News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What Happens When Housing Prices Go Down? by billy99k on Monday July 21, 2025 @08:41AM (#44634430)
"If “build more” was going to bring prices down and stabilize the system, we wouldn’t be seeing these mixed signals."

Where have we seen anything close to 'build more'? Regulations in many major cities have prevented building more for decades and I haven't seen any loosening of these regulations (they were only increased during the Biden administration).

"Prices are softening. Delinquencies are rising. Builders are walking. And instead of asking what this reveals about the fragility of our system, we’re preparing to paper over it—again—with liquidity, leverage, and euphemisms. "

This is the plan from the potential future mayor of New York: Builders and investors will flee as a result of price controls and home value will plummet.

Detroit is a good example of what happens in the long term when investors and businesses flee the city. I lived there for 20+ years and it still has never really recovered.

Re:What Happens When Housing Prices Go Down? by soylentbeige on Monday July 21, 2025 @09:36AM (#44634923)
Mass upzoning in Auckland, New Zealand resulted in a rent reduction of 22-35% for three-bedroom apartments and 14-22% for two-bedroom apartments

https://cdn.auckland.ac.nz/assets/business/about/our-researc...

Re:What Happens When Housing Prices Go Down? by lenerdenator on Monday July 21, 2025 @09:34AM (#44634912)
> Detroit is a good example of what happens in the long term when investors and businesses flee the city

Let's be honest: it's a good example of what happens when some guys with a lot of money find a cheaper place to make something.

Same with St. Louis, Baltimore, Chicago, Cleveland, Buffalo, Camden, Gary, and so on.

Re:What Happens When Housing Prices Go Down? by hollywood_court on Monday July 21, 2025 @09:45AM (#44635010)
Yep. They moved their operations to the south where they don’t have to worry about unions or those pesky worker’s right.

I experienced this first hand when I worked for a Korean company that supplied parts to Hyundai and Kia.

They sent line workers from Detroit to train people in Alabama.

My coworkers in Alabama just could not believe the Detroit folks when they talked about how much money they earned.

We were being paid half as much in Alabama. And our area of Alabama had a much higher cost of living compared to Detroit and its suburbs.

Re:What Happens When Housing Prices Go Down? by octopoc on Monday July 21, 2025 @09:49AM (#44635070)
Sounds like an improvement TBH. The quality of life improves for people in Alabama, and the company can pay people less. Sort of like the economic argument for offshoring people. The only people losing are the people in Detroit.
Re:What Happens When Housing Prices Go Down? by hollywood_court on Monday July 21, 2025 @09:53AM (#44635117)
Not exactly. Everyone on the line in Alabama had to have second jobs because the pay was not sustainable for our area. Not to mention the vacations, extra benefits, and other protections the Alabama workers didn't receive compared to their peers in Detroit.

So the company makes more money by moving their operations to the south where they exploit their workers without interference from the government.

Re:What Happens When Housing Prices Go Down? by octopoc on Monday July 21, 2025 @12:07PM (#44636878)
Has the situation in Alabama gotten better over time? Have the Alabama workers been able to negotiate for more protections/better pay?

Because that’s the explanation for why offshoring to countries with fewer regulations is a good thing. Yeah it’s tough at the beginning, but it theoretically gives the workers leverage over the company because there aren’t any cheaper sources of labor. It’s supposed to give the cheapest labor the option to grow a pro-labor movement.

Re:What Happens When Housing Prices Go Down? by hollywood_court on Monday July 21, 2025 @01:07PM (#44637620)
Nope. It's weird because the company I worked for years ago still to this day spends a great deal of time and energy promoting anti-union stances and making sure the employees know that unions are bad for them.

But at the same time, the company adopts a lot of union practices. For example, they pay based on tenure and not performance. So it doesn't matter how productive you are. You could be the single most productive individual on your line, but the guy who has been there longer is going to get paid more. Even though that guy is likely rather less productive than you.

But these companies pay so poorly that the only people applying for these jobs are people straight out of jail/prison.

When I ran the CNC line, there were ~350 people on the floor between the two 12 hour shifts. Of those ~350, there were only two of us that had never been to state or federal prison.

So the company knows that they have these employees right where they want them. The employees are too afraid to organize or even speak out.

