News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Show HN: WTFfmpeg by whywhywhywhy on Wednesday July 23, 2025 @07:54AM (#44658187)
It's really not, things can be powerful and easy to use. I'd even say some parts of ffmpeg are well designed in this way like `ffmpeg -i ./video.mp4 ./video.wav` working is well designed.

Think the fact all the commands are shorthand doesn't help because no matter how many ffmpeg commands you copy and paste in your life unless you put the effort in you're not going to begin to remember what -an means in the sea of all the other two letter switches and the copywriting in the output and error messages is very hard to tell whats going wrong for someone who hasn't used it a long time.

Not saying it should all be super wordy just that it's difficult to pick up things though osmosis when the commands look like this -ss -t -rc:v, respect to anyone who actually learnt how this works so they could type it without sitting there with the documentation and hitting a wall for an hour.

Will say though the raw tech inside ffmpeg has always meant figuring out getting it to do the thing has always been worth it because it's insanely powerful.

Re:Show HN: WTFfmpeg by Sesse__ on Wednesday July 23, 2025 @01:22PM (#44661661)
> It's really not, things can be powerful and easy to use. I'd even say some parts of ffmpeg are well designed in this way like `ffmpeg -i ./video.mp4 ./video.wav` working is well designed.

I'd argue that even this command line isn't well-designed at all; it should be `ffmpeg video.mp4 -o video.wav`. How is it sane that anything without an -i in front is an _output_ filename?

Re:Show HN: WTFfmpeg by ycombiredd on Wednesday July 23, 2025 @02:17PM (#44662284)
It's not an output filename.. The -i is the input, the .wav is the output filename in that example.
Re:Show HN: WTFfmpeg by Sesse__ on Wednesday July 23, 2025 @02:44PM (#44662583)
Yes? That's not in conflict with anything I said.
Re:Show HN: WTFfmpeg by ycombiredd on Sunday July 27, 2025 @03:53AM (#44699598)
You're right! I misread your "without" as "with". I need better glasses, or reading comprehension.