News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The bewildering phenomenon of declining quality by teiferer on Sunday July 20, 2025 @10:10AM (#44625350)
> Prior to that energy was almost seen as disposable

Turns out that from an environmental perspective, that view was bad anyway and I'm glad it's gone for good (even if the AI hype almost makes us forget that again). I don't fully see how that implies everything having to be crap now. Lighter doesn't mean worse quality.

Re:The bewildering phenomenon of declining quality by swiftcoder on Sunday July 20, 2025 @10:40AM (#44625637)
> Lighter doesn't mean worse quality

For a number of product categories it means replacing solid metal parts with inferior materials, and that pretty explicitly does mean worse quality.

Have you used a 1960s KitchenAid mixer? They look almost identical to models that followed - but in the 1970s KitchenAid replaced the metal drive gear with one made of nylon on the consumer-focussed models, and now if you use one heavily, you'll have to replace that gear more or less annually.

Re:The bewildering phenomenon of declining quality by bigstrat2003 on Sunday July 20, 2025 @02:30PM (#44627922)
The question is, does that prevent something worse from breaking? It's not inherently bad to have wear parts in a device, after all. Shear pins are a great example where you need to replace them, but something more important would break if it wasn't the shear pin, so it's worth it.

IDK the design of the mixers well enough to know if that's true for them, but I do wonder if that is the case.

Re:The bewildering phenomenon of declining quality by bsder on Sunday July 20, 2025 @06:23PM (#44629928)
> The question is, does that prevent something worse from breaking?

That doesn't matter if it means, for example, that my new mixer can't actually mix bread dough on a higher speed anymore (citing this as it's actually a failure mode on newer (like 1970s forward) KitchenAid mixers to the point that the manual mentions it).

That is an objective decrease in quality and fitness for purpose.

Re:The bewildering phenomenon of declining quality by swiftcoder on Monday July 21, 2025 @06:17AM (#44633521)
> The question is, does that prevent something worse from breaking?

That is the stated justification, yes. However, in practice pre-1970s models will happily knead bread dough for years on end, and more recent models tend to explode within the first few times you attempt to make a loaf of bread (leading home bread makers to have to spend more on an expensive commercial model...)

Re:The bewildering phenomenon of declining quality by immibis on Monday July 21, 2025 @07:08AM (#44633816)
Lighter can mean worse quality, but it doesn't have to. For example, a whole lot of things don't need metal enclosures, and plastic can be molded into more ergonomic shapes too. Now, whether the plastic enclosure is made tough or super thin is up to the manufacturer, and of course most of them choose the more profitable planned obsolescence route.
Re:The bewildering phenomenon of declining quality by teiferer on Wednesday July 23, 2025 @11:23AM (#44660256)
It's hard to distinguish "worse because lighter" from "worse because planned obsolescense". Historically, both effects correlated in their introduction into design and manufacturing consumer products. Attributing everything to just once of the two is not doing justice to the actual mechanisms.
Re:The bewildering phenomenon of declining quality by fragmede on Sunday July 20, 2025 @02:35PM (#44627980)
> Lighter doesn't mean worse quality.

It doesn't, but heft of a product is used as a proxy for quality, to the point that electronics will sometimes have a weight glued inside to pretend the item is heavier than it is, in order to seem of higher quality.

Re:The bewildering phenomenon of declining quality by teiferer on Wednesday July 23, 2025 @11:19AM (#44660203)
Which greatly illustrates the point that it's mote of a feeling than inherent property. People got used to expect crap quality from lighter products, because at the same time as plastics became more available and more versatile, so did planned obsolescence. So they are fallaciously expecting a heavy item to not having been cheaped out on so much.