News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Robot cars on public roads? California says yes by Jun8 on Thursday August 30, 2012 @02:28PM (#4456028)
This is fantastic! The adoption could be very fast, e.g. if insurance companies give benefits if you drive a self-driving car.

One current roadblock is the price of the system: the LIDAR (the thing on the top of the car in the picture) retails for ~$75K currently. There should be significant volume to drive the price down. But a lot of people would buy them for prestige, too (e.g. many early Prius adopters), so if the cost of the system can be reduced to perhaps $4K-$5K levels people will seriously think about this.

Re:Robot cars on public roads? California says yes by mturmon on Thursday August 30, 2012 @02:47PM (#4456132)
Yes, the lidars are expensive. It is believed that the Ibeo will come down to the sub-$1K range in volume production.

http://www.autonomoustuff.com/ibeo-lux-standard.html

Re:Robot cars on public roads? California says yes by sv123 on Thursday August 30, 2012 @02:42PM (#4456115)
If everybody had a self-driving car, would insurance be obsolete?
Re:Robot cars on public roads? California says yes by majormajor on Thursday August 30, 2012 @04:58PM (#4456774)
Not entirely. There's three main parts: liability, comprehensive, and collision.

Liability is the part that's legally required in the US. If the numbers showed that self-driving cars were much less likely to cause an accident, it would be considerably cheaper for them (a much more dramatic version of how anti-lock brakes can make your liability coverage cheaper).

Comprehensive (mainly stuff that happens while you're not in the vehicle) would remain unchanged. But it's also the cheapest part.

Collision is what covers repairs to your own vehicle if you're at fault or if someone at fault isn't insured themselves (you can also skip the first part and just get uninsured motorist coverage). The uninsured at-fault driver case doesn't change until there are enough self-driving cars on the road that accidents as a whole go way down, but the first case (damage to your own vehicle that was your own fault) should be much less likely and thus cheaper to insure.

Re:Robot cars on public roads? California says yes by brc on Thursday August 30, 2012 @11:15PM (#4458088)
This question keeps coming up. The answer is no.

Insurance covers much more than drivers running into other things - theft of vehicle, parts of vehicle, or damage to vehicle and theft of contents - fire + natural disasters (flood etc) - damage to the vehicle by other drivers, both moving and parked - personal liability for damage while using the car - damage to the car from accidents

Note that in multiple vehicle accidents sometimes 'blame' is shared out between insurance companies as a way of sharing costs.

As to the fiction that accidents will never happen with autonomous cars, this is simply false. Of course there will still be accidents. The accident rate should decrease but this will take a long, long time to happen.

Take this example : workers have a self-driving pickup, but don't secure a ladder on the roof properly. While driving along the freeway, the ladder comes off and smashes into self-driving car behind. Neither self-driving car can prevent this. Same goes for self-driving cars failing to detect black ice on the road and skidding into railings/trees/other traffic.

Liability for accidents with self-drive vehicles will fall on the owner of the vehicle, possibly with insurers pooling 'fault' when one or more self-driving vehicles are involved.

Re:Robot cars on public roads? California says yes by emiliobumachar on Thursday August 30, 2012 @02:49PM (#4456144)
Theft would still be an issue. Also, the bots may be less than perfect.
Re:Robot cars on public roads? California says yes by patrickk on Thursday August 30, 2012 @03:08PM (#4456224)
An Orwellian version of autonomous car theft:

"PriusBot has detected you are not authorised to use this vehicle. In accordance with law XYZ-00A, you are now being driven to the nearest police station as a precaution."

Re:Robot cars on public roads? California says yes by brc on Thursday August 30, 2012 @11:20PM (#4458101)
PriusBot would be unable to do much about being loaded on a tilt-tray, taken to a chop-shop and relieved of the various sensors, air bags, catalytic converters and body panels.
Re:Robot cars on public roads? California says yes by jrockway on Friday August 31, 2012 @12:37AM (#4458282)
Not to mention a hit from Mr. Short Circuit: http://ameblo.jp/ishinkaia/image-10951939627-11353773528.htm...
Re:Robot cars on public roads? California says yes by unwind on Friday August 31, 2012 @05:15AM (#4458908)
Only until someone arms the bot, by installing http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blaster_%28flamethrower%29.
Re:Robot cars on public roads? California says yes by sliverstorm on Thursday August 30, 2012 @03:29PM (#4456303)
It gets more Orwellian than that:

"PriusBot has detected you have been classified as a public menace. In accordance with statute XYZ-00N, you are now being driven off the nearest bridge."

