Re:July 5, 1687: When Newton Explained Why You Don't Float Away
by mensetmanusman on Sunday July 06, 2025 @08:59AM
(#44480444)
People today are confused by the word spirit because the word fields quietly replaced it, and they are just as mysterious because we don’t know if they are real.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:July 5, 1687: When Newton Explained Why You Don't Float Away
by ahazred8ta on Sunday July 06, 2025 @12:04PM
(#44481888)
At the time, 'spirit' was used to mean 'low-viscosity fluid' and 'vapor'. Alcohol and various distilled fluids were called spirits. He didn't necessarily mean 'intangible'.
Re:July 5, 1687: When Newton Explained Why You Don't Float Away
by gavmor on Sunday July 06, 2025 @11:19AM
(#44481470)
"Field" is a less mysterious term because it's not polysemous with a supernatural being (ghost) or a distilled alcoholic beverage (soluble liquid).
Sure, it's polysemous with "a cultivated expanse of land", but AFAIK there is no popular, problematic pseudoscientific quackery about suggesting our bodies possess rows of oats.
Re:July 5, 1687: When Newton Explained Why You Don't Float Away
by mensetmanusman on Sunday July 06, 2025 @03:26PM
(#44483283)
Fields give breath to the math that perfectly describes reality but which isn’t found anywhere in reality. Kind of mysterious:)
Re:July 5, 1687: When Newton Explained Why You Don't Float Away
by gavmor on Sunday July 06, 2025 @06:30PM
(#44484704)
> Wenn wir das Wesen des Baumes suchen, müssen wir gewahr
werden, daß jenes, was jeden Baum als Baum durch waltet, nicht
selber ein Baum ist, der sich zwischen den übrigen Bäumen antreffen läßt.
— Martin Heidegger, Die Frage Nach Der Technik