News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Canadian's AI hoax duped the media and propelled a 'ban... by Animats on Saturday July 05, 2025 @11:38PM (#44477628)
Nobody seems to be complaining that it's bad music. What's the problem?
Re:A Canadian's AI hoax duped the media and propelled a 'ban... by viraptor on Sunday July 06, 2025 @12:05AM (#44477737)
It is bad though. The tone is really similar on all the tracks, the solos are closer to guitar noodling, the structure is extremely predictable, etc. Ok, maybe not strictly bad - but definitely not good. Like, I'm not good and I feel like I could write a lot of similar stuff given enough effort and trying to sample bits of Led Zeppelin, Omega and others.
Re:A Canadian's AI hoax duped the media and propelled a 'ban... by RealStickman_ on Sunday July 06, 2025 @02:31AM (#44478338)
If you're knowledgeable enough in music theory most songs are predictable.
Re:A Canadian's AI hoax duped the media and propelled a 'ban... by viraptor on Sunday July 06, 2025 @04:40AM (#44478930)
There's "understood within the commonly used systems" predictable and there's "boring simple and repetitive" predictable. This band is both.
Re:A Canadian's AI hoax duped the media and propelled a 'ban... by amanaplanacanal on Sunday July 06, 2025 @05:32AM (#44479166)
A lot of popular music is boring simple and repetitive, though.
Re:A Canadian's AI hoax duped the media and propelled a 'ban... by adastra22 on Saturday July 05, 2025 @11:51PM (#44477677)
We’ve had engineered hits from committees dominating pop music for decades now. This doesn’t seem any less authentic, and apparently people like it.

Really, what’s the difference between this and virtual bands like Gorillaz?

Re:A Canadian's AI hoax duped the media and propelled a 'ban... by viraptor on Sunday July 06, 2025 @12:15AM (#44477791)
Have you actually listened to this band and to Gorillaz? There's really no comparison: velvet sunset is just boring - there's nothing there, there. There's no interesting motifs or story telling.

> and apparently people like it.

That remains to be seen. The early plays were bought to get the recommendations. We really don't know how many people listened to this yet.

Re:A Canadian's AI hoax duped the media and propelled a 'ban... by Supermancho on Sunday July 06, 2025 @12:54AM (#44477949)
> Have you actually listened to this band and to Gorillaz? There's really no comparison

The comparison is that they are both fictional bands. The received popularity of the music is irrelevant.

Did you not understand the point of the GP?

Re:A Canadian's AI hoax duped the media and propelled a 'ban... by viraptor on Sunday July 06, 2025 @01:33AM (#44478103)
Gorillaz is not a fictional band. Having cartoon characters doesn't make it fictional. We know who their creators are. Neither does Daft Punk become fictional when they put on the helmets.

(No, I didn't get what comparison was being made. It's so different I didn't realise anyone would do that)

Re:A Canadian's AI hoax duped the media and propelled a 'ban... by Supermancho on Sunday July 06, 2025 @02:41AM (#44478384)
What you consider fictional and anyone else considers fictional doesn't have to align. The point was clear, when interpreted in good faith. I understand you disagree, but that doesn't change what I think about the nature of persona.
Re:A Canadian's AI hoax duped the media and propelled a 'ban... by dmamills on Sunday July 06, 2025 @01:24AM (#44478066)
The Gorillaz are actually real people though? You do realize The Archies didn't write "Sugar, Sugar"?
Re:A Canadian's AI hoax duped the media and propelled a 'ban... by Macha on Sunday July 06, 2025 @07:10AM (#44479671)
Gorillaz (and e.g. vtubers) are effectively real people performing in digitally generated costumes. Especially Gorillaz, where it's not a secret who's behind it. This is closer to e.g. lip-syncing or vocaloids, though even they have more human input in the original composition.
Re:A Canadian's AI hoax duped the media and propelled a 'ban... by otrack on Sunday July 06, 2025 @12:04AM (#44477728)
So true.
Re:A Canadian's AI hoax duped the media and propelled a 'ban... by tgv on Sunday July 06, 2025 @03:21AM (#44478569)
So I copy someone's music, publish it under my name, and then say "Nobody seems to be complaining that it's bad music. What's the problem?"

First, people listen to absolute garbage. General taste is not a standard. Second, the quality of the music doesn't make other problems magically disappear. This music is built on enormous amounts of other people's music, and at the same time threatens to almost completely undermine music making, from amateur to megastar. That's a problem.

Re:A Canadian's AI hoax duped the media and propelled a 'ban... by deterministic on Tuesday July 08, 2025 @12:12AM (#44497019)
Whether music is good or bad is highly subjective. There is a high chance that I would find music you like to be crap and vise versa.