Re:Robot cars on public roads? California says yes by dvdhsu on Thursday August 30, 2012 @11:25PM (#4458120)
This could actually be a serious concern. By riding in a self-driving car, we're putting our life directly in to a machine's hands. Of course, this isn't very new: pacemakers, for example, are controlled by computers. They can be reprogrammed, but only when you're physically near the target [1].

But a self-driving car would almost inevitably be connected to a network: an central computer could algorithmically control where all the cars are, where they're moving, how fast they're doing it, and basically make accidents nonexistent; such a system would be enormously beneficial to society at large. Yet, the downside is that all the cars are connected to a network, which an attacker could use to, as you say, send the target "off the nearest bridge".

1. http://www.secure-medicine.org/icd-study/icd-study.pdf

Re:Robot cars on public roads? California says yes by 001sky on Friday August 31, 2012 @12:12AM (#4458230)
Yes, some of these networks hackable.[1]

Our investigation shows that an implantable cardioverter defibrillator (1) is potentially susceptible to malicious attacks that violate the privacy of patient information and medical telemetry, and (2) may experience malicious alteration to the integrity of information or state, including patient data and therapy settings for when and how shocks are administered. Moreover, standard approaches for security and access control may not always be suitable for IMDs due to tensions between security (e.g., access for pre-authorized parties only) and safety (e.g., access for previously unauthorized parties in emergency circumstances)

Nsa will have e911 equivalent and warrantable backdoor to anything DMV/govt approved, though one would think.

[1] Some physical design limits were cpu and power, plus other operational concerns.

Re:Robot cars on public roads? California says yes by icebraining on Thursday August 30, 2012 @07:33PM (#4457422)
No, an Orwellian state wouldn't kill you before you became sane.
Re:Robot cars on public roads? California says yes by ThePherocity on Thursday August 30, 2012 @03:50PM (#4456411)
Since nothing about that is totalitarian at all, I don't think the term Orwellian is correct. Having computers recognize us and authorize or authenticate is solely at the whim of the consumer. It becomes Orwellian when the government demands that government controlled sensors be included in every car.
Re:Robot cars on public roads? California says yes by 001sky on Friday August 31, 2012 @09:33AM (#4459604)
The US has alterted a few folks in the middle east they they were [Unauthorized] to [drive their vehicle] any longer, because they were on bad terms with the NSA. Try adding [Predator Drone] and [Targeted by Hellfire Missle] into the same sentence.
Re:Robot cars on public roads? California says yes by ThePherocity on Saturday September 01, 2012 @10:21AM (#4463734)
Again, that may be an act of war, but since it's not against it's own people, it's not Orwellian.
Re:Robot cars on public roads? California says yes by 001sky on Saturday September 01, 2012 @12:50PM (#4464271)
It becomes Orwellian when the government demands that government controlled sensors be included in every car.

Apr 19, 2012 – A bill passed in the U.S. Senate would require black boxes to be installed in all new cars sold in the U.S. by 2015

Re:Robot cars on public roads? California says yes by tthomas48 on Thursday August 30, 2012 @04:34PM (#4456639)
The humans are less than less than perfect.
Re:Robot cars on public roads? California says yes by cygwin98 on Thursday August 30, 2012 @02:44PM (#4456123)
Not so fast. What if a moose or a deer hits the car?
Re:Robot cars on public roads? California says yes by shardling on Thursday August 30, 2012 @03:11PM (#4456233)
Mandatory insurance exists in case you hit someone else.
Re:Robot cars on public roads? California says yes by sv123 on Thursday August 30, 2012 @02:49PM (#4456141)
If things like that are all insurance is used for then it should be about 1/100th of the current cost I guess.
Re:Robot cars on public roads? California says yes by krschultz on Thursday August 30, 2012 @03:50PM (#4456402)
You can figure it out when you look at the cost of your insurance.

It depends on what you pick for coverage and what car you are driving, but for me roughly 50% of my bill goes to liability and 50% goes to comprehensive coverage.

In a world with self driving cars, your liability wouldn't be 0 but it would be lower. The 50% that goes to comprehensive coverage would remain. That covers theft, falling trees, flooding, fires, etc.

Re:Robot cars on public roads? California says yes by Someone on Thursday August 30, 2012 @04:05PM (#4456475)
That 50% will not go completely away. The total cost of liability insurance will only drop insofar as driving gets safer. You may not be responsible for hitting that other car, but someone will have to pay.

Because of that, you likely wil have to pay a premium on top of the 'real' costs of such a car to the seller of the electronics, either as a lump sum, or as a per year and/or kilometer contribution.

