News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The bewildering phenomenon of declining quality by lenkite on Sunday July 20, 2025 @02:27PM (#44627878)
They don't do well in the US due to ideological aversion, no policy incentives and lack of funding platforms like community investment trusts.

But they are quite successful in other nations. Amul in India for example.

Re:The bewildering phenomenon of declining quality by WalterBright on Sunday July 20, 2025 @03:42PM (#44628631)
> due to ideological aversion

Nobody cares if they're buying from a collective or a conventional business.

> no policy incentives

Are you saying they should get special government incentives not available to businesses?

> lack of funding platforms

Nobody is stopping anyone from funding a collective. The reason they don't is they won't get ownership shares in return. That's one of the problems with a collective.

Re:The bewildering phenomenon of declining quality by TheOtherHobbes on Sunday July 20, 2025 @08:12PM (#44630625)
If they got the same incentives offered to businesses, that would be interesting.

Coops are fairly common in Europe, mostly in agro-food and related areas.

They're actually better at innovation for their market segments, because they can make long-term plans for expansion instead of being hamstrung by the demands of ridiculous short-term marketing-driven hype bubbles.

But if you want to profit from frothy get-rich-quick hype and don't care if this year's unicorn is next year's "Our incredible adventure comes to an end", they're definitely not for you.

Re:The bewildering phenomenon of declining quality by lenkite on Sunday July 20, 2025 @11:04PM (#44631411)
> Nobody cares if they're buying from a collective or a conventional business.

Before buying, you need to startup and produce.

> Are you saying they should get special government incentives not available to businesses?

Its the other way around. They are not eligible for incentives that are available to traditional corporations. They cannot issue traditional equity. There are also no equivalent cooperative-friendly structure like a Delaware C corporation which allows for friendly taxation and non-liability for the debts and legal obligations of the corporation. Difficult to apply R&D Tax Credit like corporations since it cannot carry forward credits due to legal constraints. Cannot claim Payroll Offset like startups do, etc.

The system in the US simply does not give incentives to cooperatives to the same extent that it facilitates corporations.