Re:Stop Hiding My Controls: Hidden Interface Controls Are Af...
by IggleSniggle on Saturday July 05, 2025 @09:36PM
(#44477052)
Right! If you want it to denote an action, you need to include the verb: "TURN ON" would be entirely clear. It's even clear if you sometimes DO want to show state / not a button "IS ON" is also perfectly clear. There's only a few that might he confused when the verb is shown, like "INCREASE," although I would have to work a little to imagine the UI where it's not clear whether the button is showing the verb or noun.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Stop Hiding My Controls: Hidden Interface Controls Are Af...
by TylerE on Saturday July 05, 2025 @09:48PM
(#44477111)
One of my big beefs with modern UI is two-state controls where it's impossible to determine what the current state actually is. Like a button that says "Music Off" where it's unclear if that means the music is CURRENTLY off, or if clicking the button turns it off.
Re:Stop Hiding My Controls: Hidden Interface Controls Are Af...
by jagged-chisel on Saturday July 05, 2025 @11:35PM
(#44477617)
Similarly, I can’t tell which state the control is in until I touch it.
Re:Stop Hiding My Controls: Hidden Interface Controls Are Af...
by khaki54 on Sunday July 06, 2025 @01:53AM
(#44478168)
Yep the best example. Especially if the result is not immediately obvious. Am I commanding "system on" or are you telling me "system on"
Re:Stop Hiding My Controls: Hidden Interface Controls Are Af...
by foo42 on Sunday July 06, 2025 @03:00AM
(#44478467)
you can get the same issue with icons too. The one that gives me anxiety is the microphone with a line through on a button. I _am_ muted or I should click to _mute_. If my kids are arguing in the background and it's an important call it can feel like a high stakes thing to get wrong and often times it only becomes clear what state I'm in by toggling a few times. Does the icon change to a mic without a line when I click or does the previously shown mic with a line now get coloured in, what does _that_ mean?
Re:Stop Hiding My Controls: Hidden Interface Controls Are Af...
by SpaceNoodled on Sunday July 06, 2025 @04:15AM
(#44478798)
And even WORSE are the services that use different variations on those depending on the platform you're using! Yes, I am looking directly at you, Amazon Chime.
Re:Stop Hiding My Controls: Hidden Interface Controls Are Af...
by schlarpc on Sunday July 06, 2025 @04:20AM
(#44478829)
And thankfully you won’t be looking at it much longer
Re:Stop Hiding My Controls: Hidden Interface Controls Are Af...
by SpaceNoodled on Sunday July 06, 2025 @11:11AM
(#44481403)
What do you know?
Re:Stop Hiding My Controls: Hidden Interface Controls Are Af...
by IggleSniggle on Sunday July 06, 2025 @10:30PM
(#44486188)
Surely this one is near universal. At the very least a clarifying tooltip of the verb would be helpful!