News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Digital vassals? French Government 'exposes citizens' dat... by protocolture on Sunday July 20, 2025 @07:43PM (#44630457)
>What I'm trying to say is: like in many offices, any slight change made users hostile,

I remember doing a Windows 7 deployment for a customer, and one of their staff had 3 A4 binders. Probably 1000 pages, of typed notes about how Windows XP works.

The second she sat down at her new Windows 7 machine it was like she had lost her memory. She was instantly aggravated and couldnt find the start menu. Dropped her windows xp binders in the bin and told me to effectively "get lost" so she can relearn it from scratch.

I was thrown. Like its basically the same system with some UI tweaks but she was acting like I had pushed her onto debian or something.

Re:Digital vassals? French Government 'exposes citizens' dat... by MarkSweep on Sunday July 20, 2025 @08:00PM (#44630556)
I’ve had a few family relations approach technology this way. I think it’s like they are missing a “theory of mind” for how software works. We have developed this intuition by either using or creating software for a long time.

Like often people are scared to click random buttons or explore menus. We have used software for a long time, so we know that any destructive act would be proceeded by an “are you sure?” dialog box.

I think I would be in their shoes if I ever tried to change the oil on my car. I may be able to follow a procedure. But I would not deviate from it. It would not try to pop the covers off unrelated parts to peek into the alternator, for fear of electric shock.

Anyways, my rambling point is ideally we people would make themselves more familiar with how to understand the technology they work with everyday. But we should have empathy for people who have not contorted their minds to understand the peculiar behavior of software.

Re:Digital vassals? French Government 'exposes citizens' dat... by jact on Sunday July 20, 2025 @11:13PM (#44631458)
Yes, this is extremely accurate. Many people are very afraid to explore or experiment with any software program out of fear of breaking things.
Re:Digital vassals? French Government 'exposes citizens' dat... by xwolfi on Monday July 21, 2025 @04:09AM (#44632830)
Because when they break things they lose hours of work they cannot afford to lose. My parents had a small business and if my mom mis-clicked somewhere and deleted some important thing, she would enter a panicked rage as she'd lose half the day with some remote tech support.

She would never touch a computer after work, because it just stressed her, she found them absolutely unbearable, also because the tech support was unbearably obnoxious.

Re:Digital vassals? French Government 'exposes citizens' dat... by jact on Monday July 21, 2025 @04:06PM (#44639858)
This is true — which is why simple version control should be de rigueur in any important application where it’s feasible.

The move to put everything in /the cloud is irritating but probably in part driven by this consumer complaint. Not that the boomers will ever learn.

Re:Digital vassals? French Government 'exposes citizens' dat... by KronisLV on Monday July 21, 2025 @12:15PM (#44636955)
> I think it’s like they are missing a “theory of mind” for how software works.

This is a delightful way to put it! I have older relatives that can't really tell apart where a website ends and where their operating system begins, due to not really knowing about the client server model (even when it's explained to them) and I worry about the generation that will also just grow up with phone apps.

That's why I actually liked the classes back in school where we had all sorts of office program tasks to do, though I wish some of the later stuff from university would also be more widespread. Probably not programming for everyone (unless something practical with like Python), but just a few lessons on how the Internet works.

Re:Digital vassals? French Government 'exposes citizens' dat... by dotancohen on Sunday July 20, 2025 @09:50PM (#44631083)

  > she was acting like I had pushed her onto debian or something.
I've actually upgraded elderly people's computers from various Windows versions to various Ubuntu versions. I always tell them it's the newest Windows version, and very rarely have seen any problems. No joke, one of the biggest issues I saw was finding a solitaire program similar enough to the windows solitaire program.
Re:Digital vassals? French Government 'exposes citizens' dat... by CalRobert on Monday July 21, 2025 @02:11AM (#44632222)
As someone who liked windows seven I find Ubuntu clearer than windows 11.
Re:Digital vassals? French Government 'exposes citizens' dat... by protocolture on Wednesday July 23, 2025 @02:16AM (#44656181)
Not @ you in particular, but theres a rogue "computer guy" in my dads town who literally goes around "fixing" elderly peoples computers for a few hundred bucks, all he does is format them and install linux mint.

My dad, who is a little bit technical from a long time ago, spends a lot of time helping distraught users reinstall windows (to get some application going that the brains trust of the middle of nowhere australia cant get going on linux) or just helping people recover photos etc from cloud backups.

Guys like an old west linux bandit or something.

Re:Digital vassals? French Government 'exposes citizens' dat... by dotancohen on Wednesday July 23, 2025 @10:58AM (#44659950)
For what it's worth I've never been paid for that service. And I go to great trouble in enumerating the applications that people use and the files that they access, including cloud files.
Re:Digital vassals? French Government 'exposes citizens' dat... by tacticus on Monday July 21, 2025 @02:07AM (#44632210)
> Probably 1000 pages, of typed notes about how Windows XP works.

Probably more than microsoft themselves maintained.

Re:Digital vassals? French Government 'exposes citizens' dat... by potato3732842 on Monday July 21, 2025 @06:19AM (#44633542)
I wonder if she found any UI bugs that they don't know about.
Re:Digital vassals? French Government 'exposes citizens' dat... by protocolture on Monday July 21, 2025 @07:22PM (#44641486)
From what I remember it was like:

To do X, click start <screenshot of start> and select documents <screenshot of documents>

To do Y, click start <screenshot of start> and select calculator....

etc etc.

