News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Rust Shaped Hole by pjmlp on Thursday July 17, 2025 @06:46AM (#44591803)
4 editions later, Rust is yet to be used at the scale of C and C++ across the industry, my point on the comment is how editions will look like after 50 years of Rust history.

ABIs and multiple versions of the language runtime, are part of what defines a language ecosystem, hence why editions don't really cover as much as people think they do.

Re:A Rust Shaped Hole by Expurple on Thursday July 17, 2025 @07:08AM (#44591932)
Editions will look like band-aids that don't fully solve the cruft accumulated over the 50 years. That's not hard to predict. It's still a very useful mechanism that slows down the accumulation of said cruft. I'm yet to see a language that has a better stability/evolution story
Re:A Rust Shaped Hole by pjmlp on Thursday July 17, 2025 @08:05AM (#44592384)
In any case, while I as language geek have these kind of discussions, given current progress in AI systems, my point of view is that we will get the next evolution in programming systems, thus it won't matter much if it is C, C++, Rust, C#, Java, Go or whatever.

We (as in the industry) will eventually get reliable ways to generate applications directly to machine code, just as optimizing compilers took a couple of decades to beat hand written Assembly, and generate reliable optimized code.

So editions, regardless of what they offer, might not be as relevant in such a timeframe from a couple of decades ahead.

Re:A Rust Shaped Hole by Expurple on Thursday July 17, 2025 @09:10AM (#44593000)
The machine code will always be generated from "something". A one-line informal prompt isn't enough. There will always be people who write specs. Even the current languages are already far from "machine code" and could be considered "specs", albeit low-level
Re:A Rust Shaped Hole by pjmlp on Thursday July 17, 2025 @01:33PM (#44595859)
Indeed, I never said it was a bare bones prompt.