News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:You can now buy eggs from in-ovo sexed hens by scarier on Monday July 21, 2025 @10:51AM (#44635805)
I’m struggling to see the nefarious angle here—-this seems like a case where both ethical and efficiency concerns are well-aligned, for a modest increase in cost that may disappear with scale. How is this anything other than a win?
Re:You can now buy eggs from in-ovo sexed hens by schnebbau on Monday July 21, 2025 @10:50AM (#44635791)
Wait, so we can all agree that killing the male chicks is inhumane. But you think the solution, _to not birth the male chicks_, is just as inhumane?

If so, awful take. This is infinitely better and most definitely a step in the right direction.

Re:You can now buy eggs from in-ovo sexed hens by pastage on Monday July 21, 2025 @10:59AM (#44635943)
Hens live in cages the size of a piece of paper (A4/letter), they are kept there for 2 years. Very small percentage of them live in better circumstances. What leaves a bad taste is calling that "humanely hatched". EDIT: Apparently here in Sweden about 20% that have the guaranteed possibility of moving around outside then hen house, and less than 1% still live in solitary confinement so I was wrong at least over here. EDIT2: Apparently about 50% live in the worst kind of cages in the US.
Re:You can now buy eggs from in-ovo sexed hens by Maskawanian on Monday July 21, 2025 @10:54AM (#44635871)
No, you are putting words into my mouth. Try to argue in good faith through understanding the other party's viewpoint before responding.

I don't see much difference between killing chicks after them being born, or stopping them from being born in the first place. The only difference is in the efficiency of business operations.

If my values are that each deserves a chance at a life--whatever life it may be, I can advocate for searching for a better solution. I did not prescribe an alternative, don't pretend that I have.

EDIT: Damn, the hostile responses (Ad hominem, bad faith arguments, etc) to such a simple philosophical discussion I've been getting are unbelievable. I don't think there is much value in participating anymore. Thank you everyone for your responses.

Re:You can now buy eggs from in-ovo sexed hens by stouset on Monday July 21, 2025 @11:05AM (#44636008)
Nobody is putting words in your mouth. They are reacting directly to the absolutely bonkers statements you are making that there is ethically no difference between killing 350 million live, healthy male chicks every year and preventing those chicks from being born in the first place.
Re:You can now buy eggs from in-ovo sexed hens by simonw on Monday July 21, 2025 @10:59AM (#44635935)
"I don't see much difference between killing chicks after them being born, or stopping them from being born in the first place."

I do. One of those involves a (presumably painful) death of a conscious animal. The other does not.

Re:You can now buy eggs from in-ovo sexed hens by Concrete3286 on Monday July 21, 2025 @11:09AM (#44636071)
The other option - a living female chick - also ends in the premature death of a conscious animal, additionally after a (presumably painful) life. Does it not?
Re:You can now buy eggs from in-ovo sexed hens by simonw on Monday July 21, 2025 @11:23AM (#44636273)
Sure. That doesn't mean that there is no difference between not having a male chick being born compared to killing it directly after it has been sexed.
Re:You can now buy eggs from in-ovo sexed hens by starkrights on Monday July 21, 2025 @11:05AM (#44636015)
Good faith clarification: you’re saying you believe that preventing chicks from being born causes an equal amount of suffering to an animal as the (what would otherwise be) physical extermination of those chicks?
Re:You can now buy eggs from in-ovo sexed hens by zahlman on Monday July 21, 2025 @11:10AM (#44636089)
> > Wait, so we can all agree that killing the male chicks is inhumane. But you think the solution, _to not birth the male chicks_, is just as inhumane?

> No, you are putting words into my mouth.

As an onlooking third party, I don't understand. You further say:

> I don't see much difference between killing chicks after them being born, or stopping them from being born in the first place.

But as far as I can understand it, that is the same thing.

> I did not prescribe an alternative, don't pretend that I have.

