News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Oakland cops gave ICE license plate data; SFPD also illeg... by loeg on Monday July 14, 2025 @02:18PM (#44563452)
"Defund the police" was never actually tried. (This is not a defense of defunding -- I agree it would have similarly bad outcomes! But you can't just point at changes that weren't defunding the police and say it was tried.)
Re:Oakland cops gave ICE license plate data; SFPD also illeg... by JumpCrisscross on Monday July 14, 2025 @03:19PM (#44564191)
> "Defund the police" was never actually tried

Isn’t this a No True Scotsmen problem?

Police budges were trimmed. Police forces were cut. Police remit, in the form of decriminalisation, was reduced. No jurisdiction abolished law enforcement (though San Francisco de facto got close). But I’d say those count as defunding the police to an extent.

Even then, we got disaster. Shockingly quickly. Shockingly powerfully. There is no threshold theory that suggests you get magical results cutting the police force by 30% instead of 3%; it’s thus reasonable to extrapolate and assume you get more of the bad.

Re:Oakland cops gave ICE license plate data; SFPD also illeg... by ceejayoz on Monday July 14, 2025 @04:13PM (#44564721)
> No jurisdiction abolished law enforcement (though San Francisco de facto got close).

What year did that occur on their budget chart?

https://x.com/chrisarvinsf/status/1399863666938310663

Re:Oakland cops gave ICE license plate data; SFPD also illeg... by JumpCrisscross on Monday July 14, 2025 @08:39PM (#44566781)
De facto, not de jure. SFPD went AWOL for a few months. One can’t complain about that and then claim it would be better if they were fired.

(Also, your own chart shows a ‘20 dip.)

Re:Oakland cops gave ICE license plate data; SFPD also illeg... by ceejayoz on Monday July 14, 2025 @11:03PM (#44567497)
“De facto abolition of policing” or “dip”? Pick one!

Cops throwing a tantrum over a dip would seem to prove a point, too.

Re:Oakland cops gave ICE license plate data; SFPD also illeg... by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday July 15, 2025 @01:35AM (#44568127)
But cops throwing a tantrum causing a crime spike proves their worth.

You can’t advocate for abolishing cops and also complain about cops self abolishing.

Re:Oakland cops gave ICE license plate data; SFPD also illeg... by ceejayoz on Tuesday July 15, 2025 @09:44AM (#44571107)
> But cops throwing a tantrum causing a crime spike proves their worth.

If we pretend the spike didn't happen during COVID and in other countries, sure.

> You can’t advocate for abolishing cops and also complain about cops self abolishing.

Sure you can, for the same reason I can get mad at my neighbor if they demolish a shed with a nuke rather than a screwdriver.

Re:Oakland cops gave ICE license plate data; SFPD also illeg... by loeg on Monday July 14, 2025 @06:24PM (#44566008)
> Isn’t this a No True Scotsmen problem?

No, this is a "this didn't actually happen."

> Police budges were trimmed. Police forces were cut.

Where were police budgets trimmed and forces cut? They weren't; that's the crucial thing you're describing that did not happen. Otherwise, I agree -- lots of reform changes that sounded good on paper led to bad outcomes. But there's no need to inaccurately call other reforms "defunding."

Re:Oakland cops gave ICE license plate data; SFPD also illeg... by JumpCrisscross on Monday July 14, 2025 @08:37PM (#44566763)
> Where were police budgets trimmed and forces cut?

NYPD’s budget was slashed by over 5% [1]. It was restored by ‘22.

[1] https://cbcny.org/research/was-nypd-budget-cut-1-billion

Re:Oakland cops gave ICE license plate data; SFPD also illeg... by loeg on Tuesday July 15, 2025 @08:06PM (#44577278)
I stand corrected, thanks.