News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Supreme Court's Ruling Practically Wipes Out Free Speech ... by landl0rd on Saturday July 12, 2025 @04:32PM (#44544935)
> conservative Christians are trying to eliminate ALL sexually-related speech online

I don’t really appreciate this framing. Despite being a very conservative Christian (at least in many ways, if not others) I don’t approve of or agree with the scope of SCOTUS’ current ruling, nor do I approve of all the age- verification laws as written. It seems futile to attempt to make everybody everywhere do this and create a locked-down “second internet” for minors.

But I do understand the impetus. As a zoomer, I’ve heard the problems particularly young men addicted to pornography have caused with some gal friends of mine they’ve dated. I’ve seen the normalization of what I view as degenerate sex acts as the treadmill of endlessly-escalating erotic-novelism spins without ceasing. I’ve watched people become more absorbed in their strange autosexual fixations than their spouses. It doesn’t seem good, or healthy, or sustainable, and I resent the contributions the proliferation of online pornography has made to these issues.

At some level I see this like sixties versus modern marijuana, where a more mild herb (or dad’s playboys beneath the mattress) has been supplanted by THC distilled and bottled into vapes (endlessly-available presence of any outlandish fetishistic stuff.) I wouldn’t like my child exposed to either but I can live with one.

Of course, I see it as primarily the parent’s responsibility to inculcate the virtue to disdain both. The state can’t nanny its way out of this one. But it’s always easier to pick a scapegoat that can’t vote (tax the corporations/rich, make the corporations implement age-filtering, etc.) than to tell people to take a hike and learn to parent.

Re:Supreme Court's Ruling Practically Wipes Out Free Speech ... by const_cast on Saturday July 12, 2025 @04:56PM (#44545094)
You might not be pushing for it, but certainly your fellow conservative Christians are.

The problem with moralistic thinking is that it's stupid and it blows up, and we've known this for hundreds of years. What you view as moral means fuck-all. I don't particularly care if you think something is degenerate, and in fact by using a term like degenerate I respect you less as a person.

So when morals are used as the sole reason to justify law, we have a problem. Morals were used to justify slavery. To justify a lack of suffrage. To justify legal domestic abuse.

What's changed since then? Time. The passage of time. But time does not stop. Where will we be in 10 years, or 20? Progressing forward, ideally, but that's not a guarantee. We're laying the ground work for abuse.

For a large part of the American constituency, anything containing homosexuals is degenerate pornography. Right now. So if "it's pornography" is our justification, we have a problem.

I think we agree that said laws are bad, but why they're bad matters. The wider-scale implication is that moralistic law making is bad. Listening to Christians and having them come up with laws based on their personal beliefs is bad. Appealing to the American purity culture is bad. This is all ripe for abuse.

Re:Supreme Court's Ruling Practically Wipes Out Free Speech ... by landl0rd on Saturday July 12, 2025 @05:07PM (#44545168)
No, some of them are. More evangelicals than my crowd.

Morality bears directly on what we consider to be a just society, so I don’t care if you don’t care. You’re broadening the scope beyond this particular issue, where I’m guessing I agree with you.

It’s not virtuous to act right because the state makes you, but the question of what we require and preclude is defined by our moral frameworks at some level.

I’m not sure with whom you’re arguing about the homosexuals point. I view a lot of things of degenerate I wouldn’t ban. Most adults I see are fat, thus gluttons, thus are committing a sin. It’s just not particularly my business to meddle in what’s between them and God and Satan. I didn’t suggest we “retvrn to Comstock” or something.

I don’t see how you can ignore the massively negative effects pornography has on mostly young men, particularly if you think about the marijuana analogy and how it’s increased in strength and availability. Novel hyperstimuli are a big issue. Just like supernormal stimuli tend to increase obesity and cause metabolic dysfunction.

A ton of lawmaking is moralistic. Eg the way I grew up I think it’s fine for two guys to settle something with a fight provided it’s clean and nobody’s kicking someone when he’s down. A bunch of people with different morals (“all violence is wrong”) told the cops to start arresting people for that sort of thing. I think stealing is wrong and vote to tell the cops to arrest people for that, while others (because of their morality) say that “it’s systemic factors” and turn people loose for sub-$1k or so, or sometimes don’t believe in property rights the same way I do. I don’t believe that income tax is just, nor federally-administered welfare, but a ton of people voted to tell the feds to take money and do just that.

I’m not sure how you can suddenly flip to “moralistic legislation is wrong actually” in such a selective sense just because it’s movitated by Christianity or right-wing ideology for once.

Re:Supreme Court's Ruling Practically Wipes Out Free Speech ... by const_cast on Saturday July 12, 2025 @05:56PM (#44545527)
> I don’t see how you can ignore the massively negative effects pornography has on mostly young men

I ignore it because I've only ever gotten responses of morality. Which, as I've said, I think are stupid.

My point about morality is that it's the same morality that oppresses homosexuals, or previously black people and women. It's not a different morality - it's the same reasoning.

Some thing is immoral because of our beliefs, so we censor it or restrict actions. Throughout history, this has only gone poorly - no exceptions. I have no reason to believe it will work out this time.

You might say, "well it hasn't always gone poorly, what about murder?" Yes, murder has morality argument, but it doesn't only have morality arguments. It has real-world effects. It denies someone of their unalienable rights, mainly by ending their lives.

Pornography only has moral arguments, which is why I reject them.