Re:What Happens When Housing Prices Go Down? by trod1234 on Wednesday July 23, 2025 @01:25PM (#44661706)
Sounds like a market distortion to me.

I have to wonder what kind of kickbacks they get for employing those people, or whether they have a work program based in whole or part on slave labor (quite common in a number of places, slavery isn't illegal for those who have been incarcerated).

Markets can't compete with slave labor, which explains why monopoly and other socialist practices take hold. Corruption has a long arm.

Re:What Happens When Housing Prices Go Down? by lenerdenator on Monday July 21, 2025 @11:11AM (#44636101)
> The only people losing are the people in Detroit.

I mean, that's a lot of people.

Also, the company doesn't pay people less all around. They pay workers less. The c-suite still makes more, and shareholders, who never did any work for the company whatsoever, get paid more. Car manufacturers haven't substantially lowered prices in years; so there are people paying more to get a car made by people making less.

Re:What Happens When Housing Prices Go Down? by lenerdenator on Monday July 21, 2025 @09:46AM (#44635023)
Or out of the country completely.
Re:What Happens When Housing Prices Go Down? by hollywood_court on Monday July 21, 2025 @10:08AM (#44635278)
That's definitely what many of the 'American' automobile brands have been doing.
Re:What Happens When Housing Prices Go Down? by atherton33 on Monday July 21, 2025 @09:28AM (#44634852)
Cambridge MA just had a major shift on zoning towards "build more" in Q1. It will be an interesting natural experiment to watch.

https://www.boston.com/news/politics/2025/02/11/cambridge-el...

Re:What Happens When Housing Prices Go Down? by indymike on Monday July 21, 2025 @09:42AM (#44634975)
> "If “build more” was going to bring prices down and stabilize the system, we wouldn’t be seeing these mixed signals."

Bringing prices down is usually a losing idea with existing asset holders. Even a financially strapped homeowner does not want the price of her/his home to go down. Politically, this is a complete non-starter. Also, appreciating home values serve as a very strong way to attract talent to a city.

> "Prices are softening. Delinquencies are rising. Builders are walking.

What do you expect. Why would a homeowner send 1-2 paychecks a month to pay interest into an investment that is losing value? Why would a builder start making an asset that will be worth less than when they started building?

Re:What Happens When Housing Prices Go Down? by avmich on Monday July 21, 2025 @09:54AM (#44635134)
> Why would a homeowner send 1-2 paychecks...

Can't the asset holder - the homeowner in this case - get rid of the asset which stopped performing? Why such a strange financial behavior? If the houses are financials - why not to deal with them as such?

Re:What Happens When Housing Prices Go Down? by indymike on Monday July 21, 2025 @10:51AM (#44635810)
That would be rational for the home owner, but for many losing money on the biggest investment they have is not really practical. Losing value on a percentage taxed asset is not really practical for govenrment.

Also - the mortgage lender may not allow a sale at a lower than loan value price. The result is foreclosure, and even more loss in value.

Re:What Happens When Housing Prices Go Down? by aprilthird2021 on Monday July 21, 2025 @08:50PM (#44642140)
Allowing our cities to become unlivable, inhospitable, and overall crazy places to accommodate letting people have enormous gains on an asset they do barely any work to improve was not practical but we did it for many years and it's time to stop.
Re:What Happens When Housing Prices Go Down? by indymike on Thursday July 24, 2025 @09:49PM (#44678570)
> letting people have enormous gains on an asset they do barely any work to improve was not practical but we did it for many years and it's time to stop

This makes little sense. In a democracy, it will be hard to get people to vote against their own best interest.

Re:What Happens When Housing Prices Go Down? by avmich on Monday July 21, 2025 @09:56AM (#44635154)
> Builders are walking.

Why? Builders are supposed to be doing the paid work, why would they walk out of it?

Re:What Happens When Housing Prices Go Down? by AnimalMuppet on Monday July 21, 2025 @10:17AM (#44635382)
If you buy a plot of land, go to a builder and ask them to build a house on it, sure, they'll do it. That's not what most builders do most of the time, though.

Most of the time, most builders buy a piece of land, build a house on it, and then find a buyer (or at least while they're in the process of building the house). If they're having trouble selling houses, then they're left with a bunch of houses on their hands, on which they're having to pay the interest. They don't want to be in that position.

