News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Oakland cops gave ICE license plate data; SFPD also illeg... by martythemaniak on Monday July 14, 2025 @12:53PM (#44562360)
That's right - no one should be angry at the people building and filling up concentration camps, and certainly not at their supporters and cheerleaders. It's all those dogooders collecting data that are the real culprits.
Re:Oakland cops gave ICE license plate data; SFPD also illeg... by kelseyfrog on Monday July 14, 2025 @12:58PM (#44562436)
The post you're responding to isn't arguing shifting blame. They're arguing that instrumental actions should be included. If you think expanding the scope of accountability dilutes the pool, that's another argument. But at least have good faith. They're not your enemy.
Re:Oakland cops gave ICE license plate data; SFPD also illeg... by ceejayoz on Monday July 14, 2025 @01:02PM (#44562496)
Drawing this line gets tough.

If I build a sidewalk curb, there's a perfectly legitimate use case for it. It can also be used to curb-stomp someone to death.

Can't we build the curb and forbid curb-stomping at the same time? Shouldn't that be our right?

Re:Oakland cops gave ICE license plate data; SFPD also illeg... by spauldo on Monday July 14, 2025 @03:27PM (#44564276)
If you build a curb for someone that is well-known for curb stomping people to death and has a bunch of people behind them saying how great curb stomping is, that's on you.
Re:Oakland cops gave ICE license plate data; SFPD also illeg... by ceejayoz on Monday July 14, 2025 @04:08PM (#44564676)
Maybe! But maybe that area still really does need a curb, and it's the curb-stomping people we need to worry about more than the curb?

The sharing of the database in clear contravention of the law is a symptom of the widespread police culture of immunity from civil oversight in the United States. They do it because they get away with it.

Re:Oakland cops gave ICE license plate data; SFPD also illeg... by spauldo on Monday July 14, 2025 @05:21PM (#44565491)
I in no way meant to imply the curb-stompers were in the right, only that building a curb for them when you know very well what it'll be used for makes you culpable as well.
Re:Oakland cops gave ICE license plate data; SFPD also illeg... by kelseyfrog on Monday July 14, 2025 @05:33PM (#44565608)
Especially when folks were saying, "If you build this curb, the curb-stompers are going to use it for curb stomping."
Re:Oakland cops gave ICE license plate data; SFPD also illeg... by mulmen on Monday July 14, 2025 @01:16PM (#44562687)
Flock didn’t build a sidewalk. Flock built the stomp-o-tron 9000 with convenient victim loading ramp and mechanical leg.

Flock built a surveillance data repository with convenient sharing mechanisms. Someone then used those mechanisms as designed for their intended purpose.

Re:Oakland cops gave ICE license plate data; SFPD also illeg... by ceejayoz on Monday July 14, 2025 @01:28PM (#44562846)
Sure. But California forsaw that, and passed a law to prevent that use case.

The cops - public servants, in theory - then blatantly violated that law.

Re:Oakland cops gave ICE license plate data; SFPD also illeg... by mulmen on Monday July 14, 2025 @04:52PM (#44565122)
Did they? The cops shared with other state agencies who then shared with the feds. From what I understand of the situation the cops didn’t break the law, which is the problem.
Re:Oakland cops gave ICE license plate data; SFPD also illeg... by ceejayoz on Monday July 14, 2025 @10:17PM (#44567255)
Per the article, yes:

> Twice, however, OPD staffers searched their system explicitly on behalf of the FBI.

And "other California police departments" are California cops subject to SB34, too.

> Rather, other California police departments searched Oakland’s system on behalf of federal counterparts more than 200 times — providing reasons such as “FBI investigation” for the searches — which appears to mirror a strategy first reported by 404 Media, in which federal agencies that don’t have contracts with Flock turn to local police for backdoor access.

Re:Oakland cops gave ICE license plate data; SFPD also illeg... by mulmen on Monday July 14, 2025 @11:21PM (#44567570)
Ah, you’re right! I should have read more carefully.
Re:Oakland cops gave ICE license plate data; SFPD also illeg... by martythemaniak on Monday July 14, 2025 @03:35PM (#44564365)
> If you're gonna be angry at someone be angry at the people among us were in favor of the creation of this data set

You're right, they're not shifting blame, they're straight up telling you who is to blame. And apparently, it is not the people who came up with this idea, nor the people carrying out the actions, nor the people supporting them.

Re:Oakland cops gave ICE license plate data; SFPD also illeg... by skrtskrt on Monday July 14, 2025 @01:07PM (#44562559)
These two things are one in the same. Every data broker knows exactly who their ultimate clients are. That's why Palantir never broke a sweat losing bazillions of dollars for years and years and years. Their final goal is to be essentially an indispensable arm of the police surveillance state.