Re:Supreme Court's Ruling Practically Wipes Out Free Speech ... by landl0rd on Sunday July 13, 2025 @10:25PM (#44555871)
This is actually a pretty sound framework and I mostly agree. Usually it's justifiable to intervene when somebody is harming someone else and not before. I think it's a bit oversimplified, though. Do you think it might contribute to the incel epidemic and the associated violence? In that sense one could make a similar line of argument to that of the temperance movement's talk of alcohol contributing to wife-beating (which it did). I don't believe that indirection leaves a clear enough link to justify state violence to ban something, but there do exist less explicitly moralistic arguments for it. Not really my position but it's not constructive to reduce every criticism to "moralizing".
Re:Supreme Court's Ruling Practically Wipes Out Free Speech ... by const_cast on Wednesday July 16, 2025 @01:51AM (#44579119)
> Do you think it might contribute to the incel epidemic and the associated violence?

No actually I don't, not at all. I blame the patriachy and feminism for the creation of incels. Not in the sense that feminism is bad, but the contrary.

What I mean is, incels have always existed. However, our tolerance for widespread misbehavior of men has grown thinner over the last 70 years.

When I was in college, it was typical to hear "oh man, don't go to that frat house, they roofie!" Looking back, it's almost comical. What? They... roofie? Is... anybody going to do anything about this? Should I tell someone? No, evidently - just don't go there.

Of course, it used to be worse. Men used to be able to just beat women, and nobody cared. Financial abuse was not only common, it was mandated by law.

We've come a long, long way. And, we've left a lot of men behind. Before, you could be a piece of shit and still be almost guaranteed a marriage, or at least sex. Our standards for behavior are much higher.

Men have been, understandably, slow to evolve. It's a much less sweet deal. This is compounded by the fact we've really never had a progressive movement for men. To this day, there are infinite ways to be a heterosexual woman - but there's only one way to be a heterosexual man. Men are closed in, trapped, by social expectations. We carry all the baggage of the patriarchy and misogyny of days gone, but we reap few benefits. We are not so liberated, not so open-minded.

It's a fine line. You must evolve, but not too much so that you may reject the performance of masculinity. You must be progressive, but not so much so. You must be traditional, but only in the right ways. Some men, even a lot of men, cannot keep up or fit into what is expected of them. And, there's no moving back.

Re:Supreme Court's Ruling Practically Wipes Out Free Speech ... by ryandv on Wednesday July 16, 2025 @09:24AM (#44582070)
> Men have been, understandably, slow to evolve.

It's true, and for all the reasons you list, men are in fact genetically inferior.

At this point all male babies should be aborted or otherwise discarded at birth. Babies born with two X chromosomes can simply transition into the gender identity role of "man" during puberty, if they so choose.

Re:Supreme Court's Ruling Practically Wipes Out Free Speech ... by const_cast on Thursday July 17, 2025 @01:41AM (#44590047)
Bio-essentialism is an inherently patriarchal belief. I'm sure you're being sarcastic, but no - obviously men are not born evil. They're socialized in such a way that sets them up for failure, and they have to actively work to overcome this. Those that don't, fail.

For the record, I'm a man. If you want to argue against the things I say then actually address the things I say, instead of some obviously hyperbolic strawman.

Re:Supreme Court's Ruling Practically Wipes Out Free Speech ... by ryandv on Friday July 18, 2025 @10:42AM (#44605179)
> They're socialized in such a way that sets them up for failure, and they have to actively work to overcome this. Those that don't, fail.

I can unquestionably see what you are talking about with respect to white culture, but it's literally racist for you to presume that all other cultures (e.g. Asian cultures) socialize all of their men to be evil.

Re:Supreme Court's Ruling Practically Wipes Out Free Speech ... by Fraterkes on Saturday July 12, 2025 @06:02PM (#44545570)
Come one man, it would be trivial for me to credibly argue that your religion has given scores of young men an absolutely dysfunctional relation to sexuality, woman, their own body, etc. Anyone could make that case as easily as your case about pornography (arguably with more proof in my case). Should we legislate both the same way?
Re:Supreme Court's Ruling Practically Wipes Out Free Speech ... by Asooka on Saturday July 12, 2025 @07:03PM (#44545948)
Yes, but "his religion" is over 2000 years old and has found ways to reform itself many times to re-centre itself towards the core teachings of Jesus Christ, namely compassion and piety. The Christians who sold indulgencies are not the Christians who burned witches are not the Christians who help those in need. It has existed for twenty centuries across continents and anyone who can corrupt it effectively wields the power of God. Of course it has been used as justification for heinous acts. Pretty much anything that has existed that long and is that powerful has been used that way.

It is irrational to hate the entire religion because of select elements, past or present. You are in effect committing the same act of hatred you are accusing Christians of.

Re:Supreme Court's Ruling Practically Wipes Out Free Speech ... by Fraterkes on Sunday July 13, 2025 @07:48AM (#44549625)
I was pointing out that similar arguments could be made about the “badness” of both religion and porn to show that these arguments are facetious in both cases
Re:Supreme Court's Ruling Practically Wipes Out Free Speech ... by kjkjadksj on Sunday July 13, 2025 @01:01PM (#44551790)
Haven’t all the reforms of christianity specifically brought the church away from the core teachings of Jesus Christ? Isn’t that why there are coptic and orthodox christians at all? Because they feel the catholic church out of Rome did not follow the core teachings of Jesus Christ?
Re:Supreme Court's Ruling Practically Wipes Out Free Speech ... by int_19h on Monday July 14, 2025 @03:58PM (#44564567)
Pauline Christianity, which represents the vast majority of Christian denominations worldwide including the more liberal ones, has little to do with "core teachings of Jesus". Starting with the claim that Jesus is God, given that the guy literally never once claimed to be one.
Re:Supreme Court's Ruling Practically Wipes Out Free Speech ... by landl0rd on Sunday July 13, 2025 @09:25PM (#44555516)
I agree that some "purity gospel" teachings have made people uncomfortable with their own bodies. For example, I don't find myself bent out of shape by girls wearing shorter shorts and don't agree with the degree of taboo applied to nudity in America. I also think this only contributes to over-sexualization rather than reducing it.

