News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Global hack on Microsoft product hits U.S., state agencie... by Arainach on Monday July 21, 2025 @05:47PM (#44640796)
Best practice is to assume the network is compromised - a VPN doesn't provide as much guarantee as people would like. In large fleets, devices are regularly lost, damaged, retired, etc. In organizations with high target value, physical penetration through any number of means should be assumed.

So you don't do that. You use zero trust and don't care that things are exposed to the internet.

Working from anywhere (remote sites, home, your phone) is a huge benefit. Organizations want to control their data entirely while still wanting their organization to be able to access it.

Re:Global hack on Microsoft product hits U.S., state agencie... by this_steve_j on Monday July 21, 2025 @07:36PM (#44641612)
Microsoft’s version of “Zero Trust” doesn’t care if things are reachable from the public internet. They have been preaching “identity is the new perimeter” [1] for years, and it doesn’t wash.

The NIST Zero Trust Architecture (ZTA) implementation guides (SP 1800-35) [2] cut through the nonsense and AI generated marketing smoke.

In ZTA, ALL network locations are untrusted. Network connections are created by a Policy Engine that creates and tears down tunnels to each resource dynamically using attribute-based-access-controls (ABAC). Per request.

Microsoft doesn’t have any products that can do full ZTA, so several pillars are missing from their “Zero Trust” marketing materials.

[1] https://www.microsoft.com/insidetrack/blog/securing-the-bord...

[2] https://doi.org/10.6028/NIST.SP.1800-35

Re:Global hack on Microsoft product hits U.S., state agencie... by tacticus on Monday July 21, 2025 @09:32PM (#44642367)
> several pillars are missing from their “Zero Trust” marketing materials.

TBH several pillars are missing from their entire security posture.

Re:Global hack on Microsoft product hits U.S., state agencie... by Tokumei-no-hito on Monday July 21, 2025 @09:52PM (#44642483)
why bother when not a single vulnerability has resulted in any appreciable fines or loss of market share? it's absurd how untouchable their ubiquity has become.
Re:Global hack on Microsoft product hits U.S., state agencie... by sneak on Tuesday July 22, 2025 @12:54AM (#44643361)
They’re the Boeing of software. They go down with the ship, but, critically, it means they also can’t go down until and unless the ship also does.

It’s a symbiotic relationship that allows them to stop having to spend resources to compete in the market on merit.

Re:Global hack on Microsoft product hits U.S., state agencie... by realusername on Tuesday July 22, 2025 @02:10AM (#44643691)
That's pretty accurate, if you want modern practice and product quality you go to Google or Amazon, if you want compliance and reassuring the board, you go to Microsoft.
Re:Global hack on Microsoft product hits U.S., state agencie... by betaby on Monday July 21, 2025 @10:37PM (#44642729)
> Network connections are created by a Policy Engine that creates and tears down tunnels to each resource dynamically using attribute-based-access-controls (ABAC). Per request.

What does it mean in technical terms? What kind of tunnels are whose and what is their purpose?

Re:Global hack on Microsoft product hits U.S., state agencie... by this_steve_j on Monday July 21, 2025 @11:29PM (#44642966)
There are four different micro-segmentation variations in the NIST reference guide: device-agent/gateway, enclaves, resource portals, and application sandboxing.

Basically a policy evaluation point (PEP) evaluates the security posture of both parties before and after a handshake, then creates a logical or physical path of some kind of between the actor and the resource. This can be done with software-defined virtual networks and stateful firewalls, at one or more of the OSI layers.

Re:Global hack on Microsoft product hits U.S., state agencie... by ptsneves on Tuesday July 22, 2025 @08:12AM (#44645891)
So the policy evaluation point has the keys to the kingdom and is the single point of failure, vs standard distributed authorisation declaration that would be up to each component of the system to implement.

How is this PEP better?

Re:Global hack on Microsoft product hits U.S., state agencie... by anonymars on Monday July 21, 2025 @06:11PM (#44640979)
Maybe I'm missing something but doesn't this very story cut your assertion off at the knees?