Re:Digital vassals? French Government 'exposes citizens' dat... by GoblinSlayer on Monday July 21, 2025 @03:59AM (#44632776)
Changing the UI was the biggest mistake by microsoft, can't overestimate it.
Re:Digital vassals? French Government 'exposes citizens' dat... by chithanh on Monday July 21, 2025 @04:36AM (#44633002)
That is seriously how some people navigate through life, not just computers.

Like if they want to go to a certain office in a building: My "instructions" would be to go to department foo, room A5.303 (made up number). Their instructions are something like "in that red brick building, take the elevator to 5th floor, turn left and then again left into the hallway, second door on the right side".

If they navigate UI the same way, then of course every element that is moved slightly to a new place or grouped differently will cause their mental model of how things work to collapse.

Re:Digital vassals? French Government 'exposes citizens' dat... by StopDisinfo910 on Monday July 21, 2025 @06:52AM (#44633719)
Your equivalence seems widely inaccurate to me. I too sometimes have a mental model which is "red building, third floor, left then left" because that’s spatial memory. A random room number tells you absolutely nothing about where you actually have to go. I can (and sometimes do) remember one and will use one if it’s all I have but that’s just random information totally different from actual direction.

I think your comment actually hits the heart of the issue. Most software developers I have met have this kind of disdain for their users familiarity and ability and act like they are above that. Most confuse their own learned familiarity when they were young and could tinker with some kind of superior ability. Well, just go read any post here about systemd, the syntax of Ocaml, or the new ux of any popular framework and you will see that we are all the same.

Accepting change takes time, especially if people had no desire for the change. Most people don’t care about their computers. They are for them a necessary impediment in the way of doing what they want to do. That’s why they dislike change: it looks like work for no upside. A major part of change management is explaining to people where the upsides are for them, helping them operating in the new environment and giving them time to process.

Re:Digital vassals? French Government 'exposes citizens' dat... by hnbad on Monday July 21, 2025 @07:32AM (#44633977)
> Most software developers I have met have this kind of disdain for their users familiarity and ability and act like they are above that.

This is absolutely true.

For what it's worth, "so-and-so department, room 123" is only a helpful mental model for navigation if you have additional knowledge not present in that description: that the department is probably contained entirely in one specific building, where that building is, that the rooms are likely numbered sequentially following a pattern that also indicates the floor they're in, etc. By itself this is an address whereas "red building, third floor, left then left" is a turn-by-turn route.

In terms of UIs, the latter is more like "left-hand side of the menu bar, 'Edit' menu I think, half-way down the screen, something like 'Modify' or 'Change' or 'Transform' or something, then third item in the list, something like 'Skew' or 'Bend' or something" compared to the first just being "Transform -> Skew". The former is fuzzier and the exact labels don't really matter because you'll know them when you see them. The latter is extremely precise but tells you nothing about how to actually find what you're looking for (is it in the 'Edit' menu? is it in a right-click context menu? etc). It's only really useful by itself if you have a command palette.

Re:Digital vassals? French Government 'exposes citizens' dat... by chithanh on Tuesday July 22, 2025 @03:56AM (#44644342)
> I think your comment actually hits the heart of the issue. Most software developers I have met have this kind of disdain for their users familiarity and ability and act like they are above that.

That is not what I meant. I don't say those users are worse for it, rather that user interfaces of course need to accommodate such approaches. Such as placing a notice at the old location which directs users to the new location (like when a brick-and-mortar-store moves).

Also when performing tasks routinely, of course I have muscle memory and will get slightly irritated when the newest function absorbed into systemd does things differently than the thing which it replaced. I have no desire for or against systemd, but I understand that this is how the world revolves and that one has get along with the times.

> Most confuse their own learned familiarity when they were young and could tinker with some kind of superior ability.

It is just willingness to learn. How you learn and how fast you learn is of course age dependent, but the attitude towards learning new things and breaking out of routine is what matters more.

Re:Digital vassals? French Government 'exposes citizens' dat... by potato3732842 on Monday July 21, 2025 @06:19AM (#44633538)
>That is seriously how some people navigate through life, not just computers.

This "treat everything like a ludicrously complex black box that almost nobody can understand" for any given subject are the lowest common denominator that laws get written to.

Re:Digital vassals? French Government 'exposes citizens' dat... by moritzwarhier on Monday July 21, 2025 @03:04PM (#44639073)
It's also how IT professionals navigate software interfaces!

I'm amused by the amount of flak you are getting here.

Being fast and efficient with any piece of UI of course means to replace navigation and discovery with memory and intuition, at least in part!

Not just keyboard shortcuts, also the placement of UI elements, latencies, learning quirky behaviors... being fast with software means not having to discover features.

Similar to labeled controls on a physical device, just in a simulacrum.

Re:Digital vassals? French Government 'exposes citizens' dat... by Xlr8head on Tuesday July 22, 2025 @04:36AM (#44644580)
This is maybe down to using the same cognitive pathways to navigate SW that we use to navigate the real world: way points en route to a destination. Whereas those with more understanding of the system can deploy other methods that are a more direct fit to that structure. The problem is, then, that if you change the terrain (e.g. new os) you also need to change the map/route in the heads of all those users without system knowledge. Even some of those with system knowledge might STILL preferentially deploy their innate navigation cognition.