I just don't see that as "my religion". That's not what I believe. In a certain sense an Eastern Orthodox Christian and a Missouri Synod Lutheran both have the "same religion", but for practical purposes they do not.

Re:Supreme Court's Ruling Practically Wipes Out Free Speech ... by boroboro4 on Saturday July 12, 2025 @05:39PM (#44545414)
> massively negative effects pornography has on mostly young men

Can you provide any source for this?

Re:Supreme Court's Ruling Practically Wipes Out Free Speech ... by landl0rd on Saturday July 12, 2025 @07:31PM (#44546136)
I don’t need a source to back up what I’ve consistently observed with my own eyes, and given the speed at which research sometimes move (and particularly since any concern over perceived “sexual liberation” attacks one of the sacred cows of progressivism) being a young guy who can see this firsthand gives me a pretty good perspective.

I’ve read research on this in the past that suggests it can happen. Hard to get people to fess up to that kind of thing for obvious reasons so measuring scope as a research endeavor is a little harder.

I know the research is there and has been if you’re actually interested, but I’m traveling without a laptop for the next bit and so don’t have it saved. If you’d just like to take a cheap shot because my reply (which talked about what I have observed) wasn’t eighteen peer-reviewed studies, go ahead, I guess.

Re:Supreme Court's Ruling Practically Wipes Out Free Speech ... by McAlpine5892 on Sunday July 13, 2025 @12:02AM (#44547383)
> I don’t need a source…

Yikes dude.

> …to back up what I’ve consistently observed with my own eyes

People have observed everything UFOs and demons to ivermectin curing their COVID. None of it is real but yet people continue to swear up and down on these things gs.

> ...given the speed at which research sometimes move

Filling in knowledge gaps with imagination is not a substitute for actual data. Ever.

> and particularly since any concern over perceived “sexual liberation” attacks one of the sacred cows of progressivism

Hard disagree. You yourself can go study human psychology and sexuality then perform studies. If you can assemble real data the scientific community would be forever grateful for your contributions. The real barrier is not “liberals”, it’s that it takes years upon years of hard work to get there. Unlike your comment, which is backed up by “my own eyes”.

> I know the research is there and has been if you’re actually interested

Leading with “I don’t need citations”, then promising that they’re “totally there” at the bottom doesn’t really sit right with me.

Anyways, it’s not the role of the state to legislate morality. That always ends poorly. If porn is bad for kids, then parents need to step up. Maybe the state could offer resources for parents - I’m not opposed to that. If it’s bad for adults, they those with chronic habits should seek help.

Re:Supreme Court's Ruling Practically Wipes Out Free Speech ... by landl0rd on Sunday July 13, 2025 @09:43PM (#44555650)
Do you really think it's fair to compare a questionable UFO sighting to what I've learned from talking with and knowing people, seeing how this affects them? I don't think it is. Or talking with their girlfriends and hearing about this issue.

If you want good evidence that this is hard to study well, even if you maintain that political concerns are a non-issue, around 11% of men report some agreement with the statement, "I am addicted to pornography." https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7044607 Of course, another analysis found that just 51.7% of men used pornography, which seems optimistically low: https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11234758/ See the concerns I mentioned around getting truthful data, which are also well-known within nutrition. 17.4% of those men were "problematic" pornography users.

I'm back on a laptop now so can pull this up a little easier, but I don't think you're defending this from the right angle. It's the same as when the marijuana legalization advocates say "it's basically medicine lol" or deny that addiction is possible and that it's known to somewhat increase risk of schizophrenia, because they are scared that admitting that something is bad means they are somehow supporting a ban on it. There are a lot of bad things people consume and I support banning very few of those. Pornography is not one. Please don't mistake my position.

I'll also point out that my original comment explicitly stated that I didn't see it as the role of the state but of parents. I'm not sure with whom you're arguing here about that.

Re:Supreme Court's Ruling Practically Wipes Out Free Speech ... by McAlpine5892 on Monday July 14, 2025 @04:19AM (#44557618)
> Do you really think it's fair to compare a questionable UFO sighting

Fair enough. I chose my example poorly. My point still stands: personal anecdotes are a terrible way of understanding most anything.

> It's the same as when the marijuana legalization advocates say "it's basically medicine lol" or deny that addiction is possible

100% feel you here. Even as a user.

> There are a lot of bad things people consume and I support banning very few of those. Pornography is not one. Please don't mistake my position.

I appreciate your clarity here and I apologize for being a bit of jerk. So often it feels like people choose views purely on their own internal personal morality. Not a larger live-and-let-live attitude. Which kinda ties into the cannabis legalization thing above imo. The truth was fudged to make the moral argument easier - because that convinces people.

So, again, apologies for jumping down your throat and I appreciate the links.

Re:Supreme Court's Ruling Practically Wipes Out Free Speech ... by DonHopkins on Sunday July 13, 2025 @04:19AM (#44548518)
Slavery is much worse for kids than porn. But you're cool with your own religion and the bible condoning slavery because you're never seen a slave?

An extensive collection of Bible verses which prove that Christianity endorses slavery:

https://www.reddit.com/r/atheism/comments/pg2pyp/an_extensiv...

>I recently read "Slavery: Scriptural and Statistical" by Thornton Stringfellow.

https://docsouth.unc.edu/church/string/string.html

>In it, he makes a very compelling argument that the Bible not only endorses, but instructs slavery. Each time I came upon a reference, I read the context of the several chapters surrounding it. Below you will find a list of these Biblical references organized chronologically. Alongside each there is a short description of what the reference says. [...]

https://www.antislavery.org/slavery-today/modern-slavery/

What is modern slavery?

