News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Meta says it wont sign Europe AI agreement, calling it gr... by threetonesun on Friday July 18, 2025 @08:31PM (#44611396)
If the Xerox machine had all of the copyrighted works in it and you just had to ask it nicely to print them I think you'd say the tool is in the wrong there, not the user.
Re:Meta says it wont sign Europe AI agreement, calling it gr... by Aurornis on Friday July 18, 2025 @08:43PM (#44611469)
LLMs do not have all copyrighted works in them.

In some cases they can be prompted to guess a number of tokens that follow an excerpt from another work.

They do not contain all copyrighted works, though. That’s an incorrect understanding.

Re:Meta says it wont sign Europe AI agreement, calling it gr... by monetus on Friday July 18, 2025 @08:46PM (#44611489)
Are there any LLMs available with a, "give me copyrighted material" button? I don't think that is how they work.

Commercial use of someone's image also already has laws concerning that as far as I know, don't they?

Re:Meta says it wont sign Europe AI agreement, calling it gr... by CamperBob2 on Friday July 18, 2025 @08:32PM (#44611403)
You'd think wrong.
Re:Meta says it wont sign Europe AI agreement, calling it gr... by zettabomb on Saturday July 19, 2025 @02:53AM (#44613191)
Xerox already went through that lawsuit and won, which is why photocopiers still exist. The tool isn't in the wrong for being told to print out the copyrighted works. The user still had to make the conscious decision to copy that particular work. Hence, still the user's fault.
Re:Meta says it wont sign Europe AI agreement, calling it gr... by 1718627440 on Saturday July 19, 2025 @09:53AM (#44615490)
You take the copyrighted work to the printer, you don't upload data to an LLM first, it is already in the machine. If you got LLMs without training data (however that works) and the user needs to provide the data, then it would be ok.
Re:Meta says it wont sign Europe AI agreement, calling it gr... by CamperBob2 on Saturday July 19, 2025 @11:57AM (#44616586)
You don't "upload" data to an LLM, but that's already been explained multiple times, and evidently it didn't soak in.

LLMs extract semantic information from their training data and store it at extremely low precision in latent space. To the extent original works can be recovered from them, those works were nothing intrinsically special to begin with. At best such works simply milk our existing culture by recapitulating ancient archetypes, a la Harry Potter or Star Wars.

If the copyright cartels choose to fight AI, the copyright cartels will and must lose. This isn't Napster Part 2: Electric Boogaloo. There is too much at stake this time.

Re:Meta says it wont sign Europe AI agreement, calling it gr... by rpdillon on Saturday July 19, 2025 @12:03PM (#44616639)
One of the reasons the New York Times didn't supply the prompts in their lawsuit is because it takes an enormous amount of effort to get LLMs to produce copyrighted works. In particular, you have to actually hand LLMs copyrighted works in the prompt to get them to continue it.

It's not like users are accidentally producing copies of Harry Potter.