Re:Robot cars on public roads? California says yes by MPSimmons on Thursday August 30, 2012 @03:10PM (#4456232)
>it SHOULD be about 1/100th of the current cost

Yes, it should be. However do you think that insurance companies are going to allow that? They'll form the insurance-equivalent of the RIAA before that happens.

Re:Robot cars on public roads? California says yes by SoftwareMaven on Thursday August 30, 2012 @03:58PM (#4456440)
I highly doubt that. Insurance companies don't represent a "precious resource" (aka celebrities), so it would be easy for somebody to come in underneath them.

Besides, insurance companies make money on the difference between rates and claims. If claims fall significantly, rates can, too, yet the insurance companies can still take home the same sized paycheck.

Re:Robot cars on public roads? California says yes by brc on Thursday August 30, 2012 @11:19PM (#4458097)
>insurance companies make money on the difference between rates and claims.

This isn't true, but is a common misconception.

Insurance companies make money by earning an investment income on the retained premium (the premium earnt between when a policy is paid for, and a claim is paid out). You can easily see this by reading analyst reports on publicly-listed insurance companies, which will analyse in detail the return on the retained premium.

An insurance company collecting more premium than claim costs is overpricing itself. An insurance company paying out more claims than premium is underpricing itself.

The idea is that the risk is managed through actuarial study, so the premium/claim payout is managed, giving an optimal time lag between collected premium and paid out claims.

The ability of insurance companies to create a very large pool of investment funds is why Warren Buffet buys them. He is an expert at investing, and the premium pool gives him the size he needs.

Re:Robot cars on public roads? California says yes by learc83 on Thursday August 30, 2012 @06:15PM (#4457166)
I agree that it will market forces will drastically lower the price, but if the margins stay the same the insurance companies will still make less money as the overall premiums will be smaller.
Re:Robot cars on public roads? California says yes by vectorbunny on Thursday August 30, 2012 @04:12PM (#4456503)
This assumes the cost of auto insurance is based on actuarial science, as opposed to whatever the industry lobby can get through state legislatures.
Re:Robot cars on public roads? California says yes by jonlarson on Thursday August 30, 2012 @05:34PM (#4456961)
If you had a self-driving car, would a malfunction in the car causing a crash be your fault?
Re:Robot cars on public roads? California says yes by paulsutter on Thursday August 30, 2012 @10:19PM (#4457922)
With self driving cars, why would you own one? Why bother making a capital investment and paying to park a rarely used vehicle when Übercab could provide rides everywhere at much lower cost with much greater availability?
Re:Robot cars on public roads? California says yes by greg_bt on Thursday August 30, 2012 @09:25PM (#4457742)
If you had a human driven car, would a malfunction in the car causing a crash be your fault? [1] I can see that if you hadn't updated the firmware of the car then maybe it could be claimed that you had not performed adequate maintenance?

[1]: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1236020/Horror-ride-...

Re:Robot cars on public roads? California says yes by abruzzi on Thursday August 30, 2012 @11:44PM (#4458166)
Vehicle integrity is the responsibility of the driver for human driven cars, I assume it would be the same for autonomous vehicles. The problem comes when you are driving a 15 year old car because you can afford new. For non autonomous vehicles mechanical safety is dependent on powertrain, steering, and brakes, all of which are under manual control. Maintaining the integrity of autonomous system--its computer, its sensors, its radar/gps, the accuracy of its maps, will be even more important than the maintenance of those manual system.
Re:Robot cars on public roads? California says yes by bradgessler on Thursday August 30, 2012 @04:17PM (#4456522)
I could also see increased adoption if HOV lanes were set aside only for automated cars.
Re:Robot cars on public roads? California says yes by dllthomas on Thursday August 30, 2012 @05:16PM (#4456871)
I would object. If you want to use the HOV lane, have multiple people in your car. I understand the rationale for extending it to things that are sufficiently fuel efficient. I don't see it here.
Re:Robot cars on public roads? California says yes by esrauch on Thursday August 30, 2012 @07:32PM (#4457418)
HOV lanes promote multiple people to reduce congestion, and self-driving cars are touted as a way to reduce congestion. If the latter claim is true, then HOV lanes could reduce congestion by allowing self driving cars to drive in them.
Re:Robot cars on public roads? California says yes by brc on Thursday August 30, 2012 @11:24PM (#4458114)
I actually think they will do the reverse. A self-driving car will likely do more miles. What's more, it will do empty-passenger miles. The travelling patterns of people are unlikely to change. But there remains the distinct possibility that people will get their cars to drive to work, then home (or at least to remote parking) again if 'work' does not have parking.

Thus the potential for cars without people driving around. This is inherently worse for congestion than 1-person cars.