You might think that slavery is a thing of the past. But right now, almost 50 million people are trapped in slavery worldwide.

It’s a problem that affects every country on earth – including yours.

“We were only there to work. It felt like I was in jail.” – Laboni, Nepal

In many ways, slavery may look different from the slavery of the Transatlantic slave trade, but modern slavery – as a term – encompasses many forms of slavery, including human trafficking and people being born into slavery.

There are hundreds of definitions of modern slavery. All of these include aspects of control, involuntary actions and exploitation.

At Anti-Slavery International, we define modern slavery as when an individual is exploited by others, for personal or commercial gain. Whether tricked, coerced, or forced, they lose their freedom. This includes but is not limited to human trafficking, forced labour and debt bondage.

Our mission is to stop slavery – to secure freedom for everyone, everywhere, always.

Unlock freedom: Stand up for human rights and fight modern slavery in 2025.

Join the movement today: Modern slavery is all around us, often hidden in plain sight. People can become enslaved making our clothes, serving our food, picking our crops, working in factories, or working in houses as cooks, cleaners or nannies. Victims of modern slavery might face violence or threats, be forced into inescapable debt, or have their passport taken away and face being threatened with deportation.

Many people have fallen into this trap because they were trying to escape poverty or insecurity, improve their lives and support their families. Now, they can’t leave.

According to the latest Global Estimates of Modern Slavery (2022) from Walk Free, the International Labour Organization and the International Organization for Migration:

49.6 million people live in modern slavery – in forced labour and forced marriage.

Roughly a quarter of all victims of modern slavery are children.

22 million people are in forced marriages. Two out of five of these people were children.

Of the 27.6 million people trapped in forced labour, 17.3 million are in forced labour exploitation in the private economy, 6.3 million are in commercial sexual exploitation, and nearly 4 million are in forced labour imposed by state authorities.

The Covid-19 pandemic has exacerbated the conditions that lead to modern slavery.

Migrant workers are particularly vulnerable to forced labour.

Source: Global Estimates of Modern Slavery: Forced Labour and Forced Marriage, Geneva, September 2022

Re:Supreme Court's Ruling Practically Wipes Out Free Speech ... by landl0rd on Sunday July 13, 2025 @09:38PM (#44555607)
Don, we've discussed this on an old account of mine so at this point I'm pretty convinced you are set in your beliefs and more interested in publicly lambasting mine. But, for the sake of this thread, fine.

In the source you linked most of the references in scripture were from the Old Testament. I am a Christian, which means I am part of a new covenant with God. Just like I can wear mixed fabrics, I believe that owning slavery is a flagrant violation of the Second Great Commandment: "Love your neighbor as yourself."

All but one of the New Testament sources were from sources besides Christ. Fallible men, whose words hold some value but are certainly imperfect. I realize this belief separates me from a majority of Christians, but it's far from the only objection I have to particularly Paul's Letters.

As for the quotation from Luke, I read this in the same way I read, "Render therefore unto Caesar the things which are Caesar's," as a rebuke of petty earthly concerns. In that verse, he certainly wasn't endorsing taxation, as he later spoke of tax collectors in Matthew 9:12 as among "they that are sick".

I'm not sure why you infodumped a landing page at me or why you think I'm a fan of slavery, but you left multiple (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44548475, https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44548632) so I'm going to consolidate responses. The Ten Commandments were obviated by the New Covenant, so I don't understand why you think God would need to add a new commandment. The Roman Catholic Pope is also not "my pope"; I don't believe in that concept at all and am not a Roman Catholic.

To your question, "are you for not either changing it or renouncing that religion?" I have thought about renouncing Christianity in the past, yes. I had a very long questioning phase, and continue to question. Much of that questioning has led to fruitful conversations with friends from a number of different religious backgrounds and shaped by beliefs. It has also led me to break with the structure of most denominations.

Lastly, why I'm not "doing something?" I already allocate my time, talent, and treasure to a local charity I co-founded some years back. I deeply believe in its mission and know all those resources go to good use, unlike with many large, international NGOs. It helps people from my town, if mostly from the other side of it. I believe in rightly-ordered love, and in working to take care of a problem I can see and understand and work to remedy, thanks to the advantage I have being present in this town, before looking elsewhere.

Re:Supreme Court's Ruling Practically Wipes Out Free Speech ... by nunez on Sunday July 13, 2025 @03:53AM (#44548382)
> Most adults I see are fat, thus gluttons, thus are committing a sin.

This is not how fatness works.

Some people are genetically predisposed to gaining weight easily. Some people are literally just hungrier and have a higher satiety threshold. This is why "just eat less" is horribly ineffective.

Diet and exercise help but are more Band-Aids than a true long-term fix. Many people gain MORE weight after a period of intense dieting and exercise than before. There's a saying that summarizes this conundrum well: "Nobody knows more about diets than fat people."

I am sure that you mean well, but please understand that this is a very complex topic.

Re:Supreme Court's Ruling Practically Wipes Out Free Speech ... by ahtihn on Sunday July 13, 2025 @05:06PM (#44553733)
> Many people gain MORE weight after a period of intense dieting and exercise than before

That's because a period of intense dieting is unsustainable non-sense.

Diets as a temporary thing can only give temporary results. Permanent results require permanent changes.

Re:Supreme Court's Ruling Practically Wipes Out Free Speech ... by landl0rd on Sunday July 13, 2025 @09:47PM (#44555673)
This is, as a matter of fact. Both sides of my family are essentially universally obese. I grew up with it. I saw lots of it. I am probably genetically predisposed, but I'm not giving my DNA to one of those sketchy testing companies, so I can't say for sure.

It's not an issue of metabolism. I've walked in on people sneaking a junk food binge at 1:30AM too many times to believe this. I've seen all the sneak-eating, all the extra oily sauce when they think "well it's a salad", to believe that.

