Re:NuxtLabs is joining Vercel
by joshdavham on Wednesday July 09, 2025 @09:06AM
(#44509568)
This makes a lot of sense. Thanks for the explanation. I also remember being a bit shocked when I was learning React and was immediately told to use Next.js with it.
Re:NuxtLabs is joining Vercel
by rich_harris on Wednesday July 09, 2025 @07:09PM
(#44515637)
> I have no doubts they'll do the same with Nuxt, demanding they implement features that solely exist to pad out hosting costs while providing next to no actual benefits to end users and devs
has that happened with Svelte?
> they now have a monopoly over the most popular frontend meta frameworks (Next, Svelte/Kit, Nuxt, Astro)
this would be a surprise to the Astro team!
> has that happened with Svelte?
Yes. There are features that have been deliberately kept on the platform level to force you to use the platform instead of implementing it on the framework level or guiding you through it with the docs.
Re:NuxtLabs is joining Vercel
by rich_harris on Thursday July 10, 2025 @07:45AM
(#44519900)
ISR _can't_ be implemented at a framework level without tying the framework to the platform. The fact that we instead chose to implement it via a platform-agnostic adapter API surely demonstrates the opposite of what you're implying
It's platform agnostic but Vercel is the only one that supports it? At least that's in the docs I linked.
This would be true if you also provided an adapter-node, which would work on most traditional servers, and most non-serverless platforms.
The fact that you prioritize the vercel one and not the node native one proves what OP implies in my opinion.
They've been so successful with this in fact, that when you check the actual official React documentation, Next is the offering being advertised prominently [1] (I see they've actually restructured this a bit, a few months ago Next was literally the only thing mentioned here, I assume because of backlash they changed it to what it is now).
I have no doubts they'll do the same with Nuxt, demanding they implement features that solely exist to pad out hosting costs while providing next to no actual benefits to end users and devs, and I have no doubts they'll have the same shenanigans as they do with Next where hosting on anything other than Vercel gives you a broken experience. As an actual Extinguish tactic, I can even see them fully shuttering Nuxt in favor of Next. After all, they now have a monopoly over the most popular frontend meta frameworks (Next, Svelte/Kit, Nuxt, Astro) and paying people to maintain all of that is a lot more expensive than just having the 1 (that already has a huge market share to begin with). Thankfully for now it's MIT and fully OSS, so there's a ray of hope here that even if they pull some shenanigans like that, it'll continue living on independently again, but I don't trust anything that has been touched by VC money as far as I can throw it.
https://react.dev/learn/creating-a-react-app