Re:Will the Fear of Being Confused for AI Mean That We Will ...
by Eddy_Viscosity2 on Sunday July 20, 2025 @07:22AM
(#44624094)
> use LLMs to help them phrase their thoughts
But is it their thoughts? Another problem with LLMs is that while it sometimes can produce a better english phrasing of what they were thinking, other times it could be something conceptually different that they didn't catch because of thier english isn't proficient enough to see it, or worse case, they are just lazy and write broad vague prompts and accept whatever blob of text comes out.
Re:Will the Fear of Being Confused for AI Mean That We Will ...
by victorbjorklund on Sunday July 20, 2025 @07:38AM
(#44624191)
I use it sometimes where I just write a stream of conciouness for describing how we can solve a Jira ticket. Then I let LLM edit it. It doesnt add anything or remove any pount. It just moves things around and make the text more clear by rephrasing it.
Re:Will the Fear of Being Confused for AI Mean That We Will ...
by JKCalhoun on Sunday July 20, 2025 @08:01AM
(#44624352)
I use em-dash all the time — and wish now I had not read that it is popular with AI. (I don't suppose I'll change though, for some dumb reason I like parens as well. Mimic me there, AI.)
Re:Will the Fear of Being Confused for AI Mean That We Will ...
by npsomaratna on Sunday July 20, 2025 @07:46AM
(#44624249)
Em-dash fan here as well. I've been watering down my use of the em-dash, because I don't want folk to think that my (always self-written) business emails, etc are a chatGPT job.
Re:Will the Fear of Being Confused for AI Mean That We Will ...
by Chloebaker on Sunday July 20, 2025 @07:26AM
(#44624117)
Not a day goes by where I don't mourn the desecration of the em-dash, but its frustrating for people that write “authentcally” (referring to academic work) to get accused of AI writing, when something is well phrased and carefully thought out. I do agree on the fact that its quite Luddite to expect people to slave away at a document outside of an academic context, using AI does make you much more efficient
I work with a lot of non-native English speakers (with English as a lingua franca) and I’m more than happy for them to use LLMs to help them phrase their thoughts in a way that I can understand more easily.
I also sometimes use LLMs myself for low-stakes stuff, tidying up sloppy notes, etc.
I think it’s a bit Ludditical to want people to always write every word themselves. Should they also hand write it using a quill pen and ink they made themselves from oak galls?
There are some types of writing (creative writing, writing to persuade, etc) where the writing itself benefits from being hand crafted, but most writing is just an imperfect way of sharing thoughts.