Diet and exercise are actually great long-term fixes, they're just not easy. We can see this pretty well by how reducing appetite via a GLP-1 agonist helps to decrease body fat, even with older-generation drugs that act almost entirely by just reducing appetite and increasing satiety rather than by additional mechanisms. There are also benefits like increased muscle mass increasing one's BMR so the same-size meal might no longer cause one to gain fat.

I understand that it's complex. It doesn't mean I want to blame or castigate people. I can empathize strongly with struggling against impulses to sin.

Both sides of my family also have extensive history of alcoholism. This has caused me to be very, very careful around alcohol, because despite a predisposition, drunkenness is still a sin. Somebody may have anger issues, but clocking somebody is still a sin. Many of us will have all these impulses or commit these sins. Most of the time, my reaction is to sit and empathize, particularly for "victimless crimes" (rather, sins where the only victim is one's own soul.)

Re:Supreme Court's Ruling Practically Wipes Out Free Speech ... by DonHopkins on Sunday July 13, 2025 @04:11AM (#44548475)
I don't see how you can ignore the massively negative effects slavery has on 50 million people. Your bible condones it. None of your ten commandments prohibit it. Why do you worship and defend a bible that condones slavery, which has destroyed a hell of a lot more lives than pornography has? Your God could add a new commandment prohibiting slavery tomorrow, and should have thousands of years ago, and that would have prevented so much human suffering, including the Civil War.

There are more slaves today than there ever were in history, so why are you wasting your time complaining about pornography when you should be doing something about the slavery that your bible condones, and that you God refuses to prohibit. Maybe it's time to ditch all the false pro-slavery Gods and bibles and religions, or are you too obsessed with fighting pornography to fight slavery?

Just what's wrong with your priorities? Is it just not particularly your business to meddle in what’s between slaves and their masters? You pro-slavery bible and religion apologists are a hell of a lot more degenerate than homosexuals.

https://www.antislavery.org/slavery-today/modern-slavery/

Re:Supreme Court's Ruling Practically Wipes Out Free Speech ... by rstat1 on Saturday July 12, 2025 @04:43PM (#44545009)
What people do in their private time is none of anyone's business. Period.

Especially the government.

Re:Supreme Court's Ruling Practically Wipes Out Free Speech ... by landl0rd on Saturday July 12, 2025 @04:59PM (#44545112)
Did something I wrote read like I disagreed with this? What children do in their private time is their parents’ business. What children do can sometimes be the business of the state; there’s tons of precedent for it acting in loco parentis. I just don’t find this to be the best solution.
Re:Supreme Court's Ruling Practically Wipes Out Free Speech ... by ujkhsjkdhf234 on Saturday July 12, 2025 @05:55PM (#44545525)
I come from a small town and know many conservative Christians. They are pushing for this. Like you said, it is easier to blame external sources than to accept you need to do better as parent.
Re:Supreme Court's Ruling Practically Wipes Out Free Speech ... by landl0rd on Saturday July 12, 2025 @07:34PM (#44546152)
Many of them are. I just don’t see any reason to say “I disagree with the conservative Christians pushing this” rather than “I disagree with the people who support this.” There are secular folks who also support such legislation. It hints at a generalized animus towards religion and likely in particular towards Christianity, kind of like Fox News boomers complaining Obama wouldn’t say “radical Islamic terrorism”.
Re:Supreme Court's Ruling Practically Wipes Out Free Speech ... by ujkhsjkdhf234 on Saturday July 12, 2025 @08:20PM (#44546387)
I understand what you're saying but when you have Trump and his cohorts fake praying in the oval office with the support of conservative Christians who abandon all of Jesus' teachings of love and compassion and embrace Trump's hate, you might understand why people take a specific issue with that.
Re:Supreme Court's Ruling Practically Wipes Out Free Speech ... by landl0rd on Sunday July 13, 2025 @09:51PM (#44555699)
I'm fine with criticizing that, and actually agree with that criticism. "Take heed that ye do not your alms before men, to be seen of them: otherwise ye have no reward of your Father which is in heaven."
Re:Supreme Court's Ruling Practically Wipes Out Free Speech ... by DangitBobby on Sunday July 13, 2025 @12:01AM (#44547375)
People need to understand that there is a radical Christian element trying to impose its beliefs on everyone. They should be called out continuously and especially when they successfully modify any laws, state or federal.
Re:Supreme Court's Ruling Practically Wipes Out Free Speech ... by landl0rd on Sunday July 13, 2025 @09:50PM (#44555687)
There is a radical proportion of American Christians which believes this, yes. I'm fine with calling out those beliefs. That's not my issue here, more tarring Christianity broadly, or even specifically those of us who hold conservative social beliefs but don't believe in imposing those via state coercion.

I don't see any moral benefit to forcing people not to sin. There's no virtue when there's no choice.

Re:Supreme Court's Ruling Practically Wipes Out Free Speech ... by EasyMark on Sunday July 13, 2025 @03:38AM (#44548307)
The majority of people pushing this in the USA are evangelicals who are moving more and more to christofascism over the years. Now they are mixing in government more and more and dropping the traditional values of Christianity and replacing them with fascism and prosperity gospel
Re:Supreme Court's Ruling Practically Wipes Out Free Speech ... by DonHopkins on Sunday July 13, 2025 @04:42AM (#44548632)
You are not only in denial about Project 2025, but also evolution, and the origin and age of the Earth and other planets and stars, and even the idea that slavery is wrong, if you actually believe what your bible says, which you're supposed to.

You, as a believer, should be policing and reforming your own religion instead of defending and evangelizing it and leaving it to us to clean up the damage to society done by your religion.