It was not supposed that you were prescribing an alternative. The words "you think the solution" were not introducing a supposed solution of yours; they were introducing a solution (the process discussed in TFA) about which you (appeared to) have a thought.

Re:You can now buy eggs from in-ovo sexed hens by Hackbraten on Monday July 21, 2025 @10:59AM (#44635944)
> The only difference is in the efficiency of business operations.

Are you implying that the chicks being killed are not suffering?

Re:You can now buy eggs from in-ovo sexed hens by schnebbau on Monday July 21, 2025 @11:07AM (#44636051)
> If the proponents of this truly believe that this is more humane, it really is targeting the wrong level

If something isn't more humane, it must be the same or less. I think it is you who needs to better articulate your position broski.

But that aside, one method kills living creatures and the other does not. If you cannot see a difference then I'm afraid you are lost.

Re:You can now buy eggs from in-ovo sexed hens by insanetake on Monday July 21, 2025 @11:14AM (#44636145)
So you're saying there's no difference between (1) not breeding dogs to fight and (2) breeding dogs and have them fight each other?
Re:You can now buy eggs from in-ovo sexed hens by bbarnett on Monday July 21, 2025 @11:07AM (#44636055)
I have to say this, I'm sorry.

--

Isn't this carrying the pro life movement too far? Chickens do not have souls, in the biblical context.

If this isn't a religious thing, then note the article has two methods. One detecting feather differences, the other a genetic test.

The genetic test should be quite early. If at that stage, I imagine a blade of grass has more intelligence, there isn't a brain yet, and nerves don't even exist.

No pain, no feeling, just a few dozen cells hanging out.

Does this not seem OK to you, if the case?

Re:You can now buy eggs from in-ovo sexed hens by mitthrowaway2 on Monday July 21, 2025 @10:57AM (#44635910)
What do you propose to do with so many roosters?
Re:You can now buy eggs from in-ovo sexed hens by colechristensen on Monday July 21, 2025 @10:47AM (#44635759)
No reason to criticize an improvement because it doesn't solve every problem.
Re:You can now buy eggs from in-ovo sexed hens by michaelmrose on Monday July 21, 2025 @10:41AM (#44635668)
male chicks aren't useful if we bring them into being we will have to kill them.
Re:You can now buy eggs from in-ovo sexed hens by tastyfreeze on Monday July 21, 2025 @10:43AM (#44635700)
Male chicks make as good of soup as hens. However, roosters are assholes and don't get along with other roosters by the time they are butcher weight.
Re:You can now buy eggs from in-ovo sexed hens by hansvm on Monday July 21, 2025 @10:46AM (#44635748)
They don't get along with any animals, and the problem starts well before they're butcher weight. It's not uncommon for an entire hen house to wind up murdered if you don't sex your chickens.
Re:You can now buy eggs from in-ovo sexed hens by esperent on Monday July 21, 2025 @10:48AM (#44635769)
> It's not uncommon for an entire hen house to wind up murdered if you don't sex your chickens.

Can you explain what you mean by this?

Re:You can now buy eggs from in-ovo sexed hens by bbarnett on Monday July 21, 2025 @11:10AM (#44636094)
Just google chicken glasses as a start of a thread to pull on.
Re:You can now buy eggs from in-ovo sexed hens by esperent on Monday July 21, 2025 @11:17AM (#44636196)
Yes, I'm aware that chickens can be aggressive or even occasionally cannibalistic (although that's never happened to any groups of chickens I've seen).

