News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:AMD CEO says U.S.-made TSMC chips are 5%-20% more expensi... by ksec on Thursday July 24, 2025 @12:34PM (#44672750)
>What I really want to know, from someone who does know: Is Intel cooked?

I dont know if I count, but at least I wrote about TSMC before most if anyone knew much about TSMC. Which is when Apple brought them to spotlight.

It depends on how you define or count as being able to compete with TSMC?

If Intel technically leapfrog TSMC and their 18nm is better than TSMC 20nm this year but;

It is 30 - 40% more expensive.

It has lower Gross margin, or even negative margin.

It has much lower volume and capacity.

It is slower in ramping up capacity for future capacity planning.

It has limited IP range for its foundry.

It has less packaging options.

It does not have other high speed, low power or analog node options.

At what point does it count as competing? Because right now there isn't a single metric that Intel Foundry is winning. And they are feeling exactly the same as Global Foundry or AMD when Intel Foundry advancement is getting all the oxygens.

And even if they did, with a magic wand got them to compete with TSMC on every single one of the item above, in medium to long term there isn't a single chance Intel could compete with their current board and management.

TSMC leadership and management team is Nvidia's level great. I cant think of any other tech company that could rival them. Their only risk is China.

Re:AMD CEO says U.S.-made TSMC chips are 5%-20% more expensi... by etempleton on Thursday July 24, 2025 @01:28PM (#44673494)
They don’t really need to be better than TSMC, they need to be one node behind and roughly competitive on price / performance.

The first year of TSMCs latest process goes to Apple. And the second few years are booked completely full. There is room for Intel if they can just get in the ballpark of TSMC.

Re:AMD CEO says U.S.-made TSMC chips are 5%-20% more expensi... by wbl on Thursday July 24, 2025 @03:04PM (#44674723)
Price/performance, not node is what matters.
Re:AMD CEO says U.S.-made TSMC chips are 5%-20% more expensi... by SkyMarshal on Thursday July 24, 2025 @02:04PM (#44673984)
> If Intel technically leapfrog TSMC and their 18nm is better than TSMC 20nm this year but;

Think you mean 1.8nm, aka 18A. We're way past 18nm and 20nm.

Re:AMD CEO says U.S.-made TSMC chips are 5%-20% more expensi... by swores on Thursday July 24, 2025 @03:25PM (#44674955)
How long ago did nm numbers stop being descriptions of size of chip and start being purely marketing names? About a decade?
Re:AMD CEO says U.S.-made TSMC chips are 5%-20% more expensi... by bee_rider on Thursday July 24, 2025 @04:23PM (#44675588)
While it is true that the nm numbers are bullshit, using the same made-up number helps keep the conversation on track, haha.
Re:AMD CEO says U.S.-made TSMC chips are 5%-20% more expensi... by danparsonson on Thursday July 24, 2025 @06:27PM (#44677058)
https://www.extremetech.com/computing/296154-how-are-process...

"For a long time, gate length (the length of the transistor gate) and half-pitch (half the distance between two identical features on a chip) matched the process node name, but the last time this was true was 1997"

Re:AMD CEO says U.S.-made TSMC chips are 5%-20% more expensi... by swores on Thursday July 24, 2025 @06:36PM (#44677150)
Oh wow, I didn't realise it has been that long! Thanks for sharing
Re:AMD CEO says U.S.-made TSMC chips are 5%-20% more expensi... by danparsonson on Friday July 25, 2025 @12:40PM (#44685150)
Same here, I would have put it much more recently than that; I wonder how long before we'll be into negative numbers...
Re:AMD CEO says U.S.-made TSMC chips are 5%-20% more expensi... by ksec on Thursday July 24, 2025 @10:32PM (#44678911)
Yeah. That is what happen when I post it just before I felt asleep. Too late now can't edit it.
Re:AMD CEO says U.S.-made TSMC chips are 5%-20% more expensi... by rossjudson on Thursday July 24, 2025 @05:32PM (#44676476)
Was Intel's board and management great? Like, when did it change?
Re:AMD CEO says U.S.-made TSMC chips are 5%-20% more expensi... by jacquesm on Friday July 25, 2025 @05:01AM (#44681136)
There is one metric where they are winning: they are not TSMC.