How about petitioning the Pope to amend the 10 Commandments to include a prohibition against slavery? Did you ever think of that, or wonder why there wasn't already one? Because your bible says slavery is A-OK, and I don't appreciate this framing of slavery as permissible by your bible.

How about you do something about that, since you're the one who believes it? Or are you cool with slavery since the bible condones it in so many ways, and you appreciate that framing?

Oh but apparently it's much more important to prevent people from worshiping other gods, so that certainly deserved its own Commandment, to justify all those wars and inquisitions you fought against other religions.

There are many more slaves today than ever before in history. What are you doing about adding another commandment against Slavery to your Holier Than Thou Bible, when you're not so busy defending Christianity and attacking homosexuality online?

What is modern slavery?

https://www.antislavery.org/slavery-today/modern-slavery/

>You might think that slavery is a thing of the past. But right now, almost 50 million people are trapped in slavery worldwide.

>It’s a problem that affects every country on earth – including yours.

Has it ever occurred to you that a religion whose bible supports slavery is morally bankrupt and definitely not the word of God, and so are you for not either changing it or renouncing that religion? It's all made up and rewritten by people anyway, and even if you believe in God, it's not like he couldn't add an anti-slavery commandment to the bible tomorrow if he wanted to.

https://www.reddit.com/r/atheism/comments/pg2pyp/an_extensiv...

Patriarchal Age : the period of time stretching from Noah, until the law was given to Abraham's posterity at Mount Sinai

Genesis 9:18-27 -- Noah (the only righteous man on earth) decrees that his son Ham and his descendants shall be slaves. (This is punishment for Ham's crime of seeing his father naked)

Genesis 12:5 -- Abram (God's anointed prophet) purchased slaves in Harran.

Genesis 16:1-9 -- Sarai's slave fled after being mistreated. God's angel instructs her to return and submit to her mistress anyway.

Genesis 17:12-13 -- All males must be circumcised, including those who were bought.

Genesis 20:14 -- Abraham (God's anointed prophet) happily accepts slaves as a gift.

Genesis 47:13-26 -- Joseph purchases the entire population of Egypt for the Pharaoh, making them his servants for life.

Exodus 12:43-45 -- God instructs Moses and Aaron that their slaves may only eat food at the passsover meal after they have been circumcised.

Legal Dispensation : the period of time from the giving of the law until the coming of Christ

Exodus 20:17 -- God provides a list of belongings which are not to be coveted, including servants (implying that they are property).

Exodus 21:2-6 -- Israeli slaves must be set free after 7 years unless you trick them into wanting to stay by giving them a wife.

Exodus 21:7-11 -- How your daughter must be treated after you sell her into slavery.

Exodus 21:20-21 -- You may beat your slaves as long as they do not die within a couple days of the beating.

Exodus 21:26-27 -- You have to let your slave go free if you destroy their eye or knock out one of their teeth.

Exodus 22:2-3 -- A theif must pay restituion. If unable, he himself is to be sold.

Leviticus 19:20-21 -- God tells Moses and Aaron what to do with a man who sleeps with another man's female slave.

Leviticus 22:10-11 -- A priest's hired servant may not eat the sacred offering, but his slaves can.

Leviticus 25:44-46 -- You may buy slaves from the nations around you and bequeath them to your children as inherited property (except if they're Israelites).

Numbers 31 -- After the Israelites conquer the Midianites, Moses orders the execution of everyone except the virgin girls (including the male children). God then instructs Moses on how the 32,000 virgins are to be divvied up and given to the Israelites as their property.

Deuteronomy 15:12-18 -- Free your Hebrew slaves every 6 years. Do not consider this a hardship because their service was worth twice as much as a hired hand.

Deuteronomy 20:10-11 -- When attacking a city, offer them the option of being your slaves rather than being slaughtered.

Joshua 9 -- Joshua "saves" the Gibeonites from being slain by the Israelites. Instead, he makes them slaves to the Israelites in perpetuity.

Gospel Dispensation : the period of time from the coming of Christ to the end of time

Luke 17:7-10 -- Jesus says servants (i.e. slaves) should know their place and not expect thanks for the duties they are required to perform.

Ephesians 6:5-8 -- Slaves are to obey their masters as they would obey Christ.

Colossians 3:22 -- Paul tells the slaves of Colosse to "obey your earthly masters."

Colossians 4:1 -- Paul says masters should be fair to their slaves. (Tacitly endorsing the existence of slaves and masters)

1 Timothy 6:1-2 -- Slaves should consider their masters worthy of full respect.

Titus 2:9-10 -- In his letter, Paul instructs Titus to teach slaves to be obedient.

1 Peter 2:18 -- Slaves, submit to your masters; even the harsh ones.

Re:Supreme Court's Ruling Practically Wipes Out Free Speech ... by antonvs on Saturday July 12, 2025 @06:42PM (#44545818)
> I don’t really appreciate this framing.

The framing is objectively accurate. Perhaps you should reconsider the group you identify with.

Re:Supreme Court's Ruling Practically Wipes Out Free Speech ... by landl0rd on Sunday July 13, 2025 @09:48PM (#44555677)
You're the one identifying me with them. That's my point. The group you dislike is "people who support this policy" or "Christians who want to enshrine their social policy via legislation." That's not what you said though.
Re:Supreme Court's Ruling Practically Wipes Out Free Speech ... by gamblor956 on Saturday July 12, 2025 @06:45PM (#44545840)
normalization of what I view as degenerate sex acts

Those "degenerate sex acts" were normal enough when the Bible was written that they were included in the Bible.

Most of our ancestors would regard modern Americans as hideously prudish.

