Re:Proxmox Donates €10k to the Perl and Raku Foundation
by kstrauser on Wednesday July 23, 2025 @11:51AM
(#44660594)
In fairness to Perl, that's a good reason not to consider it a breaking change.
Re:Proxmox Donates €10k to the Perl and Raku Foundation
by em-bee on Wednesday July 23, 2025 @12:02PM
(#44660714)
perl 6/raku was a redesign. as far as i remember, upgradeability from perl 5 without code changes was never the goal.
Re:Proxmox Donates €10k to the Perl and Raku Foundation
by aaronbaugher on Wednesday July 23, 2025 @12:08PM
(#44660789)
It's unfortunate that that wasn't clear to people who weren't closely involved with Perl at the time. So many people got the impression that Perl 5 was outdated as soon as 6 was in development, so they thought they had to move on from it. It's too bad Raku didn't have a different name from the start.
Re:Proxmox Donates €10k to the Perl and Raku Foundation
by petdance on Wednesday July 23, 2025 @02:18PM
(#44662293)
> It's too bad Raku didn't have a different name from the start.
We thought that it would take a year or two, not decades.
Also, the intent was to have a Perl 5 compatibility mode.
Re:Proxmox Donates €10k to the Perl and Raku Foundation
by aaronbaugher on Wednesday July 23, 2025 @04:15PM
(#44663496)
Looks like the last time I tried out Perl 6 was almost 10 years ago. Even wrote a few blog posts about it before giving up on it again. Might be time to take another look.
Re:Proxmox Donates €10k to the Perl and Raku Foundation
by lizmat on Wednesday July 23, 2025 @06:31PM
(#44664714)
There is a Perl 5 compatibility mode: it's called Inline::Perl5.
Maybe not the one that was originally planned. But that was only a real possibility if Perl 5 would be able to get rid of its XS addiction.
Ask yourself: how many of the up river Perl modules are Perl only?
Re:Proxmox Donates €10k to the Perl and Raku Foundation
by oofbey on Wednesday July 23, 2025 @03:13PM
(#44662856)
Agreed. Probably why they renamed it. I think everybody probably wishes they'd taken a new name from the start.
Re:Proxmox Donates €10k to the Perl and Raku Foundation
by SoftTalker on Wednesday July 23, 2025 @12:03PM
(#44660723)
Isn't that the definition of a breaking change?
Re:Proxmox Donates €10k to the Perl and Raku Foundation
by em-bee on Wednesday July 23, 2025 @12:25PM
(#44660995)
yeah, in the same sense that D is a breaking change for C, or wayland for X11. the point is that as far as i know it was never intended that existing perl 5 code would be rewritten. unlike the python 2 to 3 change where the intention was that people would convert using 2to3 and later using compatibility modules that allowed writing code that works with both. python 2 development stopped after 12 years, much later than they expected.
Re:Proxmox Donates €10k to the Perl and Raku Foundation
by 0xbadcafebee on Wednesday July 23, 2025 @12:36PM
(#44661120)
If Ford makes a 4-door passenger car, and then comes out with a 2-door sports car, and keeps producing both cars, that's not a breaking change. It's just a new car.
Perl 5 is still supported, Perl 6 (Raku) continues independently.
Perl 6?
It was so breaking they don't even call it Perl anymore.