News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The patterns of elites who conceal their assets offshore by snickerdoodle12 on Thursday July 17, 2025 @04:49PM (#44598048)
Meanwhile the Netherlands is taxing the common people like crazy, and politicians are talking about raising taxes even more.
Re:The patterns of elites who conceal their assets offshore by conception on Thursday July 17, 2025 @05:49PM (#44598632)
The Netherlands also has the number two quality of life in the world so maybe don’t worry about it so much?

https://www.numbeo.com/quality-of-life/rankings_by_country.j...

Re:The patterns of elites who conceal their assets offshore by cyanydeez on Thursday July 17, 2025 @06:25PM (#44598976)
it's weird when Americans day dream of giving tax breaks to billionaires because they might be rich one day; it's a another thing for people who ostensibly have the best social system in the world looking at America and say "we should do that".
Re:The patterns of elites who conceal their assets offshore by snickerdoodle12 on Thursday July 17, 2025 @06:38PM (#44599075)
There are plans for making mortgages more expensive by removing tax deductions and for taxing inheritance a whopping 75%. That is hardly giving tax breaks to billionaire, more so screwing over anyone who isn't dirt poor. Oh, and I'm already paying pretty much half my income in various taxes.

Anyone who has a significant amount of money can avoid these taxes, as always.

Re:The patterns of elites who conceal their assets offshore by Tadpole9181 on Thursday July 17, 2025 @07:28PM (#44599466)
> taxing inheritance a whopping 75%

This is almost universally a sign that whoever is posting it is acting in bad faith. It sure is a good thing all these laws are documented and easily accessed with a single search.

Netherlands has a progressive tax model for inheritance taxes, that change the tax outcome based on your relation to the deceased. Let's check the two most common cases with a quite wealthy sum of money (€1.000.000) on their calculator: https://www.belastingdienst.nl/wps/wcm/connect/nl/erfbelasti...

- My spouse died: €23.000. So a huge tax burden of 2.3%.

- My parent died: €179.000. 18%. So not even remotely close to 75%.

Of course, these numbers are in your favor since the median inheritance in the Netherlands is under €100.000. For children of the deceased, it's down at around €40.000.

And for that, you pay an outstanding 4%.

If you're talking US, it's even more hogwash because we have a, what, $14,000,000 inheritance tax exclusion?

So... Would you like to amend your statement? It seems an awful lot like you're not telling the whole truth.

Re:The patterns of elites who conceal their assets offshore by ReaperCub on Thursday July 17, 2025 @08:20PM (#44599837)
The problem with inheritance tax is that the person pays taxes all through their lifetime and then when their significant others inherit that wealth (which already has been taxed once at least) it gets taxed again. The issue isn't the amount, the issue is the principle of it.

I suspect BTW the very rich won't ever pay these taxes as there are always ways to restructure the wealth or simply move it elsewhere. I know this is done in the UK. So what it does is punish the middle classes the most.

Re:The patterns of elites who conceal their assets offshore by dragonwriter on Thursday July 17, 2025 @08:31PM (#44599893)
> The problem with inheritance tax is that the person pays taxes all through their lifetime and then when their significant others inherit that wealth (which already has been taxed once at least) it gets taxed again.

Yes, because that's a transfer to different people. That's not a problem.

The problem is that it's not just treated as income to the recipients—which it manifestly is—with the income tax then being modified to include both advance recognition and windfall spreading options to allow taxpayers to deal with irregular income in a fair basis with more regular income.

This is also the problem with capital gains tax. And its not th people who have the kind of income that avoids regular income taxation that are getting screwed by that.

Re:The patterns of elites who conceal their assets offshore by ReaperCub on Thursday July 17, 2025 @09:05PM (#44600109)
> Yes, because that's a transfer to different people. That's not a problem

Sorry I don't agree. The tax has already been paid when the person was alive. There shouldn't be a an additional tax on top because it is given to others after they died. Which is what is happening.

> The problem is that it's not just treated as income to the recipients—which it manifestly is—with the income tax then being modified to include both advance recognition and windfall spreading options to allow taxpayers to deal with irregular income in a fair basis with more regular income.