Re:Supreme Court's Ruling Practically Wipes Out Free Speech ... by landl0rd on Saturday July 12, 2025 @07:38PM (#44546173)
Something being normal doesn’t make it right. Obesity is normal. Shoplifting has become normal in many places. People getting drunk is normal. Normalcy doesn’t equal moral rectitude.

Why do the opinions of my ancestors bear on that, and which ones are you talking about? Most of the ones I can think of, unless you run back to the days of tribal europe, would see the culture today as hideously liberalized. Regardless a lot of my ancestors probably did a lot of things I don’t think are right. Heck, I’ve done plenty of things I don’t think are right. None of that effects what actually is and isn’t morally good.

If I’m not running around telling off couples who leave the bar together, what do you care?

Re:Supreme Court's Ruling Practically Wipes Out Free Speech ... by peterlk on Sunday July 13, 2025 @12:54AM (#44547635)
Hijacking this comment because it seems to be the most recent. I’d love to start a private email thread with you if you’re willing to do so.

After the previous election, I felt wildly out of touch, and I’ve been trying to find people who I can talk to who might be able to help me improve understanding of my (metaphorical) neighbors. I suspect that our beliefs will be quite different, but I appreciate your willingness to provide long-form, respectful responses to so many comments here.

If you’re up for it, my email is in my profile

Re:Supreme Court's Ruling Practically Wipes Out Free Speech ... by DonHopkins on Sunday July 13, 2025 @04:26AM (#44548545)
You being a normal Christian homophobic bigot doesn't make it right.
Re:Supreme Court's Ruling Practically Wipes Out Free Speech ... by landl0rd on Sunday July 13, 2025 @09:54PM (#44555716)
What makes me a "homophobic bigot"? If I believe sleeping with a woman before y'all marry is wrong, am I a premarital-sex-phobic bigot? Maybe standing with signs and saying mean things to people who do so, or lobbying to ban doing so, would qualify, but I'm not doing those things with either belief.
Re:Supreme Court's Ruling Practically Wipes Out Free Speech ... by EasyMark on Sunday July 13, 2025 @03:49AM (#44548355)
Most of the BS from modern christians is a byproduct of the church trying to control every aspect of a person's mind and body rather than being an expansion of their spiritualism. Traditional religion does not like free thinking amongst its worshippers. Puritans were amongst the worst and they have a huge influence on early Americans and their religions.
Re:Supreme Court's Ruling Practically Wipes Out Free Speech ... by landl0rd on Sunday July 13, 2025 @09:57PM (#44555730)
I agree with this to an extent actually, which has led me to conflict strongly with the structure of most denominations. There are a few exceptions (the Roman Catholic Jesuits are a good example) but I'd actually say the Roman Catholic Church contributed far more to the Church-as-a-power model than Puritans overall. That aside, some days, I get as much from reading Eckhart or Kierkegaard as a Newman or Aquinas.
Re:Supreme Court's Ruling Practically Wipes Out Free Speech ... by DonHopkins on Saturday July 12, 2025 @07:32PM (#44546143)
Not only are you in denial about Project 2025, but also evolution, and the origin and age of the Earth and other planets and stars, and even the idea that slavery is wrong, if you actually believe what your bible says, which you're supposed to.

You, as a believer, should be policing and reforming your own religion instead of defending and evangelizing it and leaving it to us to clean up the damage to society done by your religion.

How about petitioning the Pope to amend the 10 Commandments to include a prohibition against slavery? Did you ever think of that, or wonder why there wasn't already one? Because your bible says slavery is A-OK, and I don't appreciate this framing of slavery as permissible by your bible.

How about you do something about that, since you're the one who believes it? Or are you cool with slavery since the bible condones it in so many ways, and you appreciate that framing?

Oh but apparently it's much more important to prevent people from worshiping other gods, so that certainly deserved its own Commandment, to justify all those wars and inquisitions you fought against other religions.

There are many more slaves today than ever before in history. What are you doing about adding another commandment against Slavery to your Holier Than Thou Bible, when you're not so busy defending Christianity online?

Has it ever occurred to you that a religion whose bible supports slavery is morally bankrupt and definitely not the word of God, and so are you for not either changing it or renouncing that religion? It's all made up and rewritten by people anyway, and even if you believe in God, it's not like he couldn't add an anti-slavery commandment to the bible tomorrow if he wanted to.

Re:Supreme Court's Ruling Practically Wipes Out Free Speech ... by stego-tech on Saturday July 12, 2025 @05:55PM (#44545520)
Alright, you seem receptive to arguments so I'll take a crack at this.

> I don’t approve of or agree with the scope of SCOTUS’ current ruling, nor do I approve of all the age- verification laws as written. It seems futile to attempt to make everybody everywhere do this and create a locked-down “second internet” for minors.

That's not the intent. The intent from the get-go has been to "Baptise" the internet as "God's creation", and to shove out anyone not worthy of God's salvation - as determined by religious leaders. When the initial argument of "the internet is a creation of Satan" didn't work out, the religious leaders in the USA pivoted towards calling it a gift from God and demonizing anyone who "sullied" that gift in their eyes.

> I’ve heard the problems particularly young men addicted to pornography have caused with some gal friends of mine they’ve dated. I’ve seen the normalization of what I view as degenerate sex acts as the treadmill of endlessly-escalating erotic-novelism spins without ceasing. I’ve watched people become more absorbed in their strange autosexual fixations than their spouses. It doesn’t seem good, or healthy, or sustainable, and I resent the contributions the proliferation of online pornography has made to these issues.

Your observations are completely valid. As someone who creates smut (let's just call it what it is), there's a very real problem with people in general getting caught up in fantasies and ignoring reality. However, my observations suggest that pornography is just the convenient scapegoat for a society that constantly markets escapism as entertainment and penalizes anything that doesn't involve spending money. All forms of entertainment have been perverted to maximize chemical responses in humans, in order to sell more stuff. Your beef isn't with pornography so much as it is with the present consumerist hellscape, and a society that demands both spouses work full-time to have a chance at survival rather than balance the needs of the family by allowing every couple to have a spouse stay at home and make the house, if they so choose. Which brings me to your next point...

