News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:People kept working, became healthier while on basic inco... by t-writescode on Thursday July 17, 2025 @07:50PM (#44599634)
For those fortunate enough to have made absurd amounts of money, think of what you did when you had it. You kept making for whole different reasons. You kept making, kept doing.

The only thing that stops is tolerance of actual garbage bosses, abusive companies and saying “yes” to decisions that require you to be immoral.

Re:People kept working, became healthier while on basic inco... by bombcar on Thursday July 17, 2025 @07:56PM (#44599675)
Well, 25% stopped apparently. Which is somewhat telling.

If you gave me a $basicIncome raise I’d keep working; but I’d appreciate the cash.

If you guaranteed $basicIncome for life I’d restructure my life around that, and likely FIRE.

Re:People kept working, became healthier while on basic inco... by pxc on Thursday July 17, 2025 @08:15PM (#44599797)
[delayed]
Re:People kept working, became healthier while on basic inco... by t-writescode on Thursday July 17, 2025 @08:00PM (#44599701)
What would you do in your retirement? Loaf? Volunteer? Make art?

Two of those are “work”

Re:People kept working, became healthier while on basic inco... by atomicnumber3 on Thursday July 17, 2025 @08:29PM (#44599884)
He's do the only thing we're definitely here to do. Live.
Re:People kept working, became healthier while on basic inco... by appreciatorBus on Thursday July 17, 2025 @08:50PM (#44600023)
There are plenty of ways to volunteer or do art that are indistinguishable from loafing. Even if you work hard at volunteering or art, if the result isn't useful to others, at some point we will start wondering who is going to grow food and do plumbing while everyone is volunteering & arting.
Re:People kept working, became healthier while on basic inco... by throaway955 on Thursday July 17, 2025 @09:11PM (#44600148)
presumably people who don't like volunteering and arting, and do like working with their hands on concrete problems that directly affect peoples lives
Re:People kept working, became healthier while on basic inco... by ghiculescu on Thursday July 17, 2025 @09:29PM (#44600243)
You think there would be lots of volunteer garbage collectors?
Re:People kept working, became healthier while on basic inco... by throaway955 on Thursday July 17, 2025 @09:30PM (#44600250)
...pay them to do it? gp said "plumbing" not "the worst jobs we couldn't get people to do for free."
Re:People kept working, became healthier while on basic inco... by ghiculescu on Thursday July 17, 2025 @09:33PM (#44600270)
So basically we are going to pay people to not work, and then pay them even more to still work.
Re:People kept working, became healthier while on basic inco... by wat10000 on Thursday July 17, 2025 @11:34PM (#44600939)
Exactly. Instead of a floor of $0 and you earn more than that by working, you have a floor of $1,000/month or whatever, and you earn more than that by working. The idea is to provide a cushion, not replace wages.
Re:People kept working, became healthier while on basic inco... by throaway955 on Thursday July 17, 2025 @09:39PM (#44600303)
do you have some kind of evidence that enacting a ubi, which comes with absolutely no condition of "not working," will stop a majority of people from taking paid work and making more money? Do we need 100% of the population to work in order to fill vital positions? I don't think so.
Re:People kept working, became healthier while on basic inco... by ghiculescu on Thursday July 17, 2025 @10:24PM (#44600572)
Yeah, the article we are commenting on + most comments here are the evidence
Re:People kept working, became healthier while on basic inco... by throaway955 on Thursday July 17, 2025 @10:29PM (#44600606)
The article said 3/4 of people kept working, a significant portion of the 1/4 went back to school, and a hell of a a lot of people are in this comment section saying they would never stop working even with UBI.
Re:People kept working, became healthier while on basic inco... by dumbledoren on Thursday July 17, 2025 @08:36PM (#44599920)
Aside from half of those who stopped working going back to school, there is a simple reason why a lot of people will stop for a while when universal income or a similar scheme first starts:

People are burned out. They are overworked. Over-stressed. Most of them were just hurled into careers by the system without much choice because they had to make a living. Most of them didnt even have time to think about their choices. A majority has spent decades struggling for survival amidst financial insecurity. When universal income starts for the first time, all of these people will stop for a while and start revising their lives. Something which they needed to do way before, but were not allowed by the system. Its natural.

When they get over the burnout and do their reflection, they will go active again. We see this in the case of the privileged minority who are able to retire early or take sabbaticals. They rest and do random stuff for a while, then they go back to doing something they want to do. Especially in tech, that has been the case.

People dont like staying idle for long.

