But software development is about producing written artifacts. We actually need the result. We care a lot less about whether or not the developer has a particular understanding of the world. A cursor-written implementation of a login form is of use to a senior engineer because she actually wants a login form.
We actually should because the developer has to maintain and extend the damned thing in the future
1. The invention of THE CONCEPT BEHIND THE MACHINE. In our context, this is "Programming as Theory Building." Our programs represent some conception of the world that is NOT identical to the source code, much the way early precision tools embodied philosophies like interchangeability.
2. The building of the machine itself, which has to function correctly. To your point, this is one of the major things we care about, but I don't agree it's the only thing. In the code world this IS the code, to your point. When this is all we think about, though, I think you get spaghetti code bases and poorly trained developers.
3. Training apprentices in both the ideas and the craft of producing machines.
You can argue we should only care about #2, many businesses certainly incentivize thinking in that direction, but I think all 3 are important. Part of what makes coding and talking about coding tricky is that written artifacts, even the same written artifacts, express all 3 of these things and so matters get very easily confused.
There’s a reason no one does it. Because it’s inefficient. Even in recorded video format. The helpful things are tests and descriptives PRs. The former because its structure is simple enough that you can judge it, and the test run can be part of the commit. The second is for the simple fact that if you can write clearly about your solution, I can the just do a diff of what you told me and what the code is doing, which is way faster than me trying to divine both from the code.
Leetcode Zoom calls always were marginal, now with chat AI they're virtually useless though still the norm.
I claim that this approach is sustainable.
The idea behind the "I read all of your code and give feedback." methodology is that the writer really put a lot of deep effort into making sure that the code is of great quality - and then he is expecting feedback, which is often valuable. As long as you can with some effort find out by yourself how improvements could be done, don't bother asking for someone else's time/
The problem is thus that the writers of "vibe-generated code" hardly ever put such a deep effort into the code. Thus the code is simply not worth asking feedback for.
AI creates the same problem for hiring too: it generates the appearance of knowledge. The problem you and I have as evaluators of that knowledge is there is no other interface to knowledge than language. In a way this is like the oldest philosophy problem in existence. Socrates spent an inordinate amount of time railing against the sophists, people concerned with language and argument rather than truth. We have his same problem, only now on an industrial scale.
To your point about tests, I think the answer is to not focus on automated tests at first (though of course you should have those eventually), but instead we should ask people to actually run the code while they explain it to show it working. That's a much better test: show me how it works, and explain it to me.