> At some level I see this like sixties versus modern marijuana, where a more mild herb (or dad’s playboys beneath the mattress) has been supplanted by THC distilled and bottled into vapes (endlessly-available presence of any outlandish fetishistic stuff.) I wouldn’t like my child exposed to either but I can live with one.

That's...man, I want to argue this, but I got nothing. You're basically describing what I did up above, with the proper analogy. As a cannabis user myself, you're entirely correct about the potency and convenient availability being an issue, and I'd absolutely like to see more penalties for physical distribution of these things to minors while also de-glamorizing some of this stuff. Sell the product, not the experience, basically.

> Of course, I see it as primarily the parent’s responsibility to inculcate the virtue to disdain both.

That's where we align - the avowed democratic socialist and the conservative Christian agreeing that, at the end of the day, it's the parent's responsibility to parent, and it's the individual's responsibility to make better choices - including seeking help for problems they're having. Where we may disagree on approach, however (I dunno, this is kinda speculating here based on other CC's I know/lived with/attended Church with), is that I believe the steps towards minimizing or eliminating harms is destigmatizing these things in the first place. It means getting over our societal aversion to SEX, a natural biological thing we've been doing as a species for millennia. It means getting over our disdain for addicts, and offering help.

If these ghouls (passing the laws) actually cared about children, families, or humans in general, they'd be supporting rehabilitation instead of penalizing consenting adults. They'd be penalizing exploitative employers and creating a tax structure that rewards stay-at-home partners while enabling every couple to have one such partner.

That's not what's happening, though, and I resent being denigrated as some sort of sick degenerate by a government that won't even feed its fucking kids.

Re:Supreme Court's Ruling Practically Wipes Out Free Speech ... by hooverd on Saturday July 12, 2025 @06:18PM (#44545670)
People need to touch grass instead of blaming everyone else for their failure to do so haha.
Re:Supreme Court's Ruling Practically Wipes Out Free Speech ... by landl0rd on Sunday July 13, 2025 @10:09PM (#44555798)
I'm not sure if that's the intent of everyone backing this; I think part of it amounts to parents who are legitimately worried. I may not agree with their means but I can understand that. I haven't personally met anyone who talked about baptizing the internet but that doesn't mean it isn't happening, and I'd oppose that.

I strongly agree with you on escapism and consumerism. I see pornography as a nasty end-stage manifestation of this, but not as the root issue. I've also seen peers spend way too much time rotting in front of netflix or tiktok or videogames, or addicted to shopping, or spending their money traveling to highly-instagrammable destinations and posting it. I have a huge beef with what you're describing, very true, and consumerist hellscape is a great characterization. Sticking with the drug analogy, I think it's like cocaine vs. fentanyl. It seems like many fewer people can consume is "recreationally" without some level of harm if they do it repeatedly over time. I also tend to key on it more because it so explicitly pertains to what I see as some of the most beautiful and sacred elements of creation (love, sex, marriage). But it's absolutely one manifestation of a greater issue.

I tend to agree with you that "purity culture" is bad and that America has a weirdly-victorian air about it that almost seems to tempt people more. I see alcohol as another example of this; I'd prefer my kids didn't drink until they were older and in the right place/at the right time, but our current set-up just makes most kids get blackout the first half-dozen times they drink.

To be honest, it's still not something I'd be comfortable sitting and discussing personally, but I think there's a difference between "not polite dinner-table conversation" and "God forbid anyone mentions it ever."

I agree with you that lawmakers don't care one whit about children, families, or people. I wish some of my fellow Christians weren't so quick to assume that "their guy" is actually going to fix anything, and see it as a way to disclaim responsibility for working on their own families and communities in particular. I think I've noticed more of this amongst my peer group, a basic distrust of particularly the federal and state governments across the political and ideological spectra. I hope this drives us to focus on fixing what we can. Work on our families rather than calling state assemblymen, work more to feed our homeless rather than expecting the feds to implement a perfect nationwide solution. And I hope rather than politicization, Christianity in America focuses more on the Second Great Commandment, "Love your neighbor as yourself."

Re:Supreme Court's Ruling Practically Wipes Out Free Speech ... by intermerda on Saturday July 12, 2025 @11:28PM (#44547248)
Would you also understand impetus behind any proposed hypothetical ban on alcohol, tobacco, firearms, or anything else that causes harm to the society?
Re:Supreme Court's Ruling Practically Wipes Out Free Speech ... by landl0rd on Sunday July 13, 2025 @09:53PM (#44555709)
Yes, I would. Just like with proposed bans on alcohol, tobacco, and firearms, I understand the motives (particularly when I look at the rash of wife-beating that encouraged the temperance movement, for instance) but oppose the proposed solution (banning those things).
Re:Supreme Court's Ruling Practically Wipes Out Free Speech ... by EasyMark on Sunday July 13, 2025 @03:33AM (#44548280)
If you look at the goals of christofascists this is really just the beginning of incrementally becoming a theocracy run by them rather than a democracy with a diversity of thoughts and freedoms. That is the antithesis of what they want.
Re:Supreme Court's Ruling Practically Wipes Out Free Speech ... by kjkjadksj on Sunday July 13, 2025 @01:03PM (#44551817)
The thing most people misunderstand with weed getting strong is that in the past people would smoke way more. They’d smoke joints like cigarettes. Unless you’ve built up a tolerance you are smoking far less today to get high. And once you’ve built a tolerance that hardly matters too you just smoke more.