Or, just fund government research endeavors with no profit motive. If we can have a JPL for aerospace engineering, why not for pharmaceuticals?
I mean China is really rich, runs lots of centralized R&D, and has an excellent research culture, why isn’t it developing cures for everything?
The US has enjoyed a high concentration of R&D talent and funding which has somewhat starved out the desire of the rest of the world to do similar research.
If you are China, for example, why spend the funds to R&D new drugs when you can pull the same research from NIH and FDA efforts of the US and produce those same drugs for cheap.
And that isn't to say China is the only nation doing this. India is pretty famous for doing the same thing.
The issue with these drugs is once the chemical structure is known and proven to work, it's (usually) relatively trivial to spin up manufacturing.
China puts in R&D on products that are hard to manufacture even if the "how" is well known. They do that because China is a country built on international trade. That's why they are a world leader in battery tech.
Boner pills? Sure, go nuts on patenting those. But HIV prevention? No, it's immoral to patent this.
That has not been the case at all in the countries that did go that route. The US system has serious issues but I would take it over Canada's any day.
No you don't. For one, if you are insured that is not a possibility. And 100% of the people I know who are not insured save more money than insurance would cost them given their incomes are higher and taxes lower than Germany. They choose to accept the risk because they are relatively young and healthy. All of them could cut down on luxuries and pay for insurance if they wanted to.
I once took an ambulance to the wrong ER, not understanding that I had to go to one that took my insurance. When the hospital found out my insurance wasn't going to pay, they lowered the bill by 90% and it was completely manageable.
Meanwhile in Canada I have family members that have to wait nerve-racking months for life-saving procedures or even imaging. In the US, I've had a few MRIs the same week the nurse practitioner ordered them for things that were absolutely not urgent.
It's totally a possibility if you have a deductible. A few years ago I paid $500 for a 2 minute consultation with a doctor because I had a bad fever.
Citation needed. The US is neither dominating the list of big pharma (see e.g. Novartis, Roche, Astrazenica...), nor are the US exceptional in R&D spending per GDP (South Korea and Israel are the outliers). https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/research-spending-gdp?tab...
From the first link in the OP you're replying to:
> The United States Senate Committee on Finance launched an 18-month investigation of Gilead's Sovaldi pricing, and argued in its 2015 report that Gilead set prices high in disregard of the human cost and in order to set the stage for a higher eventual price for Sovaldi's successor, Harvoni. The committee's investigation, based in part on internal documents obtained from Gilead, revealed that the company had considered prices ranging from $50,000 to $115,000 per year, trying to strike a balance between revenue and predicted activist and public relations blowback, with little regard to research and development costs.
The pricing was found to be intentionally divorced from R&D costs. They are charging as much as they can because they can, not because of R&D.
It's fascinating that "fair" ends up being that the drug developer has to capture the correct amount of the value they are providing the patient, and the patient gets the rest.
Keep in mind that the value is only "theirs" by force of IP law which at least officially exists for the benefit of society as a whole. Permitting a situation where people are priced out of a cure because the only available alternative is exorbitantly expensive doesn't seem moral or useful.
If the concern is ensuring corporate investment into R&D then public policy could be adopted to subsidize R&D expenses either up front or after the fact.
There's no good reason a liver transplant should cost 300k, so yours is a false comparison.
I suspect that the lowest realistic cost in the US could be about 150k.
When compared to conservative treatments, transplants are expensive everywhere. A very invasive treatment with a small army of specialists involved.
Pharma companies are gamblers. They gamble on the cost of R&D, the market size for the drug, the amount they will be able to charge. The higher the expected value of their profits, the wider variety of drugs look like attractive prospects financially.
No denying the US plays a huge role in the global pharmaceutical industry - but Europe does too - semaglutide (Ozempic/Rybelsus/Wegovy) was developed by Novo Nordisk, headquartered in Denmark.
The popular ADHD drug lisdexamfetamine (Vyvanse/Elvanse) was developed by a US-based research team, but they ended up being acquired by a British pharmaceutical company (Shire), which in turn was acquired by a Japanese company (Takeda), who owned the patents (which expired last year or the year before, depending on country), and remain one of the major manufacturers of it.
If you want a career in drug development, there are huge opportunities in the EU and Switzerland; by no means are you limited to the US. As usual, in the US you will almost certainly get paid more, but some people find the social setting of Europe more to their liking, and view that as a compensating advantage which makes up for lower pay.
Switzerland is one of the few countries where getting paid more in the US for the same job would generally not be an "as usual" :) The large majority of equivalent jobs gets paid more in Switzerland, including office ones. The ones that don't are the outliers (which are of course greatly overrepresented here on HN).
This is IME, so feel free to correct me if I'm wrong.
https://www.healthline.com/health-news/heres-how-much-more-o...
- *For many large pharmaceutical companies ("Big Pharma"), marketing costs often exceed R&D spending.* In analyses of the top 10 drugmakers by revenue in 2020, 7 companies spent more on sales and marketing than on research and development. For example, Johnson & Johnson spent $22 billion on marketing compared to $12 billion on R&D; Bayer spent $18 billion on marketing vs. $8 billion on R&D[1][2].
- The combined marketing spend for these top 10 companies exceeded R&D by $36 billion (about 37%) in 2020[1][2].
[1] https://www.ahip.org/news/articles/new-study-in-the-midst-of... [2] https://www.csrxp.org/icymi-new-study-finds-big-pharma-spent...
Surely that's something that would be easier to get bipartisan support for, somewhat avoiding the "socialism vs capitalism" chasm between the parties that prevents meaningful healthcare reform.
[2] https://nadler.house.gov/news/documentsingle.aspx?DocumentID...
This is a hugely underappreciated aspect of why the cost of health care, including insurance premiums, is so high in the US. Well-meaning folks have called for decades for the US to transition to single-payer, citing the overall lower cost experienced in other countries as a primary motivator. Meanwhile, US companies remain the global leaders in the development of pharmaceuticals and medical equipment. That development is often subsidized by US taxpayers and the remainder is largely recovered from US patients because the single-payer systems in other countries often impose price controls that largely don't exist in the US.
(This is not meant to argue against single-payer in the US. All things being equal, a single-payer system would likely solve many more problems than it would cause. I'm just pointing out what many before me already have about how Americans disproportionately subsidize the development of the healthcare the rest of the world benefits from).