The problem wouldn't exist if the tax was abolished.

> This is also the problem with capital gains tax. And its not the people who have the kind of income that avoids regular income taxation that are getting screwed by that.

Again another case of a problem that wouldn't exist if the tax (capital gains) was abolished.

Re:The patterns of elites who conceal their assets offshore by Tadpole9181 on Thursday July 17, 2025 @10:38PM (#44600652)
Tax is a means to an end (paying for civil services). Whether or not something is taxed twice is not inherently wrong, it's just a choice on how we choose to pursue our needs in a way that is effective and equitable.

I mean, reductively, saying something can't be taxed twice doesn't make any sense because all taxes work like that. A company sells products, those sales (and/or value add) are taxed. That money is paid as income, then that income is taxed. That income is spent on goods or services, where the sale (and/or value add) is taxed. Ad infinitum.

A reasonable tax on inheritance, growing with wealth, makes sense in a society that has no effective wealth caps. Otherwise the "haves" accumulate wealth, which accumulates wealth, which accumulates wealth. By imposing a tax on wealth that is not earned, but entirely dependent on the circumstances of one's birth, you create a redistribution scheme that's... Quite fair?

No living person has their labor stolen, some redistribution is achieved, but the heir still receives a significant benefit.

Re:The patterns of elites who conceal their assets offshore by ReaperCub on Thursday July 17, 2025 @11:59PM (#44601065)
> Tax is a means to an end (paying for civil services). Whether or not something is taxed twice is not inherently wrong, it's just a choice on how we choose to pursue our needs in a way that is effective and equitable.

Well in the UK, the civil services are crap, the police don't do anything, the NHS waiting times are extensive (my mother is waiting for over 2 years for knee surgery), the roads are full of pot holes, and we have more admirals than warships.

So the money doesn't seem to be used effectively. I don't know what you mean by equitable.

> I mean, reductively, saying something can't be taxed twice doesn't make any sense because all taxes work like that. A company sells products, those sales (and/or value add) are taxed. That money is paid as income, then that income is taxed. That income is spent on goods or services, where the sale (and/or value add) is taxed. Ad infinitum.

It almost like the tax man takes at every opportunity. Describing that they tax you many times isn't a justification for more taxes.

> A reasonable tax on inheritance, growing with wealth, makes sense in a society that has no effective wealth caps. Otherwise the "haves" accumulate wealth, which accumulates wealth, which accumulates wealth.

I don't think it is moral or fair to tax beneficiaries of inheritance. It is essentially a gift from the deceased to the beneficiaries.

That the entire point of building up an inheritance for your family/beneficiaries, is that you hope to leave your children better place. I don't know what is fundamentally wrong with building up wealth generationally.

> By imposing a tax on wealth that is not earned, but entirely dependent on the circumstances of one's birth, you create a redistribution scheme that's... Quite fair?

No it isn't fair. The wealth was earned at some point in time, presumably legally. I don't understand why it matters that the person receiving it may have done nothing more than been a family member, family friend or even someone/some organisation that the deceased thought was deserving? When they were alive it was their choice who would receive upon death.

Re:The patterns of elites who conceal their assets offshore by Tadpole9181 on Friday July 18, 2025 @10:21AM (#44604932)
> So the money doesn't seem to be used effectively.

That's not what we're discussing. Nor is it even the country we're discussing? The Netherlands has the second highest quality of life in the world.

> It almost like the tax man takes at every opportunity.

Taxes are a requirement of any functional nation. This just sounds like you have no intention of having a real discussion on tax policy.

> It is essentially a gift from the deceased to the beneficiaries.

Yes, that is what inheritance is. And gifts are taxed. At a higher rate than inheritance!

> I don't know what is fundamentally wrong with building up wealth generationally.

Oh, please, don't straw man me.

Nothing is wrong with generational wealth. Looking at the US, you can see how important it is for social mobility, directly affecting the outcomes of minority communities for decades to even centuries. And through systems like the private healthcare and nursing industries, how it's being targeted to extract every last cent out of American citizens before they die and can hand it off to their loved ones.