Re:Robot cars on public roads? California says yes by dllthomas on Thursday August 30, 2012 @08:27PM (#4457594)
Ah, right - I guess I'm just so skeptical of the claims that didn't think of it. I expect self-driving cars to be driving like a cautious human driver for at least 5 years. If we get to the point where they're in fact driving closer together, then there is indeed an argument for letting them in the HOV lanes.
Re:Robot cars on public roads? California says yes by shasta on Thursday August 30, 2012 @06:44PM (#4457271)
I assumed he meant HOV and autonomous. So that the HOV lane could go faster with higher density for example.
Re:Robot cars on public roads? California says yes by Daniel_Newby on Thursday August 30, 2012 @06:42PM (#4457266)
I think the LIDAR approach will have to go. Laser systems are inherently susceptible to jamming with a cheap laser diode. We cannot afford to have mass adoption of cars where somebody can create weeks of citywide gridlock with a few thousand dollars of lasers.
Re:Robot cars on public roads? California says yes by agildehaus on Thursday August 30, 2012 @07:47PM (#4457479)
Thrun said in a talk I saw posted on HN earlier today that this wasn't being considered a problem. I'm not certain if targeted LIDAR jamming was on his mind, his comment was specifically in reference to operating with many other autonomous cars on the road.

He was concerned about GPS jamming though, but thankfully these cars have been designed from the ground up to not rely on GPS (as a signal from a satellite is not reliable). I believe as long as the area has been 3D mapped by Google, the car is capable of driving and navigating without GPS assistance.

Re:Robot cars on public roads? California says yes by zitterbewegung on Thursday August 30, 2012 @07:04PM (#4457333)
The degradation mode is that you have to drive your car. Not, everyone not being able to drive.
Re:Robot cars on public roads? California says yes by JulianMorrison on Thursday August 30, 2012 @07:51PM (#4457495)
You assume that the car is occupied by a sober adult who can drive. Not something you'll be able to assume any more when mom can send the car to do the school run.
Re:Robot cars on public roads? California says yes by Daniel_Newby on Thursday August 30, 2012 @08:10PM (#4457552)
You cannot drive your car in 1 meter spaced convoys. In many cities jamming the navigators would cause the cars to not fit on the roads, resulting in gridlock for however long the jammers could be kept going.
Re:Robot cars on public roads? California says yes by Aloisius on Thursday August 30, 2012 @09:33PM (#4457779)
And dumping 500 caltrops off an overpass would likely have the exact same effect. Worrying about someone actively attacking this kind of system using theoretical jammers that could seize up multiple lanes of traffic (without easy line of sight!) and operate for hundreds of feet at this point seems premature.
Re:Robot cars on public roads? California says yes by flyinRyan on Friday August 31, 2012 @06:12AM (#4459034)
I hate what 911 has done to people's thinking. We're talking about the future here but people can't stop with their fantasy bond villain nonsense.
Re:Robot cars on public roads? California says yes by Daniel_Newby on Friday August 31, 2012 @02:22AM (#4458534)
You can't do the caltrop trick at 50 locations for weeks on end.

The thing about lasers is they use a very narrow slice of wavelengths. Environmental light like sunlight has very little power within that slice, so its easy for the LIDAR to see its own laser. But that makes it really easy to jam. You could probably build a jammer today for a few hundred dollars, which means that in the future every disaffected monkeywrencher will do it. Ergo the approach is not suitable for the mass market.

Re:Robot cars on public roads? California says yes by paulsutter on Friday August 31, 2012 @01:08AM (#4458342)
You can jam the human eye with a cheap laser diode. Does that stop you from driving?

Besides, using the right modulation would make LIDAR as hard to jam as would be needed.

Re:Robot cars on public roads? California says yes by Daniel_Newby on Friday August 31, 2012 @02:25AM (#4458543)
The eye is broadband and the desired light is bright, so it takes a very high power density to jam it. LIDAR receivers are very narrowband and the desired light is fairly dim, so jamming it will be quite easy. Modulation does not help when the light detector is saturated.
Re:Robot cars on public roads? California says yes by paulsutter on Friday August 31, 2012 @10:52AM (#4459961)
To keep the detector saturated for any period of time you would need to have aim that's a little too perfect. Besides, my central point was that there are lots of vulnerabilities in existing cars and they're still driven.

In case you decide to test your theory about lasers and human eyes, please don't use someone else as a test subject.

Re:Robot cars on public roads? California says yes by Daniel_Newby on Friday August 31, 2012 @02:45PM (#4461081)
I think it can be done without aiming, assuming the light detector uses a wide angle lens. You just have to illuminate the scene observed by the LIDAR with a few watts per square meter of laser light. That's doable today, and easy in the future.