Re:What Happens When Housing Prices Go Down? by avmich on Monday July 21, 2025 @12:41PM (#44637266)
> They don't want to be in that position.

Then where are the builders which do what they're asked to? Is the problem with the banks which don't do this operation? Then it looks like a financial opportunity.

You're effectively saying "this business model doesn't work". This doesn't mean there are no other business models which work in this case. Where they are?

Re:What Happens When Housing Prices Go Down? by AnimalMuppet on Monday July 21, 2025 @01:45PM (#44638115)
> Then where are the builders which do what they're asked to?

These are independent companies. Who do you think is supposed to be asking them to do something? When a customer asks, they do it. What more do you want?

> This doesn't mean there are no other business models which work in this case. Where they are?

They made less money than this model over the last decade or two. So they are nonexistent, not in the sense that they are impossible, but in the sense that nobody uses them.

Could companies start using them? Sure. But probably, first some homebuilders who use the current model have to go bankrupt. (A side benefit is that some already-built homes would go on the market at bankruptcy sale prices.)

Re:What Happens When Housing Prices Go Down? by avmich on Monday July 21, 2025 @02:54PM (#44638977)
> But probably, first some homebuilders who use the current model have to go bankrupt.

I think it's not necessary. The different model homebuilders should pick up the orders, that's it.

Re:What Happens When Housing Prices Go Down? by AnimalMuppet on Monday July 21, 2025 @03:50PM (#44639674)
They don't exist - today, at least not in any quantity. There are very few "different model" homebuilders waiting around to pick up the orders.

It's not like you think it should be, and the path from here to there is less smooth than you seem to think it is.

Re:What Happens When Housing Prices Go Down? by avmich on Monday July 21, 2025 @06:02PM (#44640913)
People built houses for millenia. In America the small scale builders were here pretty recently - even now, I suspect, you can find them all across the country. I would be surprised if people completely forgot how to build houses all by themselves.
Re:What Happens When Housing Prices Go Down? by aprilthird2021 on Monday July 21, 2025 @10:07AM (#44635277)
> Bringing prices down is usually a losing idea with existing asset holders

Good. They should lose because they abused government policies through NIMBYism to inflate their assets prices. Happy to see them lose

Re:What Happens When Housing Prices Go Down? by indymike on Monday July 21, 2025 @10:55AM (#44635874)
This would be nearly every family in America. I'm not happy seeing my kids, my 80 year old mother lose money they are counting on. This is really the problem - reducing home prices hurts homeowners. And homeowners are litteraly everyone.
Re:What Happens When Housing Prices Go Down? by DangitBobby on Monday July 21, 2025 @12:05PM (#44636840)
It certainly hurts homeowners who would be upside down on their mortgage, which would mostly be people who just bought a house and people with a 2nd mortgage. My house costing twice what it did when I bought it does literally nothing for me because so does every other house! I can't actually get anything from the increased "value". Actually, it mostly hurts me because I pay more in insurance and property taxes.
Re:What Happens When Housing Prices Go Down? by zozbot234 on Monday July 21, 2025 @01:40PM (#44638044)
Households stand to gain overall from increased supply. House prices per se are a wash; even a homeowner indirectly pays a whole lot of hidden "rent" on local real estate since it's going to enter into the price of anything that's bought locally.
Re:What Happens When Housing Prices Go Down? by aprilthird2021 on Monday July 21, 2025 @08:45PM (#44642101)
It would not be nearly every family in America, that's the point. That's why people are mad. We work for 30-40 years and have no pathway to home ownership so your 80 year old mother can have a home appreciate 800% over her lifetime without lifting a finger.
Re:What Happens When Housing Prices Go Down? by projektfu on Monday July 21, 2025 @09:57AM (#44635172)
Perhaps because they signed a contract and want to buy another house sometime.
Re:What Happens When Housing Prices Go Down? by drewcon on Monday July 21, 2025 @09:31AM (#44634876)
Austin. They’ve built more and prices have declined.
Re:What Happens When Housing Prices Go Down? by kasey_junk on Monday July 21, 2025 @09:29AM (#44634856)
It’s not just regulation either. Housing companies are not building as much as they did prior to 2008, which had substantially the same regulatory environment in most places.