But are you seriously pretending you don't know what's wrong with a forever growing wealth inequality? Because inheritance taxes only meaningfully apply to the wealthy. We aren't talking working class folk here.

Are we supposed to wonder how will they ever survive on a mere €820.000 that they did nothing to earn? Despite the fact that being raised by someone with that kind of wealth statistically implies that they'll also be inheriting things like property. And that they will have a more stable upbringing with a better education and opportunities their working class peers would never get.

Re:The patterns of elites who conceal their assets offshore by TFYS on Friday July 18, 2025 @03:18AM (#44602097)
Most of the money circulating in the economy has been taxed many many times. The money your employer pays you has been taxed, the money that employer got from its customers was taxed, the money those customers used was their salary, which was taxed. That is such a stupid argument to make. It would mean that we should only have one tax at the root of money itself.
Re:The patterns of elites who conceal their assets offshore by cyanydeez on Friday July 18, 2025 @08:52AM (#44604157)
Paying for stability is not a problem.
Re:The patterns of elites who conceal their assets offshore by snickerdoodle12 on Friday July 18, 2025 @02:55PM (#44608462)
What? I'm talking about the netherlands, like is extremely obvious from the context. Read the thread you are replying to...

And I said politicians are talking about changing the laws. There are upcoming elections. Why are you talking about the current laws? Completely irrelevant. I very clearly said:

> There are plans for making mortgages more expensive by removing tax deductions and for taxing inheritance a whopping 75%

You could just google it, but I'll do it for you: https://www.metronieuws.nl/geld-carriere/belasting/2025/07/7...

Re:The patterns of elites who conceal their assets offshore by Tadpole9181 on Friday July 18, 2025 @08:33PM (#44611409)
I describe the law of and linked to a government website of the Netherlands.

> And I said politicians are talking about changing the laws.

No, you said "there are plans". What you did not say is that one party leader made an insane comment in a campaign cycle met with so much backlash it took less than a day to radically change to "with 0% under €500.000" and has still been unilaterally mocked by opinion makers, politicians, and media.

Re:The patterns of elites who conceal their assets offshore by snickerdoodle12 on Saturday July 19, 2025 @03:02PM (#44618339)
Buddy, I'm dutch. I am following local politics, and clearly, you're not.

> I describe the law of and linked to a government website of the Netherlands.

No shit? How is the current law relevant to plans to change it?

> What you did not say is that one party leader made an insane comment in a campaign cycle met with so much backlash it took less than a day to radically change to "with 0% under €500.000" and has still been unilaterally mocked by opinion makers, politicians, and media.

Yeah, so he's planning it. For now they seem to have changed their campaign surrounding the subject but there's no saying what they'll do if elected.

Re:The patterns of elites who conceal their assets offshore by Tadpole9181 on Saturday July 19, 2025 @03:29PM (#44618541)
Buddy, that's not really was "there are plans to" means. Unless you count MJT talking about Jewish space lasers "plans to" investigate Jewish space lasers from the US government. In which case, you've got a tabloid-level definition.

The quote of the current law is used to emphasize just how ridiculous sounding what you're saying even is.

Re:The patterns of elites who conceal their assets offshore by snickerdoodle12 on Saturday July 19, 2025 @03:41PM (#44618673)
Do you not understand that politicians can change laws?
Re:The patterns of elites who conceal their assets offshore by Tadpole9181 on Saturday July 19, 2025 @04:53PM (#44619283)
This is exactly what I mean in my first comment, you clearly aren't here in good faith. Or will you say, straight-faced, that you genuinely believe that the government is actually going to be implementing this?
Re:The patterns of elites who conceal their assets offshore by snickerdoodle12 on Tuesday July 22, 2025 @09:17AM (#44646499)
I am saying straight faced that there are politicians with plans to implement this. Which is what I said before, and it's factually true.

Whether they'll succeed is another matter. I hope they don't.

Re:The patterns of elites who conceal their assets offshore by conception on Friday July 18, 2025 @11:46AM (#44606070)
Americans also pay half or more their income in various taxes/premiums. Again, I’m not sure what greener grass you’re looking for.