But that doesn't explain anything about why you're saying an entire hen house can be murdered when you fail to sex chicks. I've never heard that male chicken are worse in this regard, excessive feather pecking is a result of keeping chickens in terrible environments like battery/cage farms and happens in fully female groups.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Feather_pecking

Re:You can now buy eggs from in-ovo sexed hens by hansvm on Monday July 21, 2025 @11:58AM (#44636759)
It happens from time to time even with free range chickens if a rooster picks a fight while they're all in the coop for the night.
Re:You can now buy eggs from in-ovo sexed hens by northhnbesthn on Monday July 21, 2025 @10:53AM (#44635836)
Do elaborate. Does Chad Thundercock go ballistic on all the hens?
Re:You can now buy eggs from in-ovo sexed hens by aaronbaugher on Monday July 21, 2025 @11:08AM (#44636061)
Pretty much. Small-time chicken owner here. The best ratio of hens to roosters is about 10-to-1. Each rooster will have his "harem" of hens that keep him busy, and the hens will be content. Any more roosters than that and they'll fight a lot, and the roosters that don't have their own group of hens will hang around the others looking for a chance to rape them while their regular rooster is occupied or too far away. It can be pretty hard on the hens.

I've never had a rooster kill hens, though. Each other, sure, but not the hens. I don't really buy that.

Some context for this article that most people don't know: there are chicken breeds for meat (Cornish Cross, mostly) and breeds for eggs. The egg breeds are skinny and won't become a good meat bird no matter how much you feed them. I guess you can caponize them and they'll gain more weight, but that's a process that costs money. You could use them for soup, but that probably wouldn't be cost-effective either, so that's why the large-scale operations just kill them.

Re:You can now buy eggs from in-ovo sexed hens by zahlman on Monday July 21, 2025 @11:13AM (#44636119)
> The best ratio of hens to roosters is about 10-to-1. Each rooster will have his "harem" of hens that keep him busy, and the hens will be content. Any more roosters than that and they'll fight a lot, and the roosters that don't have their own group of hens will hang around the others looking for a chance to rape them while their regular rooster is occupied or too far away. It can be pretty hard on the hens.

It seems like a sick joke of nature that a species that behaves this way wouldn't also naturally be born in a similar ratio. I wonder if they're like that in the wild, too....

Re:You can now buy eggs from in-ovo sexed hens by grues-dinner on Monday July 21, 2025 @11:57AM (#44636755)
There's no real such thing as a "natural" chicken, but their ancestors, red junglefowl, are similar. In fact, healthier females produce more males (https://academic.oup.com/auk/article/119/3/840/5561973). Perhaps it's evolutionary turned out to be good for fitness of the species if 90% of the males are killed by other males or otherwise don't mate and that outweighs "wasting" 4.5/10 eggs. Nature doesn't "care" (yes, yes, active verb for non-conscious process) if it's pretty, just that it works.

In general, life in nature just ain't that fun as a junior member of an r-selected species, which includes chickens.

Re:You can now buy eggs from in-ovo sexed hens by XorNot on Monday July 21, 2025 @10:52AM (#44635827)
My in-laws turned quite a few roosters into dinners while trying to find one which actually had an even temper with their chickens, so yeah it's a serious issue.
Re:You can now buy eggs from in-ovo sexed hens by bbarnett on Monday July 21, 2025 @11:14AM (#44636140)
That only works, if you know it's a chicken:

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=2mbnc83MS98

Re:You can now buy eggs from in-ovo sexed hens by RansomStark on Monday July 21, 2025 @10:55AM (#44635881)
You don't usually leave roosters whole if you keep them for food. You make Capons, they get huge, almost like turkeys but with all the juicy benefits of a fat chicken.

The problem with egg roosters is that the breads used for eggs are so badly bred for maximum egg laying that they mostly unusable for good food. Might be good for pet food and canned stuff.

The real solution here is to demand mixed bread chickens that lay slightly fewer eggs, but can also be used for good meat.

Re:You can now buy eggs from in-ovo sexed hens by kimbernator on Monday July 21, 2025 @10:52AM (#44635829)
It sounds like (based on the article), large-scale companies will usually either do eggs or chicken meat, not both. So you're not wrong but I see why it's not that simple.
Re:You can now buy eggs from in-ovo sexed hens by Ekaros on Monday July 21, 2025 @10:54AM (#44635873)
Broiler that is meat chicken and egg laying chickens are different breeds. So focusing on one of those is pretty sensible.