The idea that we’ve started building enough to bring prices down is a non-starter.

Re:What Happens When Housing Prices Go Down? by PretzelFisch on Monday July 21, 2025 @09:37AM (#44634934)
Why would the builder want to build enough to let prices drop? They seem to play a lot of games to give buyers incentives that do not lower the sales price.
Re:What Happens When Housing Prices Go Down? by thechao on Monday July 21, 2025 @10:02AM (#44635218)
My wife really wants to build a house; we've started by doing some light remodeling using GC's who also build houses to a "get a feel for it". There's a strong incentive for a good GC to truly believe the estimate he gives you. (They're all dudes, around here.) However, that estimate is rarely close — usually the budget goes over 50–100%. Here's the thing: the GC gets paid off the total cost, not the original contact, and he gets a cut of the cost. So, really, there's no incentive at all for him to control costs.

A buddy of mine works for a large grocer down here (HEB). The way HEB builds is that they get a build contract and a bunch of lawyers, and the GC has to demonstrate that they have enough assets that HEB can go after to make them (HEB) whole. If the GC goes over estimate, then that's on the GC, not on HEB. HEB gets a building or they take the money back.

As an individual, you can "act like HEB" by going with a major builder. Down here that'd be Pulte or someone like that; alternately, there's a lot of high quality factory-built custom homes. I'm trying to convince my wife that we should build a metal building on post-and-beam with a crawl space. We can build a minimum viable house for 25¢/$ compared to a custom, and the quality is straight-up an order-of-magnitude better. The rest of the house can be finished out using off-the-shelf components.

Re:What Happens When Housing Prices Go Down? by khaoohs on Monday July 21, 2025 @11:39AM (#44636483)
I'd be interested in any details/links you can share about a metal building post-and-beam.
Re:What Happens When Housing Prices Go Down? by pixl97 on Monday July 21, 2025 @09:43AM (#44634989)
Well because they hold inventory. If homes didn't have a year long build pipeline with another 6 months+ holding for sale buffer they'd probably care a lot less. Otherwise a 10% drop in prices can lead to their bankruptcy.
Re:What Happens When Housing Prices Go Down? by avmich on Monday July 21, 2025 @10:00AM (#44635198)
Oh, that's good. Those are institutionalized builders who hold inventory. Let them go. Let builders who are paid workers to do the job, whose income doesn't depend on house price but is described in contract between owner, bank and the builder. What's wrong with such a schema?
Re:What Happens When Housing Prices Go Down? by kasey_junk on Monday July 21, 2025 @05:35PM (#44640689)
Most houses are not built 1:1 with the land underneath it. Builders buy larger plots and then use it to make multiple houses. So a builder would need to enter at least the land risk in your scheme still.

Then if they had to wait for each plot and future house sale to occur before pricing the sale they couldn't get economies of scale.

Effectively your scheme turns every house into a more complicated bespoke futures contract with more parties involved.

There maybe benefits to that but it doesn’t seem like a system designed to get more houses built.

Re:What Happens When Housing Prices Go Down? by pixl97 on Monday July 21, 2025 @06:48PM (#44641258)
>Builders buy larger plots and then use it to make multiple houses.

Most people that had their house built decades ago don't realize the requirements for things like runoff control in modern subdivisions. In the past your water was someone else's problem, which as populations grew lead to some people getting screwed when flood waters reached new heights because of all the new impermeable land. Water impounding and runoff control are very hard to build by an individual unless they have a large chunk of land (which acts as the sink). Any dense new SFH typically ends up in a MUD that provides all the utilities and water controls and this is insanely expensive unless distributed across a large number of units.

If we want to control housing prices it won't be by building more SFH. It will be by building more dense style housing.

Re:What Happens When Housing Prices Go Down? by avmich on Monday July 21, 2025 @06:00PM (#44640902)
It surely wins if the other side just walks away from the problem.
Re:What Happens When Housing Prices Go Down? by pixl97 on Monday July 21, 2025 @06:49PM (#44641262)
Only if there isn't still demand for more houses or a growing population.

Otherwise houses won't get built and the prices of existing houses will go even higher.

