News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:YouTube Won the Battle for TV Viewers by WhyNotHugo on Wednesday July 23, 2025 @06:27AM (#44657582)
In an ideal world, each streaming service would provide the service itself, users can pick whichever app they like, and connect that app to the services they use.

In the real world, each company wants to be THE number one streaming platform, and wants users to use their app above all else. So each company reinvents the same things, and users need to deal with the mess of N apps for N services.

The idea of cooperation is completely alien in big tech companies. Descentralisation is perceived as dangerous, since it doesn’t let each individual be the number one.

In the end, because everyone want to be the number one and screw the rest, they all end up sucking. This is obviously predictable, but management everywhere remains oblivious of it.

Re:YouTube Won the Battle for TV Viewers by jasode on Wednesday July 23, 2025 @07:04AM (#44657802)
>In an ideal world, each streaming service would provide the service itself, users can pick whichever app they like, and connect that app to the services they use.

>In the real world, [...] each company reinvents the same things, and users need to deal with the mess of N apps for N services. The idea of cooperation is completely alien in big tech companies.

That fragmented outcome is expected because the companies are following the advice that HN likes to repeat: Don't be a sharecropper in someone else's feudal landlord platform.

E.g. Disney didn't want to be a sharecropper in Netflix so they pulled their content and put it exclusively on their own Disney+ platform. Likewise, Netflix doesn't want to be a sharecropper to Apple TV or Amazon Prime Video and let those platforms handle billing for Netflix subscriptions and let them take a % cut of the fee. Instead, Netflix forces users to go to Netflix's own app or website.

Disney wants to own their customer relationships instead of having an intermediary like Apple or Amazon in between.

To satisfy the ideal of a single all-in-one streaming platform without any fragmentation requires all the companies to ignore their own economic self-interests.

Re:YouTube Won the Battle for TV Viewers by PaulDavisThe1st on Wednesday July 23, 2025 @05:51PM (#44664411)
> In the real world, each company wants to be THE number one streaming platform, and wants users to use their app above all else. So each company reinvents the same things, and users need to deal with the mess of N apps for N services.

The companies do not care about app usage. They care about subscription fees, which are highly (though somewhat elastically) dependent on a platform's available content. They don't give a damn what you watch with, they just want you to pay. They already know there will be no 600lb gorilla in streaming, so it's all about getting another month of fees from you, and that is unrelated to app usage.

Re:YouTube Won the Battle for TV Viewers by Dylan16807 on Wednesday July 23, 2025 @08:09PM (#44665458)
The app usage isn't the end goal, but it's an important middle step to the strategy. While you're using one platform, they don't want you to be reminded that other platforms exist or easily browse them.