Re:People kept working, became healthier while on basic inco... by ropable on Thursday July 17, 2025 @08:46PM (#44599998)
I bet you wouldn't, at least not until your 70s. Here's my anecdote-based argument to the contrary: every single recent retiree I know (having $basicIncome as a pension) has taken 6-12 months off work and then started working again (where they are physically capable of doing so). The reasons vary from necessity, boredom or wanting to feel "useful". This seems to drop off sharply the mid-70s. I'm not saying that working is hardwired in humans, but it seems to be a strong part of our sense of self-worth.
Re:People kept working, became healthier while on basic inco... by david-gpu on Thursday July 17, 2025 @08:31PM (#44599890)
> For those fortunate enough to have made absurd amounts of money, think of what you did when you had it.

I quit my job. A handful of my coworkers did the same.

Most people, when given the chance to stop working, they stop. Just look at pensioners, including those who get a pension at 50. The vast majority simply stop working.

Re:People kept working, became healthier while on basic inco... by crtified on Thursday July 17, 2025 @11:51PM (#44601040)
You quit working in the conventional, modern, hierarchical contract employment system - a very tight and specific definition of "work".

But I'd be very surprised if you didn't still spend a goodly proportion of your time beavering away at endeavours that were productive to yourself or others in your family and community.

Re:People kept working, became healthier while on basic inco... by david-gpu on Friday July 18, 2025 @08:27AM (#44603947)
The discussion is around sustainability: when people quit paid work they no longer contribute to the very tax base that is necessary to sustain a basic income.
Re:People kept working, became healthier while on basic inco... by CuriousSkeptic on Friday July 18, 2025 @01:24PM (#44607442)
UBI could be funded in other ways than taxes. Instead we could collect rent from all commons added to the economy as private assets.
Re:People kept working, became healthier while on basic inco... by crtified on Friday July 18, 2025 @06:12PM (#44610342)
Most UBI proposals I've heard of are the equivalent of $5.00-7.50 per hour wage. If what you imply were true - that upon achieving that level, people simply said "goal reached" and ceased to be further productive - then the USA median hourly wage would not be $22.
Re:People kept working, became healthier while on basic inco... by david-gpu on Sunday July 20, 2025 @05:52PM (#44629653)
Even if UBI is set so low that it's not sufficient to live, change still happens at the margin. You will have people who were thinking about retirement that may now realize that with UBI they can bridge the gap until they get their full pension a few years from now. There will be people who are unmotivated and will now choose temporary work for part of the year and rely on UBI to make meets end. People work because they want money; reduce that incentive and fewer people will work.
Re:People kept working, became healthier while on basic inco... by crtified on Monday July 21, 2025 @12:01AM (#44631688)
That argument still relies upon the debatable premise that less formal employment means less human productivity.

For example, those "bridging the gap until their pension" are as likely to be reducing childcare costs (which are otherwise often subsidised by government/tax) for their descendants, spending more time on their own health, reducing the $health burden upon government, and any number of other potential reductions of the need for government spending. In equal proportion to the reduction in formal employment load upon the individual.

Re:People kept working, became healthier while on basic inco... by JKCalhoun on Thursday July 17, 2025 @09:35PM (#44600282)
I retired when I thought I (barely) could financially. 57 years old is by no means young, but I have done better than my parents did in that regard.

(Although I might start substitute teaching this Fall ... maybe I didn't retire after all.)

Re:People kept working, became healthier while on basic inco... by joegibbs on Thursday July 17, 2025 @09:45PM (#44600343)
That's because the kinds of people who make those huge amounts of money usually have that ambition and lack of satisfaction. But what about the parts of society that aren't go-getting yuppie strivers? There is a vast majority of people who never consider grinding leetcode to get a job at Jane Street so that they can later pivot to B2B SAAS for timeseries data.
Re:People kept working, became healthier while on basic inco... by t-writescode on Thursday July 17, 2025 @11:56PM (#44601053)
Honestly, I think you think too little of people. A *lot* of people love to invent, create, explore, dream, participate and so on. I would argue the vast, vast majority.

People I know grow crops, make food, paint, draw, build worlds, write stories, create programs and so on. And these are people from every area in life.

Re:People kept working, became healthier while on basic inco... by joegibbs on Friday July 18, 2025 @12:39AM (#44601260)
I don't deny that people love to do creative things like that. But society can't survive off creatives and gardeners and the other fun things. Those activities are nice for the people who do them but they don't help support the rest of the population - we need truckers, aged care workers, farmers, cashiers.
Re:People kept working, became healthier while on basic inco... by CuriousSkeptic on Friday July 18, 2025 @01:37PM (#44607614)
> aged care workers

Just picking out this one out of curiosity, not arguing the broader point.

In a world where people have more freedom on what to spend their energy and time on I would expect some things to return to the realm of unpaid labour. Child care, mentoring, care for the elder, local community contributions. Probably not replacing the demand entirely, but surely some shifts in supply and demand would be observed.

Re:People kept working, became healthier while on basic inco... by apparent on Saturday July 19, 2025 @12:22AM (#44612571)
There's a strong selection bias at play. People who have made absurd amounts of money are disproportionately likely to be highly-motivated people.