Re:What Happens When Housing Prices Go Down? by bryanlarsen on Monday July 21, 2025 @09:49AM (#44635076)
> Where have we seen anything close to 'build more'?

It's considerably easier to build in Canadian cities than most American cities. Not easy, but easier.

Over the past ten years Canadian cities have seen incredible growth, due to high immigration levels. Toronto is the fastest growing city in North America. Vancouver isn't far behind.

Yet Vancouver has seen flat housing prices over the last 10 years. [1] (Though flat at a very high level). Toronto housing prices are down 5% in the last 12 months.

1: https://realestatecoalharbour.com/blog/vancouver-house-price...

2: https://www.nesto.ca/home-buying/toronto-housing-market-outl...

Re:What Happens When Housing Prices Go Down? by 9rx on Monday July 21, 2025 @10:10AM (#44635322)
> Toronto is the fastest growing city in North America.

Wouldn't that be more apt to be Langford? https://www12.statcan.gc.ca/census-recensement/2021/as-sa/98...

East Gwillimbury, the fastest growing municipality in Canada, is within Toronto CMA. Perhaps that is what you were thinking of? But Toronto CMA is not a city, neither legally nor colloquially. Its mostly rural area. Growth in the City of Toronto is relatively slow.

Re:What Happens When Housing Prices Go Down? by gilbetron on Monday July 21, 2025 @09:55AM (#44635149)
Median houses in Vancouver are $2-4m ?? Wow.
Re:What Happens When Housing Prices Go Down? by bryanlarsen on Monday July 21, 2025 @10:29AM (#44635519)
Suburbs are about $1M CAD, ($750K USD).
Re:What Happens When Housing Prices Go Down? by nancyminusone on Monday July 21, 2025 @09:33AM (#44634895)
Where I live, there are about a dozen new housing development sites. I pass by 3 of them on my way into work, and my drive is only 10 minutes long. I've lived here 15 years and haven't seen anything like it. Someone somewhere must think it's worthwhile.

Disclaimer: I don't live in a major city, I live just outside a minor one. It's all condos.

Re:What Happens When Housing Prices Go Down? by Aurornis on Monday July 21, 2025 @09:37AM (#44634932)
> Where have we seen anything close to 'build more'? Regulations in many major cities have prevented building more for decades and I haven't seen any loosening of these regulations (they were only increased during the Biden administration).

Housing prices are high everywhere, not just major cities.

Interestingly, in my state we have a lot of land for building houses if you drive to nearby cities. Some people uproot themselves and move 30-45 minutes away so they can have a much bigger, nicer, newer house. Most often when they start a family.

If you’re willing to move an hour away you can even get these big new houses for very affordable prices.

Many people don’t want that, though. They want to live in the city. So these big new houses remain cheap, while housing in the city remains expensive.

It seems like an easy solution would be to start knocking down houses in the city and building tall, dense buildings. Except that is happening, and the same people don’t want those either. Even condo complexes are having a hard time selling units.

What people here continue to want is the one thing that cannot be scaled: Full houses of their own that are in the city. No amount of demolishing buildings and building density will fix that, because it’s not what they want.

I was completely wrong in guessing that COVID and remote work would help housing prices by allowing people to move anywhere. Most of the people I knew who relocated due to remote work took the opportunity to move toward cities where their friends lived, not to cheaper areas.

I think we must continue to build, though. Eventually new cities and interesting locations will be bootstrapped. I think housing prices in popular areas will remain stubbornly high, though.

Re:What Happens When Housing Prices Go Down? by nemomarx on Monday July 21, 2025 @09:45AM (#44635021)
If the condos aren't selling, shouldn't we see the prices go down? There's gotta be an equilibrium at some very cheap rent for them
Re:What Happens When Housing Prices Go Down? by spicybbq on Monday July 21, 2025 @10:03AM (#44635223)
In the long run, yeah. In the short run, owners can carry unsold inventory for quite a while, hoping conditions improve, before there is pressure to do something (e.g. a balloon payment).
Re:What Happens When Housing Prices Go Down? by zahlman on Monday July 21, 2025 @09:45AM (#44635006)
> Housing prices are high everywhere, not just major cities.... So these big new houses remain cheap, while housing in the city remains expensive.

?