With a VPN the attack surface of this vulnerability would have been miniscule compared to a publicly accessible zero-day RCE

(And it's not like you have to allow carte-blanche access behind the wall)

Defense in depth!

Re:Global hack on Microsoft product hits U.S., state agencie... by zamadatix on Monday July 21, 2025 @06:23PM (#44641073)
In zero trust "exposed to the internet" is a bit of a misnomer compared to how traditional security would use the term. A better description might be "you're allowed to form a session to it from over the internet but only after your identity and set of rights have been verified". From this view: "zero trust" < "vpn" < "wide open" (in terms of exposure).
Re:Global hack on Microsoft product hits U.S., state agencie... by anonymars on Monday July 21, 2025 @07:04PM (#44641370)
So it's essentially a more seamless and granular analog of a VPN? A device sits in front of the network and requires some sort of authenticated handshake (ideally all SSO) before passing packets through to a target endpoint?
Re:Global hack on Microsoft product hits U.S., state agencie... by zamadatix on Monday July 21, 2025 @08:14PM (#44641902)
Something I'll add to the other responses is "the network" isn't an assumption of zero trust. Whether it's a single server on the private corporate network or a multi-cloud multi-region service hosted on the internet zero trust treats them the same.

My way of mapping it to VPN mindset is "per app clientless VPNs straight to where the things are hosted". In an extremely open ruleset with all of the servers on a corporate network this could theoretically devolve into "a traditional clientless VPN to the office".

Re:Global hack on Microsoft product hits U.S., state agencie... by baby_souffle on Monday July 21, 2025 @07:19PM (#44641470)
At a high level, yeah.

They can be implemented using a variety of technical patterns but they all share a common "each request is authenticated, encrypted" property instead of "anything goes once the tunnel is up" property.

Re:Global hack on Microsoft product hits U.S., state agencie... by pmontra on Tuesday July 22, 2025 @07:56AM (#44645780)
HTTPS calls with any kind of authentication (cookies, tokens, even basic auth) are one way to be "authenticated, encrypted" for "each request". If they go to a reverse proxy at the entrance of a company network (a common setup for every internet facing http server) they are a way to do without a VPN.

And yet every customer of mine have some of their servers on a VPN. At the very least they enable ssh only on ports on the private network.

Re:Global hack on Microsoft product hits U.S., state agencie... by hug on Monday July 21, 2025 @07:16PM (#44641455)
Yes, that's zero trust in a nutshell: A VPN that does a tunnel per TCP connection instead of one tunnel for all TCP connections.

The other salient point is that all connections are established outbound through a broker, and importantly this is the case from both sides: The appliance at the terminating end of the tunnel establishes reverse tunnels to the broker for the connections, so it's never "exposed to the internet".

The broker can then push to your SIEM or whatever so you can have your SOC log jockeys harass your employees for accidentally leaving NordVPN on after watching international sports.

There are actual benefits: You can do things like allow logins to system A from anywhere, but system B only from your home country, you can do JIT network access requests, etc... but mostly it's vendor marketing to get you to spend too much money.

Re:Global hack on Microsoft product hits U.S., state agencie... by esseph on Monday July 21, 2025 @08:57PM (#44642182)
(Not just TCP)
Re:Global hack on Microsoft product hits U.S., state agencie... by BobbyTables2 on Monday July 21, 2025 @10:19PM (#44642636)
Makes “zero trust” sound like basic username/password from ancient times.
Re:Global hack on Microsoft product hits U.S., state agencie... by tjohns on Monday July 21, 2025 @11:18PM (#44642914)
Think machine certs (stored in a TPM). Plus perimeter-enforced username/password/2FA. Plus additional policy checks, like making sure your machine is up to date on security patches.

It doesn’t matter what network you are connecting from, but it does matter that you’re connecting from a company-issued laptop that’s in a trustworthy state.

Re:Global hack on Microsoft product hits U.S., state agencie... by rockskon on Tuesday July 22, 2025 @02:52AM (#44643926)
Sounds like multiple single points of failure to make a security infrastructure so hostile to the end user it would be considered the equivalent of being under persistent attack.
Re:Global hack on Microsoft product hits U.S., state agencie... by mike_hearn on Tuesday July 22, 2025 @04:08AM (#44644401)
VPN products do all of that.
Re:Global hack on Microsoft product hits U.S., state agencie... by tjohns on Tuesday July 22, 2025 @01:12PM (#44650195)
They absolutely do, that’s fair.

