removed.
I'm sorry but by my math, there aren't that many publicly routable IP addresses (like 2.5 billion?). Generating and storing rainbow tables for all 2.5 billion publicly routable IP addresses wouldn't take an exorbitant amount of time, making that part semi-reversible.
Edit: On reconsideration, though, given that, I went ahead and removed the link, email address, and solicitation generally. I'm confident nothing would go wrong in the context of the 1000 or so people I imagine would ever see that link before the service is removed/renamed in some years, but I can appreciate the high-value liability of being wrong on that. Thanks.
The entire original point of insurance was to amortize the costs of the extreme events by spreading the costs across many people.
Are you paying rack rates for pharmaceuticals instead of the PBM rates? That gets expensive really fast.
This isn't very relevant to us though given none of us have any long-term issues (what actually got me to switch off health insurance was getting the EoB paperwork [every week, because the bills never seemed to stop for a long while after I stopped going to the burn clinic] for severely burning my hand in a grease fire; I would've been better off uninsured and shopping around). After a decade at the $20k/year assumption for family of 3's health insurance, we wind up with ~$200k saved up BEFORE investment gains (which, while I'll grant can be negative, we do have a pretty powerful, accessible, and long-term consistent engine in the US). Once I'm in my 40s, I should be able to afford having brain cancer; and if I don't get brain cancer, well, the biggest positive there is not having brain cancer.
Which becomes annoying when fairly rich Europeans ride these coattails (and defense) while being incessantly snobbish about their healthcare superiority, in large part paid for by us.
Though a big part of the Trump win comes from this - yea some Americans are rich, but a lot of them are really poor and justly mad at how much more expensive things are that we produce.