Re:What Happens When Housing Prices Go Down? by carlosjobim on Monday July 21, 2025 @10:00AM (#44635200)
> Even condo complexes are having a hard time selling units.

Because instead of purchasing a house, you're just purchasing the right to continue being a renter. Meaning that the only reason to buy is that you expect an even bigger sucker to buy it from you later. And with rapidly declining population and widespread poverty among the young generation, there aren't that many bigger suckers around anymore.

Re:What Happens When Housing Prices Go Down? by kiba on Monday July 21, 2025 @10:01AM (#44635207)
A condo just means the maintenance fee is explicit, rather than implicit.
Re:What Happens When Housing Prices Go Down? by jonfromsf on Monday July 21, 2025 @12:50PM (#44637374)
And done by professionals, not homeowners. Honestly most people aren't very good at managing home maintenance, so this makes a lot of sense at scale.
Re:What Happens When Housing Prices Go Down? by micromacrofoot on Monday July 21, 2025 @09:37AM (#44634930)
The problem is that housing is a major investment vehicle, people in these cities always complain about what's going to happen to their property values so they prefer exclusionary zoning.

Developers have a hell of a time building in these areas even once they get zoning variances, because abutters will show up and complain about every single detail and try to make the property as small and unprofitable as possible. You start off with a 12 unit building with no parking and you end up with a 6 unit building with 12 parking spots in a garage that no one uses.

There's one instance in my neighborhood where the city and developer have been meeting with residents over the course of a year to try and come to an agreement on what should be built. There's just a derelict single-family house on the lot.

Re:What Happens When Housing Prices Go Down? by kiba on Monday July 21, 2025 @09:57AM (#44635170)
The problem is speculative investing, not making a profit per se. If your incentive is to prevent improvement of your community, then you're going to prevent making it worthwhile for anyone to come in and invest their effort. That could often means deterring developers, for example.
Re:What Happens When Housing Prices Go Down? by femiagbabiaka on Monday July 21, 2025 @09:43AM (#44634984)
I’ve never seen a comment that so reflects that the writer did not read the article as this. There are 3 or 4 examples quoted in TFA, all cited.
Re:What Happens When Housing Prices Go Down? by freejazz on Monday July 21, 2025 @09:43AM (#44634985)
> prevented building more for decades

What planet do people live on? Go to any neighborhood in NYC and you are going to see tons of construction.

Re:What Happens When Housing Prices Go Down? by sim7c00 on Monday July 21, 2025 @09:49AM (#44635077)
i am sure lots of ppl on this planet dont have the option to go around NYC to check out the construction. for various reasons.... also, lots of construction does not equal fixing lack of housing. it has to keep up with and overtake new ppl moving into the region, which often times it does not (so it has no impact on prices or availability, just population growth...).

idk about NYC specifics ofc. but thats how it work in my country. they build new houses, new ppl come in. still nothing available generally, and everything about 2x price over 10 years while income doesnt rise to compensate.

there is a lot of constructions of homes here too. but for the wrong reasons and with the wrong intensity.

Re:What Happens When Housing Prices Go Down? by freejazz on Monday July 21, 2025 @11:35AM (#44636431)
People are building plenty here. The poster said building was being prevented. That's not the case.
Re:What Happens When Housing Prices Go Down? by tenthirtyam on Monday July 21, 2025 @12:37PM (#44637203)
In Ireland, politicians (make appearances of) are making a lot of noise about building more houses to address the severe shortage of housing supply (and consequent runaway house price inflation). However, my take is that the root of the problem is exactly what the author here describes, to wit, the minimum housing a person can buy is (for the most part) a semi-detached two- or two-and-a-half-bedroom* house on two floors. There are precious few one-bedroom apartments or anything similar on the market, meaning that single persons entering the market are competing with couples or young families.

I don't understand the details but I'm told the origin of this is that regulations have rendered apartments of any size unprofitable to build (anyone with more insight here?). Pretty much the only housing Ireland gets are sprawling suburban housing estates. I'm reminded of this graphic, 100 houses Vs 100 apartments [1].

* By 2½ bedrooms I mean two bedrooms plus a very small "box room" barely big enough for a single bed and a small wardrobe. Frequently used as either a storage room or small home office.

[1] https://i.pinimg.com/originals/78/f5/94/78f594ebb9216e50e396...