The big difference is once you’re in, with a VPN you have direct access to the whole network.

With a zero trust setup, access has to be granted to you (or your ACL group) on a per-application basis. It makes it much harder for an attacker to move laterally when everything is default-deny.

Re:Global hack on Microsoft product hits U.S., state agencie... by mike_hearn on Tuesday July 22, 2025 @02:51PM (#44651449)
But you can combine VPNs with SSO and limited permissions. Real networks all work that way these days. Logging into the VPN doesn't get you very far, you'll need to be provisioned with specific apps and permissions too.
Re:Global hack on Microsoft product hits U.S., state agencie... by zamadatix on Tuesday July 22, 2025 @06:11PM (#44653573)
If you crank it a bit further to add:

- You must "VPN in" to access any corporate resources of any type, even ones on the corporate network when you're sourcing from the corporate network

- The client forms a separate "VPN connection" (can be clientless, but same concept) per app you access, rather than assuming a single parent VPN server can get them to any resource

- Every default ruleset started with deny all and only specific allow rules were added over time

Then you've got enough to call it a zero trust implementation. You can also take things the other way, i.e. you could "deconfigure" a zero trust setup to look and function almost exactly as a normal corporate VPN tunnel.

Rather than go through this whole thread each time, people just refer to all of this as "zero trust networking".

Re:Global hack on Microsoft product hits U.S., state agencie... by zamadatix on Tuesday July 22, 2025 @06:12PM (#44653584)
At the end of the day "you get access to things based on proving your identity" is not a novel concept. How you deploy, operate, and enforce that is where the differences in technologies lie.
Re:Global hack on Microsoft product hits U.S., state agencie... by this_steve_j on Monday July 21, 2025 @11:35PM (#44642988)
That’s my understanding.

In a pure implementation, the same level of trust is implied (absolutely none at all) whether a device is connecting to a resource from the public internet or the same subnet.

Re:Global hack on Microsoft product hits U.S., state agencie... by michaelt on Monday July 21, 2025 @07:13PM (#44641433)
Arainach is advocating for something called "Zero Trust" which, from a user's perspective, is very much like a VPN.

It's software your employer pre-installs on your work PC, that asks you to log in with your work SSO credentials, performs some endpoint security checks, then routes your traffic over a virtual network adapter, and thereby allows you to access workplace resources, even when working from home.

The main difference is it adds some semi-authenticated states. Correct device, username, password, and 2FA, but failed a device posture check because they plugged their phone into their laptop to charge it? The 'Zero Trust' system can block some systems, while letting them retain access to others.

The other big difference is the pricing - rather than paying a five-figure sum upfront for networking hardware, you instead pay $25 per employee per month, forever.

Re:Global hack on Microsoft product hits U.S., state agencie... by xxpor on Monday July 21, 2025 @07:37PM (#44641615)
>then routes your traffic over a virtual network adapter

this is not a requirement of zero trust.

Re:Global hack on Microsoft product hits U.S., state agencie... by nine_k on Monday July 21, 2025 @09:08PM (#44642239)
Zero trust is when every session with every service is like its own VPN, independently authenticated and encrypted. Consider the way an HTTPS session between a server and a browser is created anew every time the browser accesses a domain, and ends after a short flurry of requests needed to load a page.
Re:Global hack on Microsoft product hits U.S., state agencie... by BobbyTables2 on Monday July 21, 2025 @10:22PM (#44642649)
Almost sounds like “zero trust” is classic HTTPS authentication with extra marketing added…
Re:Global hack on Microsoft product hits U.S., state agencie... by anonymars on Monday July 21, 2025 @10:40PM (#44642744)
There's a significant difference which my original message hints at and is subsequently clarified: there's still an intermediary. If there's an exploit in the service, like this case, it's still not directly exposed. The intermediary device is still sitting in between and won't allow any old traffic through without separate authorization