Re:BranchOut Falsifies Wall Street Journal Quote
by JoshTriplett on Saturday September 01, 2012 @12:23AM
(#4462645)
"Falsifies" seems like an odd choice of words here; I went to the article expecting that the Wall Street Journal made some statement that BranchOut managed to disprove, not that BranchOut faked a quote from the Wall Street Journal.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:BranchOut Falsifies Wall Street Journal Quote
by tmurray on Saturday September 01, 2012 @12:26AM
(#4462649)
"falsify" means "to forge or alter as to deceive," not disprove.
Re:BranchOut Falsifies Wall Street Journal Quote
by _pius on Saturday September 01, 2012 @12:38AM
(#4462668)
Though I didn't find this confusing in context, it actually means both.
Re:BranchOut Falsifies Wall Street Journal Quote
by opminion on Saturday September 01, 2012 @01:51AM
(#4462780)
In philosophy of science, when discussing what makes a good hypothesis, it is used as disprove.
As in: the existence of the Spaghetti Monster cannot be falsified, and thus to believe in it is an act of faith.
http://www.stephenjaygould.org/ctrl/popper_falsification.htm...
Re:BranchOut Falsifies Wall Street Journal Quote
by Gormo on Saturday September 01, 2012 @09:17AM
(#4463588)
It doesn't mean "to disprove" as much as it means "to posit a condition under which the statement would be disproved". In other words, a falsifiable claim is one that can be empirically tested, not one that's necessarily already been proven false.
Re:BranchOut Falsifies Wall Street Journal Quote
by wcarss on Saturday September 01, 2012 @10:45AM
(#4463822)
To be disprovable is to be "falsifiable". To disprove, then, is to "falsify".
Re:BranchOut Falsifies Wall Street Journal Quote
by Bill_Dimm on Saturday September 01, 2012 @11:10AM
(#4463900)
Regardless, "fabricates" would be a lot clearer.
Re:BranchOut Falsifies Wall Street Journal Quote
by socialsplat on Saturday September 01, 2012 @10:50PM
(#4465960)
I agree. I had sort of a brain fart when I was coming up with a title, and couldn't think of anything that hit the mark short of "BranchOut puts quote from Wall Street Journal that Never Was."
Too late to